To be clear Methos is a murderer and he is refusing to leave the ship by helicopter, it's not a solid case, and robbiecon couldn't have been behind anything last night. Plus I don't know what evidence he thinks he has on robbiecon, unless it's something regarding the aforementioned bomb. And it's at least as much Methos' fault as anyone else for allowing sprig, the rogue, to do whatever he was doing and pass around bombs.
NOTW XXXIX: Impending Retribution Game Thread
- Thread starter Backwards Logic
- Start date
Are you sure? Is that from rhawn's scan result or from something else?
Still, I'd have to agree that robbiecon seems guilty to me, and has seemed guilty for a while. That OMGUS vote sealed it.
Izipo
Hardcore casual gamer
I'm not buying it...
We're f***ed and unless something amazing happens we might as well scuttle the list, lest it falls in insurgents hands.
Robbiecon an insurgent, sure, why not. Why not Methos, too ?
We're f***ed and unless something amazing happens we might as well scuttle the list, lest it falls in insurgents hands.
Robbiecon an insurgent, sure, why not. Why not Methos, too ?
This post sets off my scumdar a bit. It sounds a bit forced, as an excuse to not vote for robbiecon. FoS: Izipo, and if robbiecon turns up guilty, then Izipo probably is, too.
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
Even if robbiecon turns up innocent, Izipo is also highly likely to be guilty in my opinion.
Frozen In Ice
Emperor
- Joined
- Jun 30, 2007
- Messages
- 1,536
I know for certain that Izipo repaired the magazine one night, not that that is an important room however.
Robbiecon give the Navigation Override to someone else like Rhawn or Earthling by midday. If you do you will be spared. The fact that you are ignoring me is making me even more suspicious of you.
Fos: Methos as well. You know better than to not give any details. Looks like your trying to divert attention away from yourself.
Robbiecon give the Navigation Override to someone else like Rhawn or Earthling by midday. If you do you will be spared. The fact that you are ignoring me is making me even more suspicious of you.
Fos: Methos as well. You know better than to not give any details. Looks like your trying to divert attention away from yourself.
Just so everyone understands how trusted you were with Renata, everyone should know that Renata never told Earthling who received the bomb from sprig. Especially when sprig gave the bomb to Renata and then she passed it on to someone. Yet Earthling, who claims to be so trustworthy, wasn't someone Renata felt she could trust to tell.
So then, if Renata didn't trust Earthling, then why should I?
Again, its because Renata didn't trust you. What's also interesting is that the person who has it doesn't trust you either, since they haven't told you either.
I was told that you show as a killer. Considering the same individual told me the same thing about Camikaze, then I tend to believe them.
I prefer Rhawn, as I trust him enough to promote him. Earthling I don't trust and its very obvious that Renata didn't trust him either. Therefore it makes sense to give it to Rhawn and not Earthling.
Sorry, RL is more important then this game, but when I'm left a message about someone being a killer I'm not going to waste time before spreading the information.
Note: One other last point to drive home. Everyone who has ever played with Renata before knows that when Renata believes she's going to be killed she passes on all of her info to those she trusted. In other words, several people know who has the bomb, yet none of them are telling Earthling.
Again, why should we trust you, Earthling?
No matter how much I don't trust Earthling, I'm not suggesting we string him up. I'm just pointing out how weightless his accusations and statements are.
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
It doesn't make sense if he's lying either in my opinion.
Frozen In Ice
Emperor
- Joined
- Jun 30, 2007
- Messages
- 1,536
Unless it actually isn't Rhawn's ability and him claiming the ability was all a well played ploy to get rogues to attack him. Hmm.
Oh and Izipo contacted me about repairing the magazine on night six.
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
Robbie has been scanned to be a killer, while Methos being a killer and/or being a foreign diplomat is mere speculation.
It does not make sense that Methos is lying and that he is a saboteur, for he will get counterclaimed and killed in an instant.
From this evidence, robbiecon is far more valuable a target for a lynch then any other.
It does not make sense that Methos is lying and that he is a saboteur, for he will get counterclaimed and killed in an instant.
From this evidence, robbiecon is far more valuable a target for a lynch then any other.
robbiecon for execution. There is no place for unaccounted for killers on this ship.
I'd have to say this explanation makes the most sense.
Yes, but Methos appears to be a killer too. Which one first, then?
Could I have the Swiss Army Knife?
edit: x-post!
It's not mere speculation. Methos is the foreign diplomat and killed at least two people so far. Renata after all trusted me and several others enough to tell us all about Methos, again how he spent his first few nights sending messages on the Bridge, had a "tape recorder" that he threatened to leave on loop to get Renata and other Innocents to cooperate with him (but then the party brought the attack by the foreigners anyway) and all of that. And he definitely killed askthepizzaguy, and killed sprig, his further capabilities are unknown but there's just as little reason to keep a neutral-at-best killer around.
If you also didn't notice:
Seon said:
Methos happened to get back that flak jacket that probably protects him from another nightkill, you know, the item that should have probably gone to protect Autolycus, one of our most important repairmen, but no... Plus why would the saboteurs want to waste their night actions attacking a neutral foreigner? Methos is pretty safe from anything besides the public threat of execution really. No one's saying he's a saboteur at this point, but he could lie about anything for his own gain, last I heard he'd been telling folks like CCRunner about someone who scans for "Good/Neutral/Evil" when there's clearly no such scanner around among any active player, probably all another ploy.
Seon, your fad of the day allegations against Izipo also don't speak well today. Forgotten about Takhisis so fast or decided randomly going after a next person is a good idea?
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
Actually, the guy who scans for good/neutral/evil is inactive, so your story falls apart there.
Frozen In Ice
Emperor
- Joined
- Jun 30, 2007
- Messages
- 1,536
Actually that's pretty much what Earthling said. I also like how you try to nit pick one part of his arguement so you can ignore the whole thing. Seon, you aren't doing yourself many favors in my eyes.
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
Probably so.
The point is that I was the one who told Methos about the scanner, whom I had known from...oh around night 2.
But I must argue that even if Methos is a neutral killer, he is definitely worth having around. A known serial killer can be controlled by the town's whims. He will have to cooperate as much as possible with the town, because if he doesn't he dies.
As of right now, I have no reason to believe that Methos cannot win with us. Therefore, he shall live.
As for flak jacket, I must disagree. The flak jacket sure didn't do muchto help Renata when she got shot in the head. I highly suspect that flak jacket won't be able to stop an axe-wielding maniac.
As for Takhisis, I don't think he's guilty at all. I just won't pass up an opportunity.
The point is that I was the one who told Methos about the scanner, whom I had known from...oh around night 2.
But I must argue that even if Methos is a neutral killer, he is definitely worth having around. A known serial killer can be controlled by the town's whims. He will have to cooperate as much as possible with the town, because if he doesn't he dies.
As of right now, I have no reason to believe that Methos cannot win with us. Therefore, he shall live.
As for flak jacket, I must disagree. The flak jacket sure didn't do muchto help Renata when she got shot in the head. I highly suspect that flak jacket won't be able to stop an axe-wielding maniac.
As for Takhisis, I don't think he's guilty at all. I just won't pass up an opportunity.
Similar threads
