Aspiring Rapper's MAFIA- Game Thread

[Lassie]

- Have been all over the place since D1

That's part of solving the game and causing interactions

- Made a claim that is certainly not townie in nature, then pulled back hard saying you just made it up for “reactions”

I generally agree(although it's highly dependent on the specific case) - but that's not really a concern of mine when I'm town

- Initially demanded to know details of other players but didn’t want to give your own details.

I was having a little fun, because people thought I was someone else, so giving information about myself at that point, would just had revealed who I actually am. That is revealed now, and I have also provided links to other games of mine.
(and yes, I knew at some point either Glossy or myself would reveal that it was in fact me, since I knew Glossy knew it was me, since she asked me before game start)

- Basically have been shady and wishy washy all game

I'm also very suspicious of people actively trying to solve the game - how dare they!

- I am not voting for you now because frankly you have a lot of votes on you already and one more won’t really be helpful at all.

You should vote for who you believe is most likely scum, but I appreciate you're voting Mat>me though

 

[Zack]

Then why vote Mat?

edit: directed at edse

 

[Zack]

someone make a tally

 

[Lassie]

From what I could count: 6 votes on me, 5 votes on Mat, and 1-2 votes on Cuth, Murska and Endless

 

[KingMorgan]

I think Unvote Vote:Mat93 is a good alternative lynch. His day 1-2 posts had a lot of words but little substance, the late voting also ping'd me scumdar, also I think his suspects were the popular suspects d'jour, don't think I saw an original case from him.

You going to hop on too, Backwards Logic? This is the competing wagon you wanted

I knew Glossy knew it was me, since she asked me before game start

Was that conversation in your QT?

 

[Cuthillius]

Cuth, I'd like you to be more vocal - let us see a case on Mat93, because if he's the one you suspect the most, obviously you're aware that it isn't going to happen as things are going now. Why is Mat93 the person you want to see lynched the most?

Also, I'd like to see a top5 list of suspects from you, like the one Lohren and me have made.

Okay, I've been trying to be as quiet as possible just so's not to swell the post count and make it harder for people.

I can dig it up later if necessary, but my main case against Mat is the case he made against me that i refuted, he didn't respond, and then later he just requoted it when someone asked

dunno

seems rather consensusy

 

[Cuthillius]

top 5?
umm

Mat
chox
murska, maybe

i am not really sure, this game is very confusing

 

[Kennigit]

So also the one thing visor said that i remember day 2 was that with 2 night kills you could assume a smaller end of scum (4-5) instead of 5-6

But, any of ya'll think it is possible there may be designated killers than a "pick 2 team kill?"

Eg what if scum team were 2 killers, 1 power, and 3 "goons" or people who don't inherit the kill ability if a scum dies

Knowing the motives of the scum is important. Particularly because like Zack I care about why jarrema was killed and only jarrema

 

[Lassie]

Was that conversation in your QT?

Unfortunately I'm not part of any faction QT, mason QT or any of that sort.
She was the one linking the sign up thread so I saw it.

 

[Lassie]

So also the one thing visor said that i remember day 2 was that with 2 night kills you could assume a smaller end of scum (4-5) instead of 5-6

But, any of ya'll think it is possible there may be designated killers than a "pick 2 team kill?"

Eg what if scum team were 2 killers, 1 power, and 3 "goons" or people who don't inherit the kill ability if a scum dies

Knowing the motives of the scum is important. Particularly because like Zack I care about why jarrema was killed and only jarrema

This is third time Kennigit is in thread after he subbed for Newyn, and third time he seemingly are uninterested in sharing reads and commenting on anyone else than me.
Also, speculating on why the scums didn't get an extra NK this night, isn't really helping us much. Could be for many reasons; that it's an odd night vig, that it was RB'ed, that the target were protected, and more options than those.
The number of scums aren't edit: a main concern either
"But, any of ya'll think it is possible there may be designated killers than a "pick 2 team kill?""
Absolutely ridiculous - I've never seen a game with two faction kills for the scum team, and I doubt it would be the case in a game of this size. Obviously the extra N1 NK were from a PR of some sort.

 

[Zack]

No, obviously the extra N1 kill wasn't from a PR of some sort. Read the rules. All kills are mafia kills.

 

[Lassie]

No, obviously the extra N1 kill wasn't from a PR of some sort. Read the rules. All kills are mafia kills.

