aneeshm
Deity
Ahmad said:No more than someone who thinks that [insert religion here] is a very backward and barbaric religion would scare you.
Anyway, your second setiment allows me to relax knowing that you're not an islamophobe, racist, or some kind of extremist.
So no.. you don't scare me at all. Then again the question wasn't directed to me was it?![]()
It was directed to the thread starter .
And my opinion of Islam is based on three things - firstly , the actions that are sanctioned in the figh , hadis , and Quran , and secondly , the histories of the converted lands , and thirdly , the inherently expansionist , exclusivist , and political nature of Islam . This judgment , however , can only be extended to full believers of the Quran ( and all the other literature on Islamic jurisprudence ) . In fact , it is my belief ( based on my observations ) that almost all monotheistic religions tend to degenerate into barbarism .
Have no fear that I will judge you on the basis of you religion - I've got a few Muslim friends myself .
I don't want to threadjack , but I've noticed that Muslims in India who come from the middle or upper classes tend to undergo tremendous mental torture , because in school they are taught that all religions are inerently equal , while their entire way of life in their self-imposed ghetto is built around the idea that they are a persecuted set of believers in a land of Kafirs , in one of the few places which they and Islam failed in converting into a Dar-ul-Islam in spite of six hundred years of Islamic rule .
To give a more concrete example : I had recently attended a debate contest where a number of schools participated . One of the schools was an Islamic girls' school , and another was a totally secualr , normal school . The girls from the Islamic school actually wore the Hijab as their uniform ( though admittedly it wasn't black ) , complete with headscarf . The participant from the secular school was , coincidentially , also a Muslim . She , however , wore a normal school uniform . The contrast was stark . The girl from the secular school went on to win the contest . In their attempt to preserve a separate identity , I think the Muslims of India went too far and rejected modernity .