kryszcztov said:
Jass's long post is a must-read for everyone who doesn't know much about France (ie. almost everyone here
), and that was a fair summary for me as well. I on the whole agree with everything he wrote.
eyrei said:
Could someone answer my question? I'm really pretty curious...
Well, I'm scratching my heads about these two parts, to be frank.
I'm a bit of a naive airhead when it comes to such things, and I've never lived in harsh suburbs like these we talk about here. And though I did encounter a fair share of non-white people, most of my friends are still rather like me.
All in all, I mean that what I'll say next is only my own, personnal experience, and part of the experience of the few arabs and black people I know, and that it's a very specific and particular picture, and may very well be wrong.
And this experience makes me scratch my head when hearing all about these "repressive police", "rampant racism" and the like. I'm quite white, so it's no surprise here that police always left me alone. I've had my papers checked only a handful of times in my life, all when I was driving and it was probably routine control. No surprise here.
I've never, ever, ever, witnessed a blatant racist act in my life. Be it a spoken word or act. Never. The worst I've ever noticed was the kind of "well, when you see the names of the criminals, they're more often than not 'Mohammed' and the like, he ?". This was clearly hiding some racism, but somehow mild.
For a country which is supposedly so racist, I must have a knack for avoiding the FN voters.
Same for the police. I've never witnessed any "harassment" from the police. Of course, I try to precisely AVOID the suburbs where the police supposedly harass these people, so... I've a few friends from there, though. They never told me anything about police bothering them, despite being arabs and blacks themselves.
But anyway, we were NEVER annoyed (or even talked to) by a policeman when I hanged with them.
I don't want to say there isn't racism (I know there is, I'm just lucky to have only witenessed very tame expression of it) nor that there is absolutely no police harassment (I simply don't know enough on the subject).
But what I KNOW too, is that in the day-to-day live, the group of young kids with the typical "banlieue" style are the one constantly annoying people and looking for trouble, not the cops.
One thing to understand, is that these "banlieues" ("banlieues" => suburbs, often used to describe precisely the poor ones with lots of immigrants) have a very specific "subculture", with common behavioural and clothing codes.
And though, of course, not all (and even most) of the people living here doesn't bother anybody, the reality is that, when you're being attacked/agressed/annoyed/disrespected by someone, it's easily 80 % of the time (probably more) by someone from here.
If being segregated against, if having no hope, if being massively unemployed, if being harrassed by the police, is certainly no fun and can understandably lead to anger, frustration, resentment and failed integration, it's also understandable that when 90 % of the problems comes from a very recognizable and loud minority, for tens of years, people finally lose patience and ask for repression against them, and becomes prejudiciated against them.
In fact, you'll find very few defenders of these "racailles" ("rabble", which is the own word of the banlieue's typical speech for describing the people causing trouble, and is often used as in a semi-glorious title), even inside the very districts where they're from. I've some friends from the 92 and 94 (two of the most agitated departements), and they have for these "racailles" a dislike confining to hatred.
What is actually telling, is that while actually two of them are Arabs, and one is Black, they were themselves the ones talking about how it's "always the same kind of people who cause troubles".
Themselves had no particular problems with the police either, AFAIK.
So, is this "harassment" really a "racial" thing, targetted at arabs and blacks, or is it rather a "behavioural" thing, targetted at the typical troublemakers, which are detected not just because of their skin colour, but even more because of their typical banlieue-like codes ?