Polish atrocities before the war?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tank_Guy#3

Lion of Lehistan
Joined
May 11, 2004
Messages
5,918
Location
Vivat Sobieski!
I was talking recently with an acquaintance of mine at a World War II reenactment, and we got on the subject of "how we would have run the war". After about a half hour it devolved into somewhat of an argument about the start of the war.

I personally tend to be a bit more pro-Poland, being about 3/4 Polish ethnicity, but he is almost blindly pro-German. He insisted that there were Polish atrocities committed against ethnic Germans in areas of Poland acquired after the Armistice. Something along the lines of thousands killed in the months leading up to World War II. I have just spent the last hour or so researching and can only find things about "Operation Himmler" and events that took place after the German invasion.

I instantly called BS, but I am still curious if there was anybody here with that might know if some of these "facts" he stated are based on truth. I am specifically looking for events PRIOR to the start of the war (September 1, 1939).
 
While I don't have anything direct to say about the ethnic Germans, I do know Poland was quite a racist country in the 1930s, having enacted Anti-Semitic laws similar to Nazi Germany (and yes, this was the same Poland that was attacked by the Nazis and supported by the Allies).

So I wouldn't be surprised that Poland might have done similar campaign against other ethnic minorities.
 
Your buddys statements are bunch of lies. Poland at the time wasnt democratic but Nazis actually had to stage up some atrocity so there would be at least seemingly just cause for them starting the war.
 
I doubt if there was any sort of large-scale massacres of German minorities in Poland pre invasion. If there were any so-called "massacres," I think they probably were limited to handfuls of small groups of Teutophobes who attacked German minorities in back alleys or in the streets. I've heard that Hitler apologists and other sorts of repulsive Nazi lovers point to something called the "Bromberg Massacre." I have yet to find any non-propaganda credible source on said massacre.
 
The Polish government went out of its way to treat ethnic Germans well, actually, so as to avoid providing Hitler with a pretext for war. Polish citizens would sometimes whip up a pogrom against the ethnic Germans in Poland, but even that was fairly rare. Most of the claims of massacres in Poland are fabrications.
 
It reminds one of the equally 'real' belgian atrocities against germans in the ww1 timeline, which of course were the reason for the invasion of inhumane scum Belgium by noble human-rights FREEDOM Germany ;)
 
Actori incumbit probati - I don't know about the existence of any proofs for such atrocities, commited before the war.

After the war there was armed German (as well as pro-Nazi Ukrainian) sabotage activity taking place in rear area of the Polish front.

As the result of that sabotage, many Germans were executed on the basis of accusation of either being the saboteurs or helping the saboteurs.

Most of those executions were carried out legally, on the basis of legally valid sentences pronounced by wartime court-martials.

However - as it usually happens in the heat of such events and during wartime chaos - there were also some extrajudicial executions.

I've heard that Hitler apologists and other sorts of repulsive Nazi lovers point to something called the "Bromberg Massacre."

Bydgoszcz events took place during the war - on 03.09.1939 and 04.09.1939 - not before the war. These events were distorted by Nazi propaganda - for example by an English-language pamphlet published by "Volk und Reich Verlag" publishing house in Berlin in 1940, which called it "Bromberger Blutsonntag" ("Bromberg Bloody Sunday"). According to Polish sources, events in Bydgoszcz were started by armed German saboteurs, who opened fire to Polish troops.

Bydgoszcz on 03.09.1939 was a city located just behind the German-Polish frontline - in the immediate rear area of Polish combat units.

Sabotage action was aimed at disorganizing Polish defence and causing chaos and confusion in the immediate rear area of Polish frontline.

Here is the situation along the frontline on that day - we can see units of German 50. Infanterie Division (50 DP) and 3. Infanterie Division (3 DP) attacking, while units of Polish 15. Infantry Division (15 DP) were defending positions around the city (so called "Bydgoszcz Bridgehead"):

file.php


And this map shows places (black points) where saboteurs opened fire to Polish troops (firing from windows and roofs of houses, etc.):

Activity of German armed sabotage was concentrated along the most important communication arteries - main roads:

file.php


=====================================

Here you can read the English summary of the book by Dr Tomasz Chincinski titled (in English translation): "Hitler's Outpost. German Sabotage in Poland in 1939", Gdansk-Warsaw 2010, translated by Ms Maja Latynska. Dr Chincinski says it contains the key findings of his research:

Spoiler :
file.php


file.php


file.php


file.php


file.php


file.php


file.php


file.php


file.php



There is also a German book debunking the Nazi propaganda myth of the "Bromberger Blutsonntag".

