Aspiring Rapper's MAFIA- Game Thread

[Glossysushi]

He's been consistently wrong so far and I've pointed out plenty of disagreements I've had with his reasoning before. Plus I think he's scum. I honestly don't put much weight in his reads, especially considering he hasn't bothered to explain 90% of them.


I don't see the point. If Lassie and Mat are both town, why would scum care which is lynched? If anything it implicates Lassie.

That's what I meant by Lassie making more sense as the final piece in the puzzle.

Yeah, that's a fair point.

Mat93 was always town in that scenario. Ugh.

I take back my town read of Lassie again.

ugh.

He did explain his reads on day 1, however.

Can we work together?

Vote: Lassie

It makes more sense for his reads to be accurate if he has PIS. Plus, no explanations.

Plus, two strikes? He's been wrong both times, and has slipped out of lynches faster than a sushi has ever disappeared down my gullet.

 

[Glossysushi]

I feel like I'm avoiding reading anything from Lassie and Glossy until I have more time. Maybe we should lynch them to reduce the distraction.



I agree with Zack that this is meaningless. Heck, the scum could have avoided wagons on D1, and these all could be just paranoid townies.

I vote: edse per my yesterday reads.

I do wonder why Lassie has you as town.

If you wanted to lynch me, you should have done that day 1. I make the least sense then.

 

[BSmith1068]

10 people voted for Arakhor. There are 27 people in the game. You could randomly select any ten people and it's highly likely there'd be at least one scum there. Your point is meaningless.

Except I’m not picking 10 people at random… I’m picking people that responded to a scummy player and lynched a townie. Some of those people are dead now and we know they are town, further narrowing the list of potential scum. As a scum I would certainly consider pushing for an Arakhor lynch as it is an easily justifiable vote. It won’t require me to really have to defend it when push comes to shove. I’d bet top dollar that there is at least one scummer on that list, and absent any actual dead scummers it is a place to start in narrowing down our targets. We need to be focused at this point in the game.

I have been reading you pretty town this whole game, but your response is striking me as somewhat defensive in nature as your name is on that list as well. Something to think about.

As it stands I am not scum, and I had you as not scum, so that really puts our target onto just 4 players:

Choxorn
Murska
Xym
Lassie

I’d be fine with lynching any of these 4 today, and would certainly be open to deeper analysis on each of them.

 

[Glossysushi]

anyway.

Al Siiiiiiips.

Hiiiiii.

Tell me about choxorn, and tell me about edse. I missed your 'yesterday' read.

 

[Glossysushi]

Except I’m not picking 10 people at random… I’m picking people that responded to a scummy player and lynched a townie. Some of those people are dead now and we know they are town, further narrowing the list of potential scum. As a scum I would certainly consider pushing for an Arakhor lynch as it is an easily justifiable vote. It won’t require me to really have to defend it when push comes to shove. I’d bet top dollar that there is at least one scummer on that list, and absent any actual dead scummers it is a place to start in narrowing down our targets. We need to be focused at this point in the game.

I have been reading you pretty town this whole game, but your response is striking me as somewhat defensive in nature as your name is on that list as well. Something to think about.

As it stands I am not scum, and I had you as not scum, so that really puts our target onto just 4 players:

Choxorn
Murska
Xym
Lassie

I’d be fine with lynching any of these 4 today, and would certainly be open to deeper analysis on each of them.

Can you tell me about Xym? I think that he/she (?) has been a light town read for most of the game for me, but that's mostly been a tone reason.

I also mentioned Murska's timing seeming weird.

Also, hi. You look fairly townie. Consider me pocketed.

I think that Zack is still town. Can you explain how you see his response as defensive? I didn't see anything wrong with it.

 

[BSmith1068]

I agree with Zack that this is meaningless. Heck, the scum could have avoided wagons on D1, and these all could be just paranoid townies.

I vote: edse per my yesterday reads.

True. They certainly could have, but I doubt it. Arakhor was such a tempting vote in my mind. I certainly went for it.

