Aspiring Rapper's MAFIA- Game Thread

Ah, landlubber's vote on Cuth is kind of weird too. It seems to be based off of earlier interactions than what is going on in thread.

Maybe we can kill landlubber too.

Revised WTL list: Cass, BL, Kenniget, KM, Lohrenswald, Legato, landlubber

People who need to speak up: edse, Xym

Cuth is town. His waffling about and his inherent scumminess is much in line with his town meta, and he's been less questioning and prodding than he is as scum.
 
Anyway, I must leave for the day. Have choir.

Please lynch within my WTL list.

Treat all future doctor claims with a grain of salt, but don't immediately lynch someone just because of their claim.

They have to be scummy too.

That is very important. Lollll.

Okay, sushi out. Don't do anything stupid.
 
Personally i think cass and legato have completely bogus arguments between today/yesterday, which makes me lean town on them. Clearly at least 1 scum is tryharding innight kill selection (at least night 1) and I don't expect scum to make such sloppy mistakes (eg my own cases, legato saying some reversal of opinion occurred, cass quoting zack yesterday but posing a question to me as if I made that post)

Choxorn feels incredibly non-genuine inthe deciding votes yesterday but I still refuse to believr cuthillius and glossy are both town

To appeal to Zack directly, remember day 1 how you howled about how arakhor had such an incredibly scummy claim and response?

Yet here is glossy presenting himself as if he is some harbringer of sorting good power role claims and that's why on day 1 he had to lead a heroic but failed CFD away from the righteous Arakhor

I cannot look at votes too much on mobile but yea, probably the al sipclar voters were townies going "gee, IMPOSSIBLE to have 2 doctors!!!"


Maybe it is just choxorn though. Al sipclar had a line earlier that only scum ever accuse him of being scum, and I remember some specific game when i was a double voter and scum/takhisis howled and shouted that I couldn't be

Scum love to scream at truthful townies for no reason very often


So i am torn b/w glossy vs choxorn
 
Because fwiw for people who think i am scummy, my behavior day 1 was to be skeptical of arakhor's very weak claim but UPON LEARNING INFORMATION SINCE I DO NOT HAVE PIS you can note how I accepted al sipsclar and tried to point out and defend the "limited doctor" setup.

I know it is kennigit v1 and kennigit v2 but they're basically the same kennigit, both vanilla
 
Ayy. True bling bling blue here. Ride on and prosper.

All right, let's get to it. Course, there's not much to go on yet. 'Kay. Ehh.

Reasoning so far seems a bit weak, but early aggression is necessary for results.

Vote before heading to sleep, just in case.

Vote: Visorslash

Reason: He exists.

Most of the posts early on are from dead townies, but here are Murska's first two posts. I have no idea with the first one, but the second one is sort of a bad look.
 
Unvote. Vote: Cuthillius. You shouldn't bus a fellow wolf day 1 Cuth.

Unvote. I thought we agreed in wolf QT that we wouldn't bus each other Visorslash.

These posts are also a little suspicious especially since they're interacting with two townies. I hold with the reasoning that joking you're a wolf is a wolf thing to do. I dunno. :sad:
 
Thanks! :cool:



Yea, get avatars you n00bs! :p



Uh, so why exactly are you in on a mislynch of Zack? Who says it's a mislynch? Seems a little too opportunistic to me, considering you just came out of nowhere to make the post. vote: Edse.

Backwards Logic/Zack could be a thing if Zack is scum.
 
I second this, Lassie's all over the place and clearly trying to control the discussion.
This post is noted.
yea I kinda regret that post, since I was saying fos jokingly as I did before. But by now I probably shouldn't, even though most of day 1 still lie ahead.

but I have voted YOU PLEBE PAY ATTENTION

Backtracking and redirecting

I was looking through SoD and Lohr is posting a good amount of fluff/commentary/unrelated stuff.
 
There is no way a townie at this point says anyone is definitive town

If cuthillius and glossy are both actually townie I will change how I play mafia going forward in the future
 
It's definitely not the first wagon that lost steam and/or was overtaken by another. See Arakhor, Lassie, Al Sipsclar - all wagons that had concerted counter-wagons, some on multiple days.

Geh. That's not how it felt yesterday, although vote analysis isn't my best subject I'll admit. As I'm like, completely alone in this conclusion, I'll do a re-read, but I know something is off.

I agree with this!

It looks like we could go Cass or Legato today.

Please do not lynch Zack. -.-

Way to lynch all the top posters with lots of effort (it's my fault too, ugh).

WE ARE NOT LYNCHING ZACK TODAY.

Feel free to go for Cass, Legato Endless, Backwards Logic, Kennigit.

Also! If you think I'm scum, then vote me. Do not vote someone else just because they're easier to lynch. That, my dears, is scummy. You can go die between a rock and a hard place if you want to go down that route.