This book is "Das Unternehmen Bromberger Blutsonntag. Tod einer Legende" written by Günter Schubert.
 
1) The treatment of Germans in interwar Poland wasn't good. I am not talking about daily massacres or some such Nazi propaganda, but they were systematically being repressed as a minority which was sees as being hostile to the Polish state (which they often were). The position of Germans in Poland was actually a lot worse than that of ethnic Germans in Czechoslovakia.

2) However, one has to realize that Nazi Germany would have found even the slightest trouble to be a sufficient excuse for aggression. When you read about how Goebbels' propaganda machine totally twisted the reality and persuaded half of Europe that the evil Czechs were massacring the poor innocent Sudeten Germans with poison gas and whatnot, when in fact at that very time Sudeten Germans enjoyed far greater civil liberties than the Germans living in the Reich itself, you realize one thing. Even if Poland's Germans were treated with nothing but kindness, the Nazis would have found a way to construe it as an excuse for invasion. In reality they didn't give a DAMN about the German minorities abroad, they were just pawns in their aggressive, expansionist game.

So, next time you see that friend of yours, I guess you can greet him with a right hand salute and "Sieg Heil!", because he's one of those who still believe in Goebbels' lies 70 years after the war ended. There's plenty of such people, unfortunately.
 
Winner said:
1) The treatment of Germans in interwar Poland wasn't good.

(...)

The position of Germans in Poland was actually a lot worse than that of ethnic Germans in Czechoslovakia.

I would like to see some hard proofs for these statements, rather than empty slogans.

Can you provide some evidences and examples of alleged "harsh treatment"?

Also - it should be underlined - that German minority in Poland included many Nazi supporters, a fact that was even proudly admitted by themselves.

For example a member of the German minority in Poland - Ferdinand Lang - in his "Denkschrift an Herrn Reichsmarschall Hermann Göring", published in Bydgoszcz (Bromberg) on 01.05.1940, wrote:

"(...) A front of unity against the Polish state was formed in Bromberg. In 1935 in Bromberg a memorial to the then Polish prime minister Slawek was drawn up, in which it was clearly stated, that we - Germans in Poland - stand on the ground of the National-Socialist worldview and that we will fight with all available legal means for spiritual assimilation with the worldview of the Fatherland of our origin. (...)"

And here some excerpts about Nazi-sympathising organizations in the area of Bromberg, from a report by local Polish authorities dated 1937:

700 of local ethnic German minority members from the area of Bydgoszcz belonged to Jungdeutsche Partei as of 1937.

Polish authorities reported the following about the ideology of members of Jungdeutsche Partei:

"(...) Jungdeutsche Partei consists of combative element, full of enthusiasm, active, aggressive, sincerely professing Adolf Hitler's slogans and believing in possibility of their implementation in practice. (...)"

Further 480 of ethnic German locals, were members of - illegal in Poland - Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei:

"(...) This party, consisting in Bydgoszcz and in the Bydgoszcz periphery of 480 members, apart from propaganda work, full of radically nationalistic spirit, is expanding the net of influences especially in organizations and in business firms, sending its agents there. Activity of this party is secretive and utterly hostile to the Polish state. (...)"

Pro-Nazi organizations had strong support of local Evangelical Church in Poland - one of members of the local "department" of Deutsche Vereinigung in Bydgoszcz, was Julius Assmann (1868 - 1939) - who was at the same time the director (superintendent in Polish - not sure about translation) of the evangelical church. And one of members of a board of the local DV in Bydgoszcz - Otton Niefeldt - was an agent of Abwehrstelle in Stettin (Abwehr = German Intelligence Service). Deutsche Vereinigung (DV) had many more influential members with pro-Nazi connections.

Report by Polish authorities regarding the attitudes of local German minority citizens towards their Polish neighbours after 1934:

"(...) Germans more and more often underline their affiliation to the Reich, they do not try to hide their contemptuous attitude towards Poles, they demonstratively use German language and Nazi salutations. Especially German youth, who are encompassed by German organizations, pastors and teachers with special care, being educated by them for nationalists and enemies of the [Polish] state, behave like this."
 