 

[Lassie]

lol, ok

that was my guess

is it because you are?

Cuth asking Glossy if she is Alette, now that Glossy revealed I wasn't Alette.

Look at Glossy's post where she says that I'm not Alette:

Okay, so I'm on page ten. Loool the game started, and I must have missed the QT email notification. Anyway, I know Cuthilius, Lassie, Visor, and Cass.

Sort of know edse a little from graveyarding in a game with him/her.

Lassie, btw, is not Alette. So you can throw your meta out of the window, Cass/Cuth/Visor.

DOES THAT IN ANY WAY IMPLICATE THAT SHE IS ALETTE HERSELF?
Answer: NO
There is absolutely no reason Cuth should be thinking she is Alette based on what she wrote, which is what his question was in response to.



Like, can anyone explain me this. Why would Cuth think Glossy is Alette herself, when Glossy writes like this: "Lassie, btw, is not Alette." <- She talks about Alette as a third person, not in any way leading to her being Alette.

The reason Cuth is asking this, is because he tries to distance them as scum partners, no other reason for him to ask that.

 

[Zack]

re: why I switched to Mat

I was starting to have doubts about Lassie, and wanted to avoid a runaway wagon, in hopes that it would force people into a voting situation that would create meaningful analysis later on. I intended to come back at eod but I lost track of time and didn't make it.

Vote: Lassie

Except I&#8217;m not picking 10 people at random&#8230; I&#8217;m picking people that responded to a scummy player and lynched a townie. Some of those people are dead now and we know they are town, further narrowing the list of potential scum. As a scum I would certainly consider pushing for an Arakhor lynch as it is an easily justifiable vote. It won&#8217;t require me to really have to defend it when push comes to shove. I&#8217;d bet top dollar that there is at least one scummer on that list, and absent any actual dead scummers it is a place to start in narrowing down our targets. We need to be focused at this point in the game.

I have been reading you pretty town this whole game, but your response is striking me as somewhat defensive in nature as your name is on that list as well. Something to think about.

As it stands I am not scum, and I had you as not scum, so that really puts our target onto just 4 players:

Choxorn
Murska
Xym
Lassie

I&#8217;d be fine with lynching any of these 4 today, and would certainly be open to deeper analysis on each of them.

My point was that the group of people is so large, relative to the size of the game, that saying at least one of them must be scum isn't meaningful analysis, because that would be true of even a randomly selected group of the same size. It was an "easily justifiable vote" because the reasoning was solid, even if the conclusion was wrong.

 

[Zack]

Cuth asking Glossy if she is Alette, now that Glossy revealed I wasn't Alette.

Look at Glossy's post where she says that I'm not Alette:


DOES THAT IN ANY WAY IMPLICATE THAT SHE IS ALETTE HERSELF?
Answer: NO
There is absolutely no reason Cuth should be thinking she is Alette based on what she wrote, which is what his question was in response to.



Like, can anyone explain me this. Why would Cuth think Glossy is Alette herself, when Glossy writes like this: "Lassie, btw, is not Alette." <- She talks about Alette as a third person, not in any way leading to her being Alette.

The reason Cuth is asking this, is because he tries to distance them as scum partners, no other reason for him to ask that.

honestly who cares? it's so trivial I don't see how it has any bearing on alignment

 

[Lassie]

Zack you're absolutely incredible at reading me scum. I can promise you, that if I were scum I would had NK'ed you so much at this point, just because of how annoying your read on me are

 

[Glossysushi]

Cuth asking Glossy if she is Alette, now that Glossy revealed I wasn't Alette.

Look at Glossy's post where she says that I'm not Alette:


DOES THAT IN ANY WAY IMPLICATE THAT SHE IS ALETTE HERSELF?
Answer: NO
There is absolutely no reason Cuth should be thinking she is Alette based on what she wrote, which is what his question was in response to.



