mitsho
Deity
the Perfume by Patrick Süskind. Probably the best German book of the last decades (just after "Der Vorleser").


mitsho said:the Perfume by Patrick Süskind.
Till said:Edgar Allen Poe
I agree that it is one heck of a novel.mitsho said:the Perfume by Patrick Süskind. Probably the best German book of the last decades (just after "Der Vorleser").
![]()
I like to read Poe, while listening to an audiobook version of the text. It's facinating!Heretic_Cata said:I love Poe - so depressing, but so good.
I've read both, and I think Der Vorleser isn't bad, although the first half is better. When it trailed it off into the Nazi-past/guilt-theme in the second half I realised I'd read something just like it often before. As to The Perfume, it didn't impress me that much, the whole smelling thing seems a bit ridiculous to me, as does Grenouille's character. I suppose it does open your senses to the world of smell though, and shows that different people perceive in different ways.mitsho said:the Perfume by Patrick Süskind. Probably the best German book of the last decades (just after "Der Vorleser").
![]()
Ciceronian said:I've read both, and I think Der Vorleser isn't bad, although the first half is better. When it trailed it off into the Nazi-past/guilt-theme in the second half I realised I'd read something just like it often before. As to The Perfume, it didn't impress me that much, the whole smelling thing seems a bit ridiculous to me, as does Grenouille's character. I suppose it does open your senses to the world of smell though, and shows that different people perceive in different ways.
Yeah mitsho, I agree that Der Vorleser does treat Nazism in a fairly reasonable and subtle manner. It's just that we'd read so many books in German class about Nazi Germany that I just got slightly fed up with that theme. Good that we agree that the first half is better.mitsho said:In the case you got me wrong, I do think "Der Vorleser" is a good novel and one of the few where the nazitime is in my eyes reasonable depicted... But ok, the first half is better.
The perfume on the other hand is just a genius work on how to use language. If you don't like the story, the logic, Grenouille's Character, it's ok, they are debateable... But just the way how Süskind writes it down, is superb (imho). And it's just an epic story...
m