Duke Blackstone
John Marchman
Out of Robbiecon and Methos, I guess Methos is the better choice.
NOTW XXXIX: Impending Retribution Game Thread
- Thread starter Backwards Logic
- Start date
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
Oh you can't be serious.
Frozen In Ice
Emperor
- Joined
- Jun 30, 2007
- Messages
- 1,536
Giving the navigation override back does point to robbiecon being innocent. I don't think Methos is a good target though. If we don't want to execute robbiecon how about we go after some of the other major saboteur suspects?
Actually until Robbiecon explains how he killed someone I think we should still execute him.
Actually until Robbiecon explains how he killed someone I think we should still execute him.
So, we have a choice between a possible serial killer who could be lying about a possible saboteur killing, an unknown scan ability, and said saboteur won't tell us where his claymores are, but did give the navigation card back.
Well, I was surerobbiecon was a wolf a while ago, but he did give the card back, which seems very un-wolfish, and he couldn't have been killing or saboteuring while he was in the brig, so I guess that leaves Methos.
And why am I still a leading saboteur suspect? I was repairing on a night with massive saboteur activity. For that matter, I still have the Monkey Wrench, so if you want me to use it to repair something tonight to account for my actions again, I'd be glad to do that.
Earthling- if you want me to search a room, I don't need a key- you should know how my ability works by now. I will need it if I want to repair the room, though, so I'll take the Key to the CIC and repair it tonight.
Earthling can has Assault Rifle.
rhawn can have the Armory Key
Duke Blackstone can have the Thunderfall Codes and the Nuclear Launch Key.
Well, I was sure
And why am I still a leading saboteur suspect? I was repairing on a night with massive saboteur activity. For that matter, I still have the Monkey Wrench, so if you want me to use it to repair something tonight to account for my actions again, I'd be glad to do that.
Earthling- if you want me to search a room, I don't need a key- you should know how my ability works by now. I will need it if I want to repair the room, though, so I'll take the Key to the CIC and repair it tonight.
Earthling can has Assault Rifle.
rhawn can have the Armory Key
Duke Blackstone can have the Thunderfall Codes and the Nuclear Launch Key.
robbiecon
Savoy Truffle
I have not killed anyone. I injured choxorn with my first planted claymore when he snuck into the Engine Room. I have placed my other 3 Claymores, but they have not gone off, even though, by my estimation, one should have gone off some nights ago. Which leads me to the conclusion that one of the people whom I have told the location of a Claymore has told someone else, perhaps allowing them to disarm the Claymore, having known the location. But my two main contacts were Renata and Winston Hughes, deceased innocents, who both suggested places for me to plant one.
With the Claymores planted, and the Navigation Override Card passed to Earthling, I have no more Night Actions. All that I have in my possession is the photo from Winston Hughes, which no-one has requested to look at yet.
With the Claymores planted, and the Navigation Override Card passed to Earthling, I have no more Night Actions. All that I have in my possession is the photo from Winston Hughes, which no-one has requested to look at yet.
Change of plans- I've just learned a very good reason to not go into the CIC. So, I'll let rhawn have the Key to that, instead. I'll repair the Deck or the Galley tonight, unless someone wants to give access to somewhere else or search something else.
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
You don't talk about that sort of stuff in thread, choxy.
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
Anyways, fine. I am willing to leave the darn ship.
robbiecon
Savoy Truffle
Backwards Logic said:
As you can see here, the Claymore I had placed in the Electrical Room did indeed go off, but you can also see Renata was not killed by it.
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
The big question is where the heck is rhawn.
Not really - we already have the brig scan result that robbiecon is supposedly a killer. We've already had a really bad false positive (an Innocent with no weapons or anything ever came up as a killer) and with robbiecon's job with the claymores and generally what he's done he's not necessarily guilty. So I'd rather give robbiecon a chance, for the helicopter at least. Even if we don't find out his alignment he'd be off the ship, thus the helicopter mission would be a success. Takhisis you ought to speak up if you want to helicopter robbiecon or Seon or anyone tonight, you really should.
