On tarius: I suspect he is Palpatine, but his recent action makes me think he just has something IRL, in which case, logging of right now is the right choice. Thus, I will not pile on the ridiculouswagon against him. Now analysis (note that suspicous in the following list does not mean that there is a strong case for you being mafia, it means there is no strong case against you being mafia):
1. askthepizzaguy: Claimed R2D2, no counterclaim. R2D2 is probably in the game, thus
Town
2. Autolycus: Lurker.
Suspicious
3. azzaman333: Lurker.
Suspicious
4. Backwards Logic: Posted good analysis so far, so probably
Town
5. BSmith1068: He is usually much more active than this, so
Suspicious
6. Buddhafish:
Town, since his claim seems to match reality. It could be a cover role, with him making stuff up to fit it, but then how do you explain the night extension. The only alternative is that CH was the SK and sent no orders, but I hope our GM is better about replacements than that
7. CivCube:
Pro-Townish. Strong roleclaim, backed by existance of dead mason partner and no counterclaim.
8. CivGeneral: Lurker,
Suspicious
9. classical hero replaced by NinjaCow64: Posts a lot, with some analyis but still unsatisfactory IMO.
Suspicious
10. Darth Caesar:Lurker.
Suspicious
12. Gone 3 The Celt: Lurker.
Suspicious
13. Jarrema: Lurker.
Suspicious
15. johnhughthom: Probably
Town, since I dobt Civcube would have a PG to kill a mafia.
16. Kennigit:
Suspicious for attacking a role that is not anti-town, since we do not have a counterclaim
17. Mat93: Posts some good analysis, so probably
Town, but not sure
18. mechaerik: Lurker,
Suspicious
19. Mergle: You usually post more.
Suspicious
20. SamSniped: Lurker.
Suspicious
21. SouthernKing: Lurker.
Suspicious
22. spaceman98: Watto roleclaim with no counterclaim, so probalby
Town (Well, I know I am town, but...
)
23. Takhisis: Jar-Jar roleclaim with no counterclaim, so
Town
24. The Black Knigh. Wierd behavior at the start of this turn so
Suspicious
25. topsecret: Lurker.
Suspicious
26. traius: Player meltdown, but not necissarily scum. Either palpatine or a senator as both have stopping power. I will say
Suspicious of being Palpatine, though Palpatine's role in the comic is far les set than in the movie (have not yet gotten to the last scenes with the emperor, just the first movies) he is still a negative character.
28. Xenoneb: Lurker.
Suspicious
29. Zack: Posts often, but nothing to truely prove townieness.
Suspicious
This is a list of confirmed townies (to me). Everyone else is marked as suspicious but I will
vote: NinjaCow since you have posted often, but made little analysis.
