Ask an American Civil War reenactor

Daird

Warlord
Joined
Oct 28, 2013
Messages
165
Location
The Birthplace of God
Hello there, folks! I've been reenacting as a private in the 153rd Pennsylvania Volunteer Infantry for about a year and a half. With the 150th anniversary celebrations in full swing, I figured it would be good to get a thread up for anyone who wants to know more about this particular hobby, so go ahead and ask away.
 
Do you reenact in "flavor" skirmishes or do you reenact a specific battle?

Do the reenactors of the 153rd Volunteers have artillery, and if so, what types?
 
Are you concerned about the Brits coming in for the South? If they do, do you think the French will support the North?
 
Don't you feel odd sometimes that you're celebrating and glorifying war?

Of course I realise that isn't the intention .... but I am wondering if mixed feelings ever enter into the situation.
 
Do you camp using only period technology/resources for the duration of the reenactment? How long are the reenactments; day, weekend, week? Do you substitute some items because of health concerns. Like modern spoon instead of pewter because of lead. Do you use period soap? Do you cook food/prepare meals on a campfire? Were you in the armed forces? What type of age group is responsible for most reenactments? Who comes? Family? Do you reenact at National Parks and deal with tourist? Does it feel odd being part of the totalitarian armies in the war of northern aggression?
 
Give a guess as to what percentage of reenactors wear period-style undergarments.
 
Do you reenact in "flavor" skirmishes or do you reenact a specific battle?

Do the reenactors of the 153rd Volunteers have artillery, and if so, what types?

A bit of both. If it's a local reenactment, they may be general skirmishes. Bigger reenactments have specific parts of the battle done at specific times, as there's obviously no way to get full-size armies on the field. As for your second question, my particular regiment doesn't own any artillery.

Are you concerned about the Brits coming in for the South? If they do, do you think the French will support the North?

You've got it backwards, my friend. There was virtually no chance of the British throwing their lot in with the South. The Confederacy actually got a conditional offer of support from the French, but the condition was that the British had to join in as well, so it was really a moot point.
Don't you feel odd sometimes that you're celebrating and glorifying war?

Of course I realise that isn't the intention .... but I am wondering if mixed feelings ever enter into the situation.

Occasionally, yes. In real life, I'm pretty much a pacifist. However, we try to emphasize the whole of the war, which by necessity means mentioning the suffering of soldiers and civilians alike.

it's worse; he could be a neo-confederate.

serious: what kind of firearms do you use? are they replicas? are they legitimate firearms or more-or-less props?

I use a .58 caliber Enfield rifle. Perfectly legitimate weapon, though I admit I've never actually put a live round downrange. I'm a small guy, and it's a big gun. I'd probably end up on my backside if I tried.

Do you camp using only period technology/resources for the duration of the reenactment? How long are the reenactments; day, weekend, week? Do you substitute some items because of health concerns. Like modern spoon instead of pewter because of lead. Do you use period soap? Do you cook food/prepare meals on a campfire? Were you in the armed forces? What type of age group is responsible for most reenactments? Who comes? Family? Do you reenact at National Parks and deal with tourist? Does it feel odd being part of the totalitarian armies in the war of northern aggression?

Whoa, slow down there. Most of us use only period equipment for camping. I stay at home or in hotels rather than camping and have a cell phone with me, but those are both for health-related reasons. Equipment is made with modern materials, and we often have field-cooked stew, but there's usually home-baked goods available as well, and there's always modern food available for the spectators, who are mostly family and the portion of the general public interested in history. There's always public interaction, but virtually nobody reenacts at national parks to my knowledge. As for the age group, many of the old-timers will be retiring at the end of next year with the conclusion of 150th anniversary events, so there's kind of a changing of the guard feeling.

Give a guess as to what percentage of reenactors wear period-style undergarments.

Not going to touch that one, literally or figuratively.
 
Do you have any photos of past events you can post?
 
What is your opinion of LARPing? Do you engage in civil war re-enactments more for the history or the role-playing?
 
I was always hoping one of these events would get out of hand. But that's a Southern perspective.
 
Are there any folks in your group that take it too far? For example, stay in character for the full duration of the reenactment, regardless of off-time/interaction with people from outside that particular event?
 
Are you aware of any commonly-held misconceptions on the ACW? If so, do you do anything to attempt to dispel them?
 