As I wrote aboute, apart from German sabotage there was also Ukrainian pro-Nazi armed sabotage (so called "Fifth Column") in Poland.

They were recruited from Ukrainian national chauvinists in East Galicia (Western Ukraine).

Here is an excerpt from an original German Abwehr document about saboteurs from Kampf-Organisation Ost-Galizien:

As you can see below, Abwehr estimated, that KO "Ost-Galizien" was capable of mobilizing 12,000 - 15,000 action-ready saboteurs:

szefer.jpg


Similar sabotage units existed in Western Poland, where German national chauvinists and Nazi supporters were recruited to those units.

Not all members of sabotage units were actual citizens of Poland - many of them (especially commanders) were "tourists" smuggled from Germany.
 
Question: Does the OP's friend run around as a Nazi?
 
Domen said:
where German national chauvinists and Nazi supporters were recruited to those units.

And not only them - also some ethnic Polish traitors were recruited by German Abwehr.

For example Captain of the Polish Army Witalis Wieder - who was chief of the Association of Reserve Officers of the Polish army - was an agent of Abwher. Also one of pre-war officers of the Polish Counter-Intelligence Service (Unit 2 of the General Staff of the Polish Army) whose surname was Starykon was a German agent.

Other German agents were for example Leon Adamczyk from the Command of the Border Guard (Straż Graniczna), Lieutenant Wybocki from the Command of Corps District (DOK) No. VIII Torun (Thorn).

Another German agent was for example this guy:

Major Władysław Boczoń - pseudonym "Panther" - in 1939 chief of officer outpost in Poznan, one of officers of the Polish Counter-Intelligence Service, in September he was a liaison officer responsible for communication between Armies "Poznan" and "Lodz" (I don't have to add that he didn't perform his task very well...). Also for example Major Haraszymowicz and an ethnic Ukrainian guy - Major Diaczenko - were German agents in ranks of the Polish Army.

After the war in Communist Poland there were 276 trials for pre-war collaboration with Abwehr. Leon Adamczyk was sentenced to death and executed. So was Starykon from Counter-Intelligence Service. Witalis Wieder was sentenced to death as well but he escaped from Poland in January 1945.

Major Haraszymowicz was executed by Polish Underground resistance movement already during the war.

German Intelligence Service also infiltrated with at least one spy into the structures of the Polish Army's High Command during September 1939.

That spy was an officer of Abwehr, who pretended to be a civilian clerk, Mayor of Siemianowice Slaskie, escaping from the Germans - he joined the motorized column of the High Command during its withdrawal from Warsaw to Brest-Litovsk. There was a working radio station in his car.

Polish military code / cipher was also captured by Germans - so they could read Polish encoded reports.

=========================================

As the result of that sabotage, many Germans were executed on the basis of accusation of either being the saboteurs or helping the saboteurs.

Most of those executions were carried out legally, on the basis of legally valid sentences pronounced by wartime court-martials.

However - as it usually happens in the heat of such events and during wartime chaos - there were also some extrajudicial executions.

Below several episodes illustrating such executions:

In first days of September 1939, Polish army discovered a secret radio station in Nowa Wies Krolewska (Königlich Neudorf). This radio station was operated by three Germans from Nowa Wies Krolewska and one German from Biechowo (17 - 66 years old) as well as one ethnic Pole from Nowa Wies Krolewska (17 years old). They were sentenced by the Martial Court to death and were executed in Krzywagora in the afternoon of 6 September 1939 (together with three men aged 19 - 22, inhabitants of the Jarocin County).

As we can see not only ethnic Germans but also ethnic Poles ditto suffered consequences of their illegal actions. There was no "special treatment" depending on ethnicity of perpetrators.

A similar episode took place in Gorazdowo, where local Germans were using radio stations to inform about units of the Polish army stationing there (as the result positions of those units were attacked by Luftwaffe). These saboteurs were escorted to Września and imprisoned there.

A similar situation, but on a larger scale, also took place in Sokolniki (Hamlet Sockelstein), where local Poles interned 41 local Germans (only men - between 15 and 73 years old) and intended to escort them to the nearest police station in Strzalkowo and then to Slupca. However, it turned out that police stations were no longer functioning (due to evacuation of police to the east) and in Sompolno (Deutschen Eck) Germans were handed over to the encountered Polish Army unit, which executed them as saboteurs. On 7 September 1939 these Germans of Sokolniki were buried in the evangelical cemetery in Sompolno, but later (in November) their remnants were exhumated to Sokolniki.

