I wish to have multiple wives.

aneeshm said:
And by the way , if you really want four wives , convert to Islam .

Why they thay have to right to have 4 wives but I can't? Thats nothing but bloody discrimnation. Either have polygamy legal for everyone or illegal for everyone. No in between.
I should start a bloody protest.
 
I don't want multiple wives. One is enough. And, if you have multiple, jealousy comes up...
 
silver 2039 said:
Why they thay have to right to have 4 wives but I can't? Thats nothing but bloody discrimnation. Either have polygamy legal for everyone or illegal for everyone. No in between.
I should start a bloody protest.

"They" , as you call them , get to have four wives becuase their Prophet ( may Allah have him in his mercy ( you're supposed to say that every time you mention the Prophet , by the way ) ) was a man of rather generous appetites .

Another thing - if it is concubines you want , Islam has ample space for that . You can keep as many as you want .
 
aneeshm said:
"They" , as you call them , get to have four wives becuase their Prophet ( may Allah have him in his mercy ( you're supposed to say that every time you mention the Prophet , by the way ) ) was a man of rather generous appetites .

Another thing - if it is concubines you want , Islam has ample space for that . You can keep as many as you want .

I am not intrested in converting to Islam. I am quite happy with my atheisim thank you.

What angers me though is Muslims are allowed to have that many wives/concubines as they want while I can't? There is clealry a double standard at work here. While I have no intreast in having many wives it is a matter of princiapal over equality. If Muslims can have it there is no reason I should not.
 
mdwh said:
But if you're talking mating for life, why are you okaying serial monogamy? If you advocated only having one partner ever, then although I disagree, I would respect your viewpoint as being consistent. But you're still allowing yourself to have relationships one after the other (even if they last for 10 years or more) which isn't "mating for life".

Also, what has "for life" got to do anything? If you favour "for life", surely multiple relationships for life would be better than having several one after the other.

I said "ideally". You should not have sexual relations with any person unless you intend to remain faithful to that person as long as both of you are alive.
 
{|}$~\ said:
I said "ideally". You should not have sexual relations with any person unless you intend to remain faithful to that person as long as both of you are alive.
Of course. I'm not sure what that's got to do with having multiple versus single relationships however. Nowhere am I suggesting being unfaithful to one's partners.
 
"Faithful" includes "monogamous".
 
silver 2039 said:
I am not intrested in converting to Islam. I am quite happy with my atheisim thank you.

What angers me though is Muslims are allowed to have that many wives/concubines as they want while I can't? There is clealry a double standard at work here. While I have no intreast in having many wives it is a matter of princiapal over equality. If Muslims can have it there is no reason I should not.

Of course you're not interested in converting to islam . I was joking .
 
aneeshm said:
Of course you're not interested in converting to islam . I was joking .

well here in Canada NO religion can have multiple wives. We have gay weddings, eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeewwww but not multiple wives.Looks like our courts got SOMETHING right
 
Have you ever heard of an instance where a woman sought multiple husbands?

Anyway, I am speaking of the actual marriage itself. If one man has ten wives, or one woman has ten husbands, it's still demeaning to the wife or husband who is one of many.
 
cgannon64 said:
Have you ever heard of an instance where a woman sought multiple husbands?

Anyway, I am speaking of the actual marriage itself. If one man has ten wives, or one woman has ten husbands, it's still demeaning to the wife or husband who is one of many.

Yes in Indian mythology :p

Perhaps but as long as people are willing the option should be open.
 
I think that if polygamy was legalized worldwide, it would only be found in cultures where women are already demeaned, dehumanized, and barely able to think for themselves - or the male equivalent, though no such equivalent exists, as far as I know.

Legalizing polygamy would help keep these women downtrodden.
 
Be careful what you wish for, multiple wives = multiple headaches. One wife is quite enough for most men. I think what you really want is a harem -- there to meet your (ahem) appetite when you want them, but not putting any other demands on you or your time.
 
{|}$~\ said:
"Faithful" includes "monogamous".
Well, if you're using such a biased definition, then I reject that your version of "faithful" is anything necessarily good at all.

To me, the important points are keeping to promises or commitments you make to people, and not betraying them.
 
cgannon64 said:
Have you ever heard of an instance where a woman sought multiple husbands?
Yes. [Well, not multiple *husbands*, since that's illegal; similarly I haven't seen instances of men seeking multiple wives. I have however seen examples of multiple relationships of both types, and many more, and some of these people may wish to get married if it was possible.]

Anyway, I am speaking of the actual marriage itself. If one man has ten wives, or one woman has ten husbands, it's still demeaning to the wife or husband who is one of many.
Only if those people have no other partners, and are prevented from having other partners.

You also forget other possibilities, eg, a ring of four, not to mention including same-sex or mixed-sex groups, where there are many more possibile combinations.

I think that if polygamy was legalized worldwide, it would only be found in cultures where women are already demeaned, dehumanized, and barely able to think for themselves - or the male equivalent, though no such equivalent exists, as far as I know.
False, practicing multiple relationships already exists in our culture, as I stated earlier, albeit not widely known about, and the term "polygamy" is rarely used, because people either assume it means "marriage" which is illegal, or only consider "one man many women" as you yourself do.
 
Back
Top Bottom