Whoa, slow down there. Most of us use only period equipment for camping. I stay at home or in hotels rather than camping and have a cell phone with me, but those are both for health-related reasons.

Well for ever person the was killed in combat another two died from poor sanitation and hygiene. The south had it worse though, there rations were so small and poor that men would eat there meat rations raw as cooking it would render all the fat off, shrinking the already tiny ration.

Anyways rebel traitors deserve death by dysentery ! :mad:
 
Do you have any photos of past events you can post?

Sorry, but no.

What is your opinion of LARPing? Do you engage in civil war re-enactments more for the history or the role-playing?

If LARPing's your thing, that's fine, but it's not for me. I'm in it for the history, and also to get the best idea I can of what my ancestors who actually fought went through.

I was always hoping one of these events would get out of hand. But that's a Southern perspective.

Happens more often than you might think. Last year at Gettysburg, there was a rumor flying around that a Confederate infantryman actually overheated and passed away on the field, but I was never able to find out the truth about that.

Are there any folks in your group that take it too far? For example, stay in character for the full duration of the reenactment, regardless of off-time/interaction with people from outside that particular event?

We used to have that problem with our bugler, but he packed up and moved to Wyoming. Wyoming can keep him, far as I'm concerned.

Are you aware of any commonly-held misconceptions on the ACW? If so, do you do anything to attempt to dispel them?

Yes, there are a few commonly held misconceptions that even I had when I started. To begin with, there's the idea that the most important thing a soldier had to know was how to shoot accurately. In fact, the very first thing I learned was how to move your rifle to various positions. Order arms, shoulder arms, that sort of thing.

Well for ever person the was killed in combat another two died from poor sanitation and hygiene.

And therein lies another common misconception, that most soldiers died from fighting, which was what they spent most of their time doing. One soldier whose name has been lost to time wrote home that "Soldiering is long periods of extreme boredom, occasionally interrupted by short periods of extreme terror." I never served in the actual military, but I can't imagine that part has really changed much.
 
Edit: I worded this like crap - redo.

Do the Confederate reinactors ever catch crap for being racists? Do they deserve it?
 
Does the term "farb" mean anything to you?

How hardcore is too hardcore?

If you were to give any advice to a prospective reenactor, what would it be? I've considered it, but the clothing is expensive. My town does the Battle of Selma every year, so I get to see and smell it all up close.
 
Does the term "farb" mean anything to you?

How hardcore is too hardcore?

If you were to give any advice to a prospective reenactor, what would it be? I've considered it, but the clothing is expensive. My town does the Battle of Selma every year, so I get to see and smell it all up close.

Farb is basically calling someone out for being REALLY unauthentic, and is the worst insult you can hurl at a reenactor. If you call someone a farb, you're asking for trouble.

How hardcore is too hardcore? We're here mostly to educate the public, whether by answering questions or doing battle reenactments. 99% of the time, we actually aren't in character, believe it or not. That's reserved almost exclusively for battles. Trash talk has been known to fly when we're in the lines, but there were extenuating circumstances that particular day.

You want to be a reenactor? I've got some information for you if you want to be infantry, but cannot speak for artillery or cavalry. First, work on your cardio and ability to function in high temperatures. It can get hot out there, and those uniforms are wool. Secondly, your total cost for gear will be about $2K, but dues are essentially nonexistent. I pay fifteen bucks a year, and most of that's for insurance. Third, find out whether your regiment uses Hardee's Manual of Arms or Casey's. Either way, go on Youtube, find some demonstration videos, and use those to help you practice whichever one you use until you can do the movements in your sleep. If you're a lefthander like me, you'll also need to work on coordination with your right hand. Everything's done right-handed.

Edit: I worded this like crap - redo.

Do the Confederate reinactors ever catch crap for being racists? Do they deserve it?

Yes, they do catch some flak, but they don't deserve it at all. They're just normal people, and besides, Southerners certainly didn't have a monopoly on racism in America. Some of Lincoln's views were undoubtably racist by today's standards.
 
Do you reenact with reproductions of the authentic equipment and uniforms of the era? What does your volunteer organization do when there's no reenactments scheduled? Do you or the volunteers make appearances in museum events or other educational places as a speaker to educate the public?
 
Back
Top Bottom