In the night from 4 to 5 September Polish soldiers arrested - on charge of sabotage - 15 Germans from Sobiesiernie (men and women between 19 and 67 years old) and on 5 September at 18:00 executed all of them on the field between Sobiesiernie and Grzybowo (one of these Germans survived the execution).

All these episodes took place during the war, not before the war.

I don't know even a single example of such execution before the war.

Many Germans suspected by Polish Counter-Intelligence Service or by Police of being agents or saboteurs employed by Abwehr (III Reich's Intelligence Service), were arrested before the war, during the Summer of 1939. In most cases there were no mistakes commited by Polish Counter-Intelligence, and those arrested Germans really were Abwehr agents. However, they were not executed - they were only imprisoned or interned in Eastern Poland.

About the internment of dangerous German activists before the war - below several examples of such actions:

Excerpts from initial chapters of the book "Battle of Mlawa 1939" by Ryszard Juszkiewicz:

This refers to the "Cold War" between Poland and Germany, which was taking place in the Summer of 1939, before the real invasion started:

Sorry if quality of translation is not the best:

From page 16 of the book:

"[...] German staffs were also trying to cause psychosis of fear, uncertainty and disbelief in Polish Armed Forces also with use of non military means. Among them broadcasts of German radio in Konigsberg. They were saying in these broadcasts about "shortage of casual men in Poland", about "possibility of finding a well-paid job in Germany", to encourage people to escape to Germany. However, it is characteristic that although economic situation in the borderland in 1939 did not improve, only not numerous escaped to East Prussia. [...] Germans were disappointed because they calculated that because of the propaganda thousands of men would escape, in this way weakening the strength of the Polish Army. Attempt failed. Due to the Sentence of the Regional Court in Mława for an attempt of organizing illegal overruns of the border in 1939 the following people were sentenced: Emma Bergeisten, Rudolf and Marta Weissens, Reingold Elgert, Alfred and Freda Scheins and Franciszek and Józef Szpejewskis.

If there were any escapes to the Reich, they were only carried out by ethnic German minority members living in Northern Mazovia. For example from Iłów - to avoid recruitment to the Polish Army - two sons of Wilhelm Sowa, two members of Prejs family and two Radzanowski brothers escaped to Prussia. Escapes of Poles from the border poviats of this region were not recorded. [...]"

Page 17:

"[...] Another mean, which was to cause atmosphere of uncertainty and disorganize the political life, were messages spread by the German secret service, saying that peasants should not work in their fields, because it is a vain effort in the face of imminent war. German agents were gathering and buying Polish coins. Limited amount of coins in circulations was causing among some people willingness to tesaurisate silver and nickel coins as these - according to commonly spread gossips - would retain their value during the war.

Also behaviour of Germans living in Poland changed. They became even more arrogant and provocative. Local press was saying about numerous indictments to the Polish courts from Polish civilians, about insults and abuses of impudent Germans - informed about imminent war - towards ethnic Poles. [...]"

Pages 25 - 27:

"[...] To protect the resources of the future frontline in the end of August few hundreds of the most active Germans were displaced from Northern Mazovia to the central parts of the country.

In the last few hours before the war many German agents were arrested - thanks to that assembled for a long time intelligence agencies and sabotage networks in several poviats / counties were disorganized.

Another serious success of the local "dwójka" ["dwójka" = Section II of the Main Headquarters = Polish counterintelligence] was "cracking" the activity of Edward Lenc, inhabitant of Mława. His occupation was surveyor and due to this he could freely go anywhere he wanted outside Mława and he was gathering spy information. Moreover together with Brunon Hirsz, occupation - teacher, he was officially working as director of the local PCK in Mława and... was directing the V Column of the local ethnic Germans, number of which in the Mława poviat yet before the war was around 850. "New Mławska Newspaper" from 16.04.1939 in article titled "Germans in the mławski poviat" was saying, that German colonists were living mainly near the locality Szreńsk. In village Stołowo only Germans were living. In village Ostrów there were 60% Germans, in Rochnia - 50%, in Wola Proszkowska - 40%, and three German families in Proszkowo. Two young Krugers were the go-between of the German colony and the Reich.