... obviously I'm aware it was a mafia kills since we don't have vigs on town team. What I mean, is that the extra kill was from a scum PR, like a scum vig of some sort.
Mat made it sound like scum could have 2 factional kills - I've never seen that in any game, so I doubt that would be the case here.

 

[Lassie]

the OP only excludes town vigs "No town vigs" and 3P roles like SK

 

[Lassie]

Anyway, the main point is that it's scummy of Kennigit to pop in to the thread only to say that ,while he has still not shared any noteworthy reads and has his vote on a town(me)

 

[Zack]

Scum have had 2 factional kills in plenty of games Pizza has hosted and in games where he hails from (totalwar.org), particularly in large vanilla games like this.

'scum vig' is an oxymoron. A vig is town by definition.

 

[Lassie]

Scum have had 2 factional kills in plenty of games Pizza has hosted and in games where he hails from (totalwar.org), particularly in large vanilla games like this.

'scum vig' is an oxymoron. A vig is town by definition.

Well, a role that has kills then. And if Pizza has hosted games with 2 factional kills for scum, then it's of course within possibility here. It's just not information that will really add anything to our chance of lynching a scum correctly.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Still sick, so I would welcome a hero doing a very accurate tally for me.

If it's a close one I will still have to recount manually, but the extra set of eyes helps guys.

Much appreciated. That way I can focus on giving you a writeup and a round ending on time.

 

[Al Sipsclar]

I apologize once again for my inactivity. My work-life-mafia balance got seriously out of whack, but I'm working on restoring the natural order.

I've looked at choxorn's ISO, and he seems alright. Yes, he lynched two townies (but who didn't?). Arakhor, for his hesitation to change his vote. Visor, by claiming PIS for him clearing townies (come on, this is what town Visor always does!) and the difference in perception of what "pushing for BL lynch all day" really meant. I've been told before, that people who claim seeing PIS, themselves have PIS ("He who smelt it, dealt it"). This, in my eyes, is the worst offence that choxorn has. The vote for Visor is bad, but can be attributed to townie paranoia. I guess that I, like Lohrenswald, am holding a grudge against choxorn for what he did in Madness!

I said before that I have too many town leans. Once again, the top two wagons are leaning town for me. Here are my leans atm (most on tone and scumhunting effort):

Town:
Zack
Cass_

Slight Town:
Lassie
Glossysushi
Cuthillius (only because of the CFD D1, scum didn't have to do it)
Mat93

Neutral:
Lohrenswald
Xym
choxorn

Slight Scum:
edse
landlubber
Takhisis
Legato Endless
BSmith1068

Unresolved:
Autolycus
Backwards Logic
Golden1Knight
KingMorgan
Murska
Newyn-enhanced Kennigit
Sooh

I'll support lynching anyone from the last three groups. Vote: Legato Endless

 

[Lassie]

Zack -> Mat93
landlubber -> Lassie
Takhisis -> Lassie
Xym -> Lassie
Mat93 -> Lassie
Autolycus -> Cuthilius
Lohrenswald -> Lassie
Murska -> Al Sipsclar
Cuthilius -> Mat93
Cass_ -> Legato
Golden1Knight -> Lassie
Backwards Logic -> Murska
KingMorgan -> Mat93
BSmith1068 -> Mat93
Kennigit -> Lassie
Lassie -> Mat93
edse -> Mat93

Lassie - 7
Mat93 - 6
Cuthilius - 1
Al Sipsclar - 1
Legato - 1
Murska - 1

So I'm actually in lead, which means it would be very nice if some more would vote Mat or change away from me, thanks!

 

[Lassie]

Zack -> Mat93
landlubber -> Lassie
Takhisis -> Lassie
Xym -> Lassie
Mat93 -> Lassie
Autolycus -> Cuthilius
Lohrenswald -> Lassie
Murska -> Al Sipsclar
Cuthilius -> Mat93
Cass_ -> Legato
Golden1Knight -> Lassie
Backwards Logic -> Murska
KingMorgan -> Mat93
BSmith1068 -> Mat93
Kennigit -> Lassie
Lassie -> Mat93
edse -> Mat93
Al Sipsclar -> Legato

Lassie - 7
Mat93 - 6
Legato - 2
Cuthilius - 1
Al Sipsclar - 1
Murska - 1

updated