Soul Scourge [Game Thread - Concluded]

[Kennigit]

The town awoke to an unfamiliar site in this overcast and dark winter: A sunrise fresh over plains!

Moreover, it seemed no one died during the night!

"Well we gotta lynch somebody*"

So the voting began!

*sidenote: no lynch is an option

Day 4 ends in:
[TIMER=3/4/2015 10:00 PM PST; Day 4 Over][/TIMER]​

All updates linked in post 2

 

[Zack]

Vote: Verarde didn't vote yesterday. Maybe scourge are inactive?

 

[spaceman98]

Or could be spearmen did their job well.

Remember, there's two scourges. It would be very unlikely for both scourges to be inactives.

 

[Visorslash]

Vote: zack why would they suddenly become inactive? Pretty easy vote there

 

[Zack]

Vote: zack why would they suddenly become inactive? Pretty easy vote there

Well what else is there to go on?

 

[Jarrema]

I will vote: Verarde

I wan to hear why he didnt answer at all to my cooperation proposal

 

[Verarde]

Whoooops, thought I voted yesterday...getting confused between this game and None Shall Pass.

Zack, I agree with you that inactivity is something we should look at. Therefore I will vote: remake20.

 

[SamSniped]

Vote: remake20 for now, until he speak up.

 

[spaceman98]

I don't think that lynching inactives is the right plan. Inactivity vs. activity generally is determined by real life or other online commitments, not by team alignment. In general, mafia will be active but unhelpful, not totally inactive. Posting every phase is a minimum that almost everyone who can will meet, at minimum to avoid the WOG.

Therefore vote: Zack. Easy vote, and the other cases are worse.

 

[Zack]

You don't think no kill could indicate inactivity? What other reasoning is there to go on for a lynch?

 

[spaceman98]

I think No Kill indicates that spearmen +bowmen +shamans got lucky. We've got three days worth of content in thread. Surely we, as town, can do better than ignoring them? In this game, we have no free information being dispensed upon us at night by scanning roles. We have to actually look at the thread to stand a chance of winning.

 

[remake20]

Zack for the lazy vote. I'm not a huge fan of spaceman either as his posts just seem kinda scummy to me. This seems very standard so far and there's not a lot to go on. I'm not sure how much private communication has gone on, but it should probably increase if we hope to find the scourge. I will do my part when I get some more time tonight. Remake out.

 

[Zack]

Zack for the lazy vote. I'm not a huge fan of spaceman either as his posts just seem kinda scummy to me. This seems very standard so far and there's not a lot to go on. I'm not sure how much private communication has gone on, but it should probably increase if we hope to find the scourge. I will do my part when I get some more time tonight. Remake out.

Are you kidding me? You jump third on a ridiculous bandwagon because my vote is lazy? At least I put more thought in it beyond "well spaceman and Visor are voting for him, might as well join them." Give me a break, this is ridiculous. Unvote, Vote: remake20

I think No Kill indicates that spearmen +bowmen +shamans got lucky. We've got three days worth of content in thread. Surely we, as town, can do better than ignoring them? In this game, we have no free information being dispensed upon us at night by scanning roles. We have to actually look at the thread to stand a chance of winning.

Yeah, and I looked at the thread and saw two people with questionable activity and a lack of a night kill.

 

[Zack]

Are you kidding me? You jump third on a ridiculous bandwagon because my vote is lazy?

Meant to emphasize "my" to highlight that remake's vote is way lazier than mine.

 

[Visorslash]

There were kills night 1 and 2 though.

 

[spaceman98]

Zack for the lazy vote. I'm not a huge fan of spaceman either as his posts just seem kinda scummy to me. This seems very standard so far and there's not a lot to go on. I'm not sure how much private communication has gone on, but it should probably increase if we hope to find the scourge. I will do my part when I get some more time tonight. Remake out.

None because of these

Also, does my username say Askthepizzaguy? Why the hell are people randomly roleclaiming to me already?

In all honesty role claiming is quite stupid in this game as scum knowing the distribution of roles is bad.


No, based on how you are deciding to go about this game.

posts and Sprig's day 1 lynch

Sprig was trying to gather swordsmen together. Its worth noting that I voted for and pushed the Sprig lynch, because scourges knowing who the swordsmen are (and absorbing their attack) would have been awful.

My personal belief was that defensive roles should network for mutual protection, but TBH we've been doing fine in terms of night defense as it is (scourges never got to make two kills). We just need to get our **** together when it comes to the lynch.

 

[Visorslash]

NSP 2 is chewing up activity for this game and we don't have an active playerbase atm anyway.

In any case, does anyone know a game where Samsniped was scum? I'd like to take a look at him.

If there are any swordsmen left, I'd like to organise you guys in thread.

 

[Visorslash]

1) Visorslash - town
2) Zack - unsure as of yet, he's normally quieter as scum, but he also has to host a game as well
6) remake20 - inactive mostly, bandwagon vote on zack is something that i suspect he knows he'll be voted for which is strange. guessing town based on the behaviour
8) samsniped - feel scum
9) count dingdong - inactive
10) Jarrema - no real read which annoys me
11) verarde - inactive
13) