What's her boyfriend like? Does he fit the outlaw biker category?
Hehehe.. I get the reference, but no

He's the musical type who plays in a band... and cuts grass for a living. His family is fairly well off, so he's a bit spoiled, or so she claims anyway. He's very quiet when I've been around him and doesn't say much. All else I know about him is that they have some sort of connection and that he plays soccer, as a hobby, from time to time.
chinesefireball said:
So your situation could have been something like that, but with your cuddling she doesn't really have the excuse to be clueless. More really good friends with some benefits thrown in.
Yeah, it's possible. I've gotten "tickle fight" and "shoulder rub" coupons from her before. She just enjoys that sort of stuff and I get it, but I don't get how she could not have clued in into what she was doing. We talked about the cuddling and she says she doesn't remember most of it. However, during it.. she was quite awake and aware. It's almost as if she doesn't want to face it and talk about it most of it directly.. which bugs me a lot, because that night meant something to me. The first time I brought it up she started crying - said she thought I would say we couldn't be friends anymore.
chinesefireball said:
If you are happy with it - I say keep it. You mentioned you wanted some more controll in where the relationship was heading - the only way I can think of you doing that without pushing yourself onto the girl is by saying no to cuddling (but since that is occasional, well it may not really work)
Yeah, I wouldn't mind that at all. I suppose I could just rent a scary movie and invite her over one night, and see what happens. Thing is that now there are feelings involved - at least on my end. I told her that we're going to be friends no matter what.. But I'm not sure if something like that would hurt me a lot or not. It almost feels like I might as well go all the way and make a significant move.. or forget cuddling at all.
I still have 2 of those coupons that I never redeemed. Maybe I can work those things into all of this somehow.
Golden Touch said:
wow and I thought men were ****ed up! In a nutshell I think your right in thinking your the boyfriend substitute. It is hard to do long distance relationships and what started out as some male influence and a hug from some manly arms went too far. I'm not denying she must feel something for you to be spending so much time with you in fairly intimate ways - but at the same time you dont do long distance for a laugh. She MUST love her boyfriend and as such you should stay well clear as she's only going to mess with your mind.
Yeah, they do have some sort of connection. I don't get it. She got a bit insulted when I told her that I would never want that sort of relationship with her.. so if that's what she thought I meant by 'boyfriend', then that's not what I was talking about. Her response.. "But he's my boyfriend!" *stare*
She might very well love him, but their lack of communication and time spent together makes me go.. "whaa?". He only lives 1.5 hours away.
Golden Touch said:
However, shes a friend which makes it more difficult. I would recommend cutting down on the time you spend together. Its not normal to spend that much time with a member of the opposite sex that your not dating and your always going to feel this way about her whilst you do. I would say get out there, date again - they dont have to be your soulmate just someone fun! Try and keep your friendship on a strictly friends basis think 'would I do this with another female friend'. Try being civil to her man, show her you dont mind. There is a good chance she WILL come on to you but its up to you to take the 'you have a boyfriend, we're just friends. If you want me then i'm not settling for being your plaything during the week. friends dont do that to each other'. That way she will either leave her man and end up being yours, OR you'll know once and for all that shes just a very messed up girl.
Yeah.. It is hard to spend less time together. It was always her, though, who initiated these things and asked if I wanted to do something together. I did my share, but I would have felt weird to call her every single day, asking her to come over, so she'd usually come on msn and call me, and we'd make plans that way. She'd even show up @ my work and bring me food and stuff.. or just drop by to say hi and make plans there.
So lately I've felt bad that it's usually been her, so I've been trying to be more proactive about it.. but right now.. I saw her Monday night, and I haven't taken steps to set up our next "date". We'll just hang out whenever she wants to. I think that's the best approach.
And I like your idea about keeping it professional.. but this is the sort of thing she will do.. Last week she decided to try to fix my faucet.. and she's a weak little thing, so I'm in there trying to help her.. She claims she has experience doing this sort of work - but it does take a lot of manly power to screw/unscrew some of those bolts

So we'd be down on the floor, she'd be down inside the cabinet checking stuff out.. and while she's doing that, her ass is rubbing up against me, indiscriminately. seemed very playful. I rubbed up against it a couple times, I just couldn't resist. I will be seeing more stuff like that - instead of a direct "coming on". It is not something I can deny her .. She'll just go "what? I'm not doing anything"
That helped btw, thanks
Brighteye said:
What more needs to be said? You've found someone with whom you can have a wonderful time, and she feels the same about you, but you can't do anything sexual with her because of intimacy issues, and so you have 2 options:
Well, it's not quite that simple. My intimacy issues aren't really that bad - they don't prevent me from having sex.. but they do make me more cautious about physical contact. Having said that, I seem to have gotten over all of that.. somehow.. lately. So it shouldn't be an issue anymore.
It is mostly the fact that I never wanted to ruin our friendship - and her signals weren't ever strong enough for me to go "Ok, she means it". All her signals have been very... careful.. something she can deny if she wants to.
Brighteye said:
1. She feels like she's your platonic friend. She has a great time with you and loves you dearly, and doesn't want to lose you. However, she doesn't think of you sexually, so any move you make will just spoil the friendship for both of you.
This is what I'm not sure about. There have been hints both ways. She has even directly asked for sex before, but it was still early in our relationship and I took it as a joke.. plus at that time I wasn't emotionally attached. We were just walking home from the store, and I ended up paying for a bunch of pop and chips and what not... and she quietly said: "you can pay me back later.. with sex".. it just took me aback. I didn't respond.. boo! I should have.. but ah well, that's the past now. We didn't get close at all that evening, so at the time it was easy to dismiss it as a joke. I was still in "We're just awesome friends" mode anyway.
Brighteye said:
2. She loves you more than in a platonic way, but is confused by your lack of sexual advances. So she thinks that you're platonic friends, but is then confused by your moodiness about her boyfriend and her odd signals. She opts for the safe option of saying that you're both just friends; it may be that she isn't entirely sure of her own feelings too.
That could very well be right on.. except that I've told her why I haven't been making any sexual advances.. When we first started hanging out, she made a point of telling me that most of the previous 'close male friends' she had.. that weren't gay.. ended up taking advantage of her.. and the rest of them gave her a "boyfriend or nothing" ultimatum. I have always felt like we have something special, and I did not want to ruin that, becoming just another guy that she was used to. That isn't me, anyway.
Her signals just haven't been strong enough. They are there, and they are confusing me, but at the same time, they are not strong enough for me to consider risking what we have. Right now, as far as she is concerned, I have fully accepted the "never" thing and am hving a blast just being friends. I haven't done anything to signal otherwise, unless she's misinterpreting the walks I have been taking with her.. and I suppose it might be possible to read me without me doing anything direct. See, this sort of attitude from me is what made her send those recent signals. So I am hoping that by doing more of the same, she will get more frustrated and do something more direct. Or she could just get frustrated and give up.
Ingvina Freyr said:
@warpus There were two things I didn't get out of your very interesting story (sorry if it's there but I missed it); You say that the girl is talking about moving away and saying that she wants something to happen, but nothing about what she is saying about her boyfriend. Is that because you don't want to talk about him with her or us, or is it because she doesn't include him in her future plans?
She never talks about him. I used to hear about him maybe once a month, and it'd be something in passing. They don't seem very close at all, but then I hear that she's "in love with him" or whatever. It is confusing.
I don't think she is including him in her future plans, but I don't think that is because she doesn't want him in them. I think it is more a case of her wanting things to just unfold naturally. Plus, including him in her future plans would be a comittment.
Ingvina Freyr said:
Secondly, your questions are basically about what she wants, but what do you want? I think that's what you need to decide for yourself, and then try to make that happen. If you ask me, I'd say it seems you want her as a girlfriend, otherwise I think you would have been more content with the situation as it is.
See, here's the thing. I haven't talked about it because I've figured that part out.
I would love to have her as my girlfriend.. okay, so apparently this is "never" going to happen. Her idea of a boyfriend is a bit messed up, IMO, so her idea of a boyfriend/girlfriend type relationship is not what I'd want.
I want to spend a lot of time with her and for her to be around. It makes me happy. I also want to be able to fully express my feelings for her and do what feels naturally, without having to pull myself back, not wanting to damage the friendship.
I know what I want, but I have no idea how much of that she would be willing to give me, and in what form. That is my predicament. She is a very fragile creature and confusing to say the least. I do not know what options I have, so I am being very careful.
Thanks a lot for all of your input. THis has been very confusing for me, but the more I type it out and/or talk about it, and the more feedback I get, the more sense everything is starting to make.
For now I'm just going to do my own thing and see what she does. Last time I saw her was Monday night and I was getting out of a cab.. and I said: "We gotta work on my faucet! We'll be in touch" and gave her a hug.