Like, can anyone explain me this. Why would Cuth think Glossy is Alette herself, when Glossy writes like this: "Lassie, btw, is not Alette." <- She talks about Alette as a third person, not in any way leading to her being Alette.

The reason Cuth is asking this, is because he tries to distance them as scum partners, no other reason for him to ask that.

uhhhhhhhhh

what

?????????

why are you reading me as scum buddies with other people for them 'thinking' that you are Alette?

wouldn't that be distancing from you?

You were the one everyone thought was Alette......
are you okay?

 

[BSmith1068]

Can you tell me about Xym? I think that he/she (?) has been a light town read for most of the game for me, but that's mostly been a tone reason.

I also mentioned Murska's timing seeming weird.

Also, hi. You look fairly townie. Consider me pocketed.

I think that Zack is still town. Can you explain how you see his response as defensive? I didn't see anything wrong with it.

Not much on my end regarding Xym. I don't have a read one way or the other based on his posts.

I still have Zack as town, but I took his post as being somewhat defensive. His name is on the list and it would make sense to distance himself from that analysis if he was indeed scum. He also glossed over the reasons why the selection of 10 players isn't random. Just one way to interpret the post, given the broader context. Probably just me being paranoid though.

 

[Glossysushi]

Zack you're absolutely incredible at reading me scum. I can promise you, that if I were scum I would had NK'ed you so much at this point, just because of how annoying your read on me are

eww.

kill this with fire.

just no.

 

[Lassie]

uhhhhhhhhh

what

?????????

why are you reading me as scum buddies with other people for them 'thinking' that you are Alette?

wouldn't that be distancing from you?

You were the one everyone thought was Alette......
are you okay?

... Cuth is asking you if you are Alette, while it is super obvious that you were not Alette either, because of how you wrote the post saying that I wasn't her(you mentioned her in third person, meaning it wasn't you either, meaning it makes no sense for cuth to ask if you were her)

 

[Glossysushi]

Not much on my end regarding Xym. I don't have a read one way or the other based on his posts.

I still have Zack as town, but I took his post as being somewhat defensive. His name is on the list and it would make sense to distance himself from that analysis if he was indeed scum. He also glossed over the reasons why the selection of 10 players isn't random. Just one way to interpret the post, given the broader context. Probably just me being paranoid though.

Okay, I think I get that. I didn't see anything wrong with it because he'd posted similar posts before, talking about how he disliked D1, how he disliked certain things, how many things are just blah and bleh (uh, this is super general, but I hope that you get this because I'm not about to go back and find it).

So, I just took this as a prime example of him being pessimistic or just a grumpy pants?

 

[BSmith1068]

My point was that the group of people is so large, relative to the size of the game, that saying at least one of them must be scum isn't meaningful analysis, because that would be true of even a randomly selected group of the same size. It was an "easily justifiable vote" because the reasoning was solid, even if the conclusion was wrong.

I get that, but now that list is not 10 people given that some are dead and confirmed townie. Solid reasoning is the best place to be as a scum when placing votes. I could certainly be wrong, but I would bet that I am not.

 

[Lassie]

eww.

kill this with fire.

just no.

Lolol, 10 minutes ago you completely flipped on me, saying I was town again, and now that you see Zack still wanting to lynch me, you jump on that train

 

[Glossysushi]

... Cuth is asking you if you are Alette, while it is super obvious that you were not Alette either, because of how you wrote the post saying that I wasn't her(you mentioned her in third person, meaning it wasn't you either, meaning it makes no sense for cuth to ask if you were her)

.....



looooooooooooooooool

what even

 

[Glossysushi]

Lolol, 10 minutes ago you completely flipped on me, saying I was town again, and now that you see Zack still wanting to lynch me, you jump on that train

do you not remember me saying

that I lie about my reads to get reactions?



was seeing how you'd react to me town reading you.

it just made you compare me to beck and that was lol.

 

[Lassie]

@Zack the only reason you are alive ,despite being town read by most and in no way close to being a lynch target, is that they know you'll stubbornly return your scum read on me because I was wrong on Mat93