The whole German colony was fully benefiting from the civil rights of the citizens of the Polish state. It had got its own school with German language of instruction and its own prayer house. Polish authorities did not use any harassments towards the German minority. On the eve of the war only several dangerously active Germans were displaced - on the strength of the decision of administration authorities - from the Mława poviat to the łukowski poviat - for example Brunon Hirsz and owner of the brickyard - Karol Baran.

Edward Lenc was detained for the first time on the border in the beginning of August of 1939. He was soon released, but he was being carefully surveillanced since that time. Lenc, convinced of the incompetence of the Polish secret service, very quickly provided convincing evidence to arrest him as well as the whole intelligence agency, which he had created. During search in his house spy materials and installed broadcaster were found. He was transported to Warsaw and - on the basis of a court sentence - executed during the first days of war.

For his spy contribution Lenc received substantial sums of cash, which he exploited for example for building a big house (near J. Lelewela street 9) in Mława, buying expensive furniture and a car. He was investing his earnings in the bank account in Warsaw.

In 1940 "Deutsche Ostwacht" in an article titled "Silent heroism of a woman and terrible murder of a German - Lenc. Mlawa example for many" presented the activity of Lenc as great heroism - example to imitate - and his arrest and further execution - on the strength of a legally valid court sentence - as example of bestiality of Poles, not respecting basic rules of a citizens' freedom, murdering him only because he was German. The Lenc's case was treated as another proof of suffering allegedly inflicted to the German minority by Polish authorities.

More or less in the same time in a small town Iłów, located 9 kilometres from Mława, Polish authorities liquidated - to which Andrzej Ziółkowski contributed - a spy network of Wilhelm Sowa. Also a German storage of weapons and ammunition located in the house of Radzanowski near Szkolna street 9 was detected and liquidated.

German spies and members of V Column could not be arrested earlier not because of the lack of information about German agents operating in this area, or idleness of the Polish security service, but orders from the political factors - mainly from Ministry of Foreign Affairs - to keep maximal caution, not provoke and soften the international situation.
[...]"

Page 28:

"Characteristic phenomenon for the last period before the war were numerous illegal migrations of young people in recruiting age on both sides of the border. In the mławski poviat many people in beggar clothes appeared. On the other hand young Germans were escaping from Poland to avoid being enlisted to the Polish Army or to avoid detentions in case if they were members of spy networks or V Column. Due to these facts on 30.04.1939 Polish authorities issued the "Law about Special Criminal Liability In Case of Illegal Escapes to the Enemy or Outside the Borders of the State". On the strength of this law Polish courts punished many ethnic Germans. But it did not prevent all escapes. In August of 1939 many young Germans appeared along the border. Captured by Polish Border Guard or Police, they were explaining that they were escaping from the upcoming war, that they hated Hitler, that they were good Catholics persecuted by German authorities. Polish security authorities usually interpreted reasons of these escapes correctly - that is, contraband of saboteurs to the Polish territory. But many circles - including the local press and Catholic clergy - assumed that stories about massive escapes from religious reasons were true, they were cheated and treated exodus of "refugees" as preview of soon crisis in godless Germany. Indeed, there were also such persons, who were really escaping from the Nazi terror, but it was several years before the beginning of the war. For example in 1936 a German deserter with full equipment escaped from the garrison in Olsztyn [Allenstein] to Poland - his name was Heinz Keller."

As you can see Nazi propaganda depicted executions of Nazi Germany's agents and spies in Poland, as "persecution of German minority in Poland".
 
Kaiserguard said:
having enacted Anti-Semitic laws similar to Nazi Germany

No, rather similar to the United States of America, which introduced Jewish quota (numerus clausus) in many universities long before Poland did.

Anti-Semitic laws in Nazi Germany were many times harsher than those in Poland in the 1930s or those in the USA in the 1920s and the 1930s.

