1. No bringing up abortion in a thread not explicitly about abortion. Punishable by ban.
Generally agree. The exception should be a general political thread. Say, if there's a thread about who we're voting for, saying "I'm not gonna vote for Obama since he wants to allow abortion" or "I won't vote for Santorum since he opposes the right to choose" should be allowed.
Also, I think the penalty of ban for one offense is generally too high. Same criticism as the one below. Note: There ARE some posts that deserve a flat out week off, but that's the exception, not the rule (And I've made one once... As Domination...)
2. No bringing up Nazis in a thread not explicitly about Nazis. Punishable by ban.
...Sometimes... I think the Godwin rule should be changed to the Godwin guideline.
3. Terms such as communism, socialism, fascism, etc. will be used PROPERLY as per their generally accepted meaning among political scientists. Statements such as "the US is communist cause obamacare" or "the repubs are fascist cause pro-life" will be deleted. Punishable by 2-point infraction.
Why? Just correct them.
4. Any claim must be backed up by a reliable and trusted source, preferably a well-known newspaper. Punishable by warning and deleting of post.
Not every claim. Some things are just established, even if they aren't well known. I don't need to prove John Tyler was the 10th President (Post made in entirety without sources. I know them from memory

)
Even if the claim is controversial, I don't necessarily have to prove it. I can make the claim. If you challenge it, I should have to either back up or back down. Not necessarily by force of rules, but if its, "Is not, is too" a mod can delete it.
I responded to yours because I found them interesting,l even though I disagree with some.
As for me...
1. Acknowledge that some posts are so inexplainably stupid that continually making them in a combative manner should be a punishable offense. What I mean about this is making a comment that is borderline insulting but you think its true, being proven wrong, then doing it again, exc. Such posts should either be infracted, or...
2. My preference: Allow us to call idiots idiots.
There.
Then, after finding that I have violated all of these rules, I will ban myself. Twice. And give me a 2-point infraction.
No worries

Domination3000 was banned at least 15 times.