Choxorn - I thought you had given the monkey wrench away but then I wasn't in charge of that. If not though, why didn't you repair last night too? I'm still serious, the number of repairs don't add up to the number of repairmen we should have had, and I think we have no reason to assume that Autolycus didn't manage to do some repairs. Also I'm fully aware you, choxorn, could get injured by a claymore if we sent you somewhere like the CIC but that's what I was recommending, puts you (and Seon possibly) to the test for actually using an ability at night
Choxorn - I thought you had given the monkey wrench away but then I wasn't in charge of that. If not though, why didn't you repair last night too? I'm still serious, the number of repairs don't add up to the number of repairmen we should have had, and I think we have no reason to assume that Autolycus didn't manage to do some repairs. Also I'm fully aware you, choxorn, could get injured by a claymore if we sent you somewhere like the CIC but that's what I was recommending, puts you (and Seon possibly) to the test for actually using an ability at night
rhawn
Emperor
I'm sorry I had a busy Saturday. Ill read up and give my opinions within the next couple hours.
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
Choxorn - I thought you had given the monkey wrench away but then I wasn't in charge of that. If not though, why didn't you repair last night too? I'm still serious, the number of repairs don't add up to the number of repairmen we should have had, and I think we have no reason to assume that Autolycus didn't manage to do some repairs. Also I'm fully aware you, choxorn, could get injured by a claymore if we sent you somewhere like the CIC but that's what I was recommending, puts you (and Seon possibly) to the test for actually using an ability at night
Might be worth trying.
Choxorn, mind walking into the explosive device again?
Choxorn - I thought you had given the monkey wrench away but then I wasn't in charge of that. If not though, why didn't you repair last night too? I'm still serious, the number of repairs don't add up to the number of repairmen we should have had, and I think we have no reason to assume that Autolycus didn't manage to do some repairs. Also I'm fully aware you, choxorn, could get injured by a claymore if we sent you somewhere like the CIC but that's what I was recommending, puts you (and Seon possibly) to the test for actually using an ability at night
I asked a couple of people who to give it to, but nobody ever gave me an answer.
I'd repair, but I could only repair the Deck or Galley, neither of which was damaged very much, and given a choice between giving something +1 health and being immune to night kills, I'll take the night-kill immunity unless I have a good reason not to.
No thanks, I'd rather not blow myself up again. I'd be happy to repair a room that contains no claymore, though.
Seon
Not An Evil Liar
No no no, it will be fine. I will be there to heal you this time. It will all feel like rainbows and bunnies in the sick bay, I promise you.
Do not mind the cadavers. Those were leftovers from the previous occupants of this shi, I mean,lynchings.
Somehow, that isn't very re-assuring.
Regardless of whether I blow myself up or repair something on the ship, I'll still be doing something you can account for. If I blow myself up, I'm useless to you for a day, or 2 if Seon doesn't heal me again. If I repair something, it will get a very slight repair boost, and you can keep the claymore in the CIC for someone else to walk into it, and prevent the saboteurs from attacking it and taking all our defense systems offline. Which one sounds like a better idea?
Regardless of whether I blow myself up or repair something on the ship, I'll still be doing something you can account for. If I blow myself up, I'm useless to you for a day, or 2 if Seon doesn't heal me again. If I repair something, it will get a very slight repair boost, and you can keep the claymore in the CIC for someone else to walk into it, and prevent the saboteurs from attacking it and taking all our defense systems offline. Which one sounds like a better idea?
I'm finding this rather hilarious. Now Earthling wants to fly robbiecon off the ship? Wow.I have no idea who the alignment prophet is and until Seon contacted me, I didn't even know I'd been scanned. I'll say it again, I have no idea who the scanner is, though I do have a guess.
It's my understanding that some of you have suggested that we only have a couple of days left until the game is over, so I might as well state that there's no point in attempting to lynch me. I'll simply stop it from happening, which means you then have to spend two days to lynch me, which only screws us over more. It would be wiser to have me vig killed if you all want me dead that much.
Lynch Robbie.
Yeah, it's really haha funny that Renata didn't get you killed back like Day four after she had it all wrapped up that you were a foreign diplomat and caused that jet fighter attack, so you had nothing left to threaten us with.
But yes, I agree with the assessment we might only be a couple days from the ship sinking - or killing enough saboteurs in time. However I think you could easily be bluffing that we can't execute you today. If not I've already given my second suggestion on who to lynch. We still might have enough days of voting, vig-kills, and then helicopter rides altogether to get a lot of people taken care of.
But yes, I agree with the assessment we might only be a couple days from the ship sinking - or killing enough saboteurs in time. However I think you could easily be bluffing that we can't execute you today. If not I've already given my second suggestion on who to lynch. We still might have enough days of voting, vig-kills, and then helicopter rides altogether to get a lot of people taken care of.
Similar threads