=======================================

Here a Nazi propaganda newsreel - perhaps from late 1939 or 1940 - about those alleged Polish atrocities in 1939:

Narrator says, for example, at 2:48 (between 2:48 and 3:17) of the video:

My translation:

"Polish Jews in many cases turned out to be guilty of inciting to crimes against German population. Out of these circles [i.e. Jewish] were recruited criminals and murderers, who after 1918 deluged defenceless Germany, and their names, Barmad or Putiska, remain deeply in our memory. Brothers and sons of these Eastern Jews are nowadays sitting in England and France, inciting to war which is supposed to destroy the German nation.":

And another excerpt (at 1:36 and then at 2:02) - this time justifying German atrocities against Polish civilians:

My translation:

"German troops are following thick on Polish Army's heels. One of their first tasks is to clear the captured settlements of rabid Polish mobs, who had been incited by the Polish government to treacherous partisan combats against the German soldiers.":

Since 2:14 we can see those "rabid Polish mobs, perpetrators of the Bromberger Blutsonntag" - soon before execution by German soldiers...

And then at 3:18 we have "captured Polish debtors (?) are being interned in huge camps."

Polish "debtors" (not sure about translation?) is apparently a pun referring to "typical Polish subhuman mismanagement" (polnische Wirtschaft).


Link to video.

So basically, "quickly retreating in panic" Polish army - incited by Jews of course - is busy with murdering all German minority members on their way.

On the other hand, "so victorious and so glorious" Wehrmacht is simply - in a noble and just way - "clearing the settlements of rabid Polish mobs".

This is Joseph Goebbels' art of filmmaking, as well as "the art of German Racism", in its finest, I must say. :)
 
At 1:19 of the propaganda newsreel video above, there is also such a fragment:

"The retreating Poles had not enough time to organize a withdrawal. In their panicked retreat they abandoned their positions. When leaving villages and cities, they are setting on fire houses of ethnic German settlers. Their rabid appetite for destruction has caused the fact, that they are also destroying houses of their own compatriots."

Combined with:

"German troops are following thick on Polish Army's heels. One of their first tasks is to clear the captured settlements of rabid Polish mobs, who had been incited by the Polish government to treacherous partisan combats against the German soldiers."

I always like it, how the Nazi propaganda was describing resistance by Polish civilians as much stronger than resistance by Polish army. :)

But when we look at actual memoirs / accounts of German soldiers, officers and generals, rather than Nazi propaganda newsreels, we can see that majority of them give due credit to Polish soldiers they were fighting against in September and October 1939.

===================================

Regarding the accusation in that Nazi propaganda newsreel, that Polish forces during their withdrawal were setting on fire villages inhabited by German minority as well as villages inhabited by ethnic Poles. Let's check who was in fact setting on fire villages:

Translated excerpt from an article about German experiences from combats against fortified defence in Poland.

The article was written and published by Major Meltzer in "Vierteljahreshefte fur Pioniere", No 2 of 1940:

Major Meltzer said:
In order to eliminate that bunker, two shock groups were formed from 2. company of 49. pioneer battalion (each of them 11 men strong) and attached to each of two battalions of IR.86 which were attacking in first line. First attempt of those 22 engineers to approach the bunker frontally did not succeed. Another attempt to approach it from behind also failed because of Polish infantry fire from houses of village Kurpiki. But German engineers - using pyrotechnic pistols - set on fire straw thatches of houses, which forced Polish defenders to abandon the burning houses.

Village Kurpiki:

Kurpiki2.png
 
It reminds one of the equally 'real' belgian atrocities against germans in the ww1 timeline, which of course were the reason for the invasion of inhumane scum Belgium by noble human-rights FREEDOM Germany ;)

Interestingly - and shockingly - a few decades before the German invasion, Leopold II did commit one of the worst atrocities ever known to human history. He had 30 million Congolese killed, primarily by having the force publique amputate their limbs. Had Germany invaded Belgium at the time, nobody would have given a damn, given that Belgium was near-universally loathed because of this. It was a many fold times worse than the Armenian genocide or the rape of Belgium, and certainly comparable to the Holocaust and the Stalinist massacres.
 
So, next time you see that friend of yours, I guess you can greet him with a right hand salute and "Sieg Heil!", because he's one of those who still believe in Goebbels' lies 70 years after the war ended. There's plenty of such people, unfortunately.
Acquaintance. He is the CO of our reenacting unit. There are many people that have left the unit because of him, hell I've come incredibly close to doing so. Were it not for a few key people that I really like, I'd have split immediately.

On Topic: I have heard that there was a quite a bit of racism in Poland at the time. But personally I think it can be attributed to Nationalism, which admittedly can spawn a bit of xenophobia.
 