WTL list: Cass, BL, Kenniget, KM, Lohrenswald, Legato, landlubber

That is absurdly large. First, there aren't 7 mafia. Not with double kills per night. And regardless, placing half the entire listing of remaining players as acceptable isn't sensible in the slightest.

I don't like that choxorn considered Al Sips a better lynch than Zack although he was unsure about the claim.

I don't like the Al Sips lynch at all, it was driven by the mafia in some form.

Agreed.

Personally i think cass and legato have completely bogus arguments between today/yesterday, which makes me lean town on them.

Sigh.

Choxorn feels incredibly non-genuine inthe deciding votes yesterday but I still refuse to believr cuthillius and glossy are both town

To appeal to Zack directly, remember day 1 how you howled about how arakhor had such an incredibly scummy claim and response?

Yet here is glossy presenting himself as if he is some harbringer of sorting good power role claims and that's why on day 1 he had to lead a heroic but failed CFD away from the righteous Arakhor

I cannot look at votes too much on mobile but yea, probably the al sipclar voters were townies going "gee, IMPOSSIBLE to have 2 doctors!!!"


Maybe it is just choxorn though. Al sipclar had a line earlier that only scum ever accuse him of being scum, and I remember some specific game when i was a double voter and scum/takhisis howled and shouted that I couldn't be

Scum love to scream at truthful townies for no reason very often


So i am torn b/w glossy vs choxorn

You know, I could go for either. Chox needs to flip simply because at this point it's outright astonishing he hasn't been lynched with the degree of suspicion he's gotten from everyone.

Vote: Choxorn

I could maybe support flipping Glossy, if mostly because I'm fairly uncertain what to make of the game. I'll take a look through the reams of posts and see if anything changes. Cuth I can't go along with though, if I'm wrong then, blah, I'm wrong, but there's nothing making me think he's scum in all this.

If Glossy is scum, then Cass is actually probably town IMO.
 
Backwards Logic's vote on me (OMGUS), lack of content, complaining about the thread speed, and all of the above seem to be mere excuses for what he's been doing (not much), and seem to be lazy. What is wrong with following a town read, especially since every town Visor's defended has been town?

Here's the problem with the argument against me: It's all meta related. Yea, I tend to lurk as scum, but it has absolutely no bearing for this game. How have the meta arguments worked so far? Go ahead and lynch me if it gets rid of that lingering question a handful of you seem to have. You'll be painfully disappointed when I flip town.

My vote on you was not OMGUS, it is your play. You call out a bunch of people to make reads and push cases, and even now today it's "lynch one of these six or seven people." That's not town, that's misdirection. You haven't pushed any of them with anything convincing. You call choxorn out on making obvious statements, then go ahead and do it yourself. Then choxorn makes one post and suddenly everything is honky-dory. On top of it, you claim to be following along, yet how exactly do you miss that KM replaced Xym? This is the kind of thing scum miss - it doesn't impact them directly so it's a thought that gets neglected. Townies on the other hand have to make cases/leans on almost everyone, so a player change is something that's going to stick out. I'm only half following along due to time and I knew this.

How exactly is Zack town? He pushed a bunch of cases (sort of), they were all wrong, and now he's claiming he's taking a backseat now and letting others drive the cases. Assuming he's scum (and I'm leaning that he is - he's been wrong as town before and never took his foot off the gas like this), doesn't it make sense for another scum to start directing and driving the cases on other townies to take the focus off of Zack?

Vote: Zack. You don't do this as town.

I'm seeing a glossy/Zack/choxorn/murska connection right now, I'm getting scum vibes from landlubber, and the cass post that's somehow incriminated him seems to be glossy grasping at straws. I've made the "look at x player tomorrow" post as town. Hell, we all have - if this guy flips, then look this way. If not, look at these guys. It's how you play the game. So I find it highly suspicious and slightly hilarious when two of the more active posters grab onto something so trivial and run with it. Oh and why Murska?

This on two wagons that look rather likely to have been two Town. (Unless Zack is scum) Then he voted on Zack to preserve Backwards Logic, who was shaping up as a third CFD wagon.

Vote: Legato Endless on my part.

Underlining mine. Unless Zack is scum? Obvious statement is obvious. And why the backpedaling on Zack? It's like you're hedging your bets in such a way that if Zack flips scum, you have an out (oops, I was deceived!). While we're calling people out on making trivial statements and Capt. Obvious posts, I'm assuming glossy will get around and make the post calling Murksa out as such. Oh wait...

I agree with this!

It looks like we could go Cass or Legato today.

Please do not lynch Zack. -.-

Way to lynch all the top posters with lots of effort (it's my fault too, ugh).

Underling again mine. Don't lynch Zack, unless he's scum... WHAT?!?!

tl:dr

glossy/Zack/Murska/choxorn/ possibly landlubber. Start with the four, then we'll sort it out from there.
 
Back
Top Bottom