Discussion in 'Civ - Ideas & Suggestions' started by Xandinho, Jun 26, 2019.
Ashanti - 1
Navajo - 15 (18-3) Top 3 is good enough.
Tibet - 16 (15+1) Should be #1 IMHO.
Ashanti - 0 (1-3) ELIMINATED They certainly could make an interesting civ in a continent which needs more Civs. However for me Benin remain the better option.
Navajo - 15
Tibet - 17 (16+1) Its tough competition here, but for me they remain the best choice to finish first. They check several boxes including being historically a regional power, having a significant cultural/religious legacy, and being in an area of the world currently unrepresented in Civ.
Ow, that's the second time in a row where I wasn't on the forum for a bit and promptly missed the start of the most hectic part of the voting on an elimination thread.
Navajo - 15
Tibet - 14 (17-3) Indeed it is tough competition. This is the one I'm least interested in. That's really all I have to say - I wouldn't oppose its inclusion in Civ even though we all know it's probably not gonna happen due to politics. I also think it'd be kind of lame to have the winner of an elimination thread be a civ that won't ever be in the game, but that's not why I'm downvoting this one haha
Vietnam 18 (17+1) I understand the whole SEA-doesn't-really-need-more-civs-right-now thing, especially as I've been using region-filling as an argument for my past votes on this thread, but Vietnam still just intrigues me. The devs want to include female leaders? Well, they can do TWO in one fell swoop, by adding the Trung Sisters! Then have water puppetry in some form, maybe some agriculture-related bonuses, and defensive capabilities, and they'd be set. A cultural civ that emphasizes tall, defensive play is always fun.
Navajo - 16 (15 + 1) Lets get some desert farms and hogans. Wow, that was a pretty short upvote from me!
Tibet - 11 (14 - 3) Its just the one I find the least interesting among these 3. I could definitely change my mind if I hear some good gameplay designs from them.
Vietnam 18 I'll just mention that even IF they don't go for 2 leaders in 1 with both Trung Sisters, Trac Trung would be the leader and Nhi Trung could be a unique governor a la Ibrahim of the Ottomans.
Navajo - 13 (16 - 3) The least interesting
Tibet - 12 (11 + 1) Again a long and fascinating history which has changed the political climate of the country greatly
Navajo - 13
Tibet - 13 (12+1) Definitely my top pick of these 3.
Vietnam - 15 (18-3) Evening out the score.
Navajo - 10(13-3) least interesting from me out of three
Tibet - 14(13+1) this mountainous civ will fill the massive gap between Delhi and Beijing.Indosphere requires more representation in the game,unfortunately whole Indosphere is viewed from very narrow mindset.
Vietnam - 15
Navajo - 10+1=11 We need a U.S tribe. I'd prefer more if we had the room.
Tibet - 14-3=11 I just want the others more and also I don't feel like it would be included for political reasons..
Vietnam - 15
Navajo - 12 = 11+1 Agreed that NA representation is really poor. Would be god to fix that.
Tibet - 11 These are never going to appear but even though culturally they are very different, I expect Firaxis could swap their game mechanics for another himalayan civ like Nepal or Bhutan so I'm kind of interpreting them in that light.
Vietnam - 12 (15-3) Riae and Fall would have been the place for them. There are enough 'valiant resistance' civs in the game already
Navajo - 9 (12-3) After invade Pueblo land, Navajo turned slowly on a defensive civ.
Tibet - 11 If Tibet is a political problem, I hope they chose Bhutan over Nepal because Bhutan is culturally closer to Tibet.
Vietnam - 13 (12+1) Vietnam is not only defensive, if not ask Champa or Cambodia.
I found funny that this 3 civs share some characteristics, like start offensive and end defensive, or how Navajo are "Pueblo plan B" and Tibet would probably need a "Bhutan plan B".
Navajo - 9
Tibet - 8 (11-3) Buthan and Nepal would also be a bit controversial and we are talking only about Tibet here. We all would love to see tem, but we all also know that we won't.
Vietnam - 14 (13+1) Not that I don't want Navajo, but Vietnam seems way... more interesting.
Navajo - 9 +1=10. My top choice of those remaining.
Tibet - 8 -3=5. Not a great fan of religious civs in Civ VI.
Vietnam - 14
Navajo - 10
Tibet - 2 (5-3) China is a huge market for games and everyone wants in there. How do we think the Chinese government will react to Tibet becoming a playable Civ that can defeat a Chinese leader in-game? Never mind that historically Tibet was a powerhouse in the medieval age; we have to be realistic here.
Vietnam - 15 (14+1) A region deserving to be known for more than the famous war the US engaged in there, and doesn’t quite carry the controversy Tibet definitely would.
Navajo - 7 (10-3) I'm not as interested in this as Vietnam and Tibet.
Tibet - 2
Vietnam - 16 (15+1) This may have an interesting and unique mechanics.
Navajo - 8 (7+1) The most interesting and fills in a large gap in the map, I've already stated my reasons why I want this civ.
Tibet - 2
Vietnam - 13 (16-3) Not the most interesting civ IMO, and personally i feel like there are better and possibly more unique defensive civs compared to Vietnam.
Navajo - 8
Tibet - 3 (2+1) Looks like they are next to be eliminated, but they are still my favorites, to hell with politics!
Vietnam - 10 (13-3) They are good, but in my opinion, Civ 6 needs the other 2 civs more.
Navajo - 5 (8-3) Among the last 3 my least favored
Tibet - 4 (3+1) Among the last 3 my most favored
Vietnam - 10
But we really don't need to be realistic. This thread is purely about what we'd like to see.
Navajo - 6 (5 + 1) Brings far more cultural variety to the roster than any other remaining option.
Tibet - 4
Vietnam - 7 (10 - 3) Definitely a strong option, but not above Navajo or Tibet.
Navajo - 3 (6-3) Navaho code would be great for some espionage theme, hogans could be cool ancient burst to whatever devs would want this civ to revolve around but still in this competition i think they should go down next.
Tibet - 5 (4+1) China wouldnt like this is the lamest of excuses, this is about this civ, and it would be superfun, having some sort of elite warrior monk UU, maybe it could be the only civ to settle on mountains(roof of the world theme) while others could only pass through them(with losses like in the Civ V with Carthage) and try to be quick with taking Tibet cities. Last time i voted for Vietnam but i wanted to give this great civilization a burst.
Vietnam - 7
Navajo - 0 (3-3) ELIMINATED I don't find them as compelling as the other two options.
Tibet - 6 (5+1) My favorite out of what remains, and the whims of a tyrannical state won't discourage me from saying so.
Vietnam - 7
Separate names with a comma.