metalhead
Angry Bartender
- Joined
- Apr 15, 2002
- Messages
- 8,031
Even those methods are under severe scrutiny. Not long ago in Philly, it took several cops to physically subdue a very large, uncooperative man. In the process, the very large man was brought to ground so he could be cuffed, but one cop used an apparently unauthorized choke hold in doing so and the man died. It was on video and there was nothing particularly brutal in evidence.
That was in NYC, and the key is "unauthorized" choke hold. It's unauthorized for a reason. He shouldn't have used the choke hold, full stop. He belongs in prison, not the unemployment line. That's the solution - put him in jail for homicide to deter cops from using unauthorized choke holds.
Very unfair, unless you are trained in threat assessment. Unarmed people can kill. Can you be quite certain the unarmed does not intend to harm you, or kill you. Do you think it is better to 'take the chance'? Suppose you are much smaller than the assailant? Suppose you're not sure if there is a concealed weapon? If you are willing to set the standard that cops should never meet a threat with a greater force, then so be it. Not sure how many people are willing to do that.
That's why nonlethal methods of incapacitation are the best option. If you assess a threat and cannot be sure, then you use means to incapacitate the suspect without killing him or her. If Darren Wilson legitimately feared for his life, then he should have other means besides killing Michael Brown with which to protect himself. It's a huge part of the problem that cops aren't trained to use other means of defending themselves.
There are few instances where you can be certain about anything. But that is exactly why there have to be more options for a fearful officer than pulling out their gun and shooting at the perceived threat. You'll never eliminate every instance of this happening, but that's why accountability is so important.
It's also worth noting, this is to protect the cops too. I doubt many of them do very well handling killings like this. I would imagine many of them would welcome tools to better de-escalate situations, use non-lethal force, and ultimately save lives.