Interestingly - and shockingly - a few decades before the German invasion, Leopold II did commit one of the worst atrocities ever known to human history. He had 30 million Congolese killed, primarily by having the force publique amputate their limbs. Had Germany invaded Belgium at the time, nobody would have given a damn, given that Belgium was near-universally loathed because of this. It was a many fold times worse than the Armenian genocide or the rape of Belgium, and certainly comparable to the Holocaust and the Stalinist massacres.

The genocide in Congo became well-known to the world thanks to Polish-British traveller and writer Joseph Conrad (born Józef Teodor Konrad Korzeniowski).

However, roughly in the same period (1904 - 1908), a genocide of Herero and Nama people took place in German colony of South-West Africa.

Knowledge about this genocide has been slightly popularized only relatively recently, by Casper W. Erichsen and David Olusoga in their book "The Kaiser's Holocaust. Germany's Forgotten Genocide and the Colonial Roots of Nazism", Faber and Faber publishing house, 2010.

It seems, that the Belgian genocide in Congo was not that much worse than the Imperial German genocide in South-East Africa.
 
On Topic: I have heard that there was a quite a bit of racism in Poland at the time.

Jochen Boehler's book "Auftakt zum Vernichtungskrieg. Die Wehrmacht in Polen 1939" shows that there was a lot of racism in the German society.

Boehler deals with this issue (German racism and anti-Semitism) in the following chapters of his book about Wehrmacht's crimes in Poland in 1939:

Chapter 1 - Stereotype and picture of the enemy

Chapter 2 - Poland and her inhabitants in the eyes of German soldiers

Chapter 7, sub-chapter "Discrimination and murdering of Polish prisoners of war of Jewish descent"

Chapter 8 - Collapse of discipline (sub-chapters "Robberies" and "Rapes")

Chapter 9 - Crimes and murders with anti-Semitic background

=====================================

It is interesting, that racist and anti-Semitic notes can be found even in German military documents such as Kriegstagebucher (Combat Diaries).

All excerpts quoted below, are from the above-mentioned book "... Die Wehrmacht in Polen 1939" by Jochen Boehler:

Such an excerpt from a report by a platoon commander within German Artillerie-Regiment 31 - the town of Krzepice:

"With interest we were looking at many sticky of dirt Jews."

Chronicle of Infanterie-Regiment 51, about the capture of the town of Mława:

"The city was burning in many places, there was not a single sign of enemy forces. Only Jews were swarming in the streets, greeting our forces with funny words 'Chail Chitler' and plundering houses."

From the chronicle of Gebirgsjäger-Regiment 136, describing the town of Maków on 06.09.1939:

"These pseudo-Aryans were the majority here. Isak Buchsbaum, Aron Leiber, Israel Fischlib and similar surnames on signboards of shops were clear proofs that these types were racially pure."

Excerpt from a report of a German NCO, titled "Die 6. Battr. des Art.Rgt.3 im polnischen Feldzug" - describing the town of Zduńska Wola:

"A godforsaken hole, swarms of Jews!"

From the report of rifleman Robert L. (field post 19216), titled "10 Tage aus dem TB eines Gebirgsjägers", dated 08.09.39, describing the town of Biecz:

"One of our soldiers suggested that it must be a German city, pointing at signboards with beautiful German surnames, such as Rosenblatt or Osterduft. But then we saw several of such types. Little filthy Jews in gabardines and with side curls, you can't see such ones even in 'Der Stürmer'".

And one more excerpt from the chronicle of Gebirgsjäger-Regiment 136 - describing the town of Krosno:

"Jews were plentiful, you could see their funny figures everywhere, dirty and dressed in eccentric clothes."

Finally - an excerpt from Kriegstagebuch of Inf.Rgt.31., a note from 06.09.1939 describing the town of Piotrków Trybunalski (Petrikau):

"The high number of despicable Jews is striking."

There are also plenty of similar racist comments regarding Polish people. I also did not quote all of anti-Semitic comments cited by Boehler.

These are proofs that anti-Semitism and racism were deeply rooted among many soldiers of the German Wehrmacht.
 
It seems, that the Belgian genocide in Congo was not that much worse than the Imperial German genocide in South-East Africa.

Actually, it was. The Congo genocide was arguably the worst excess of colonial rule of all of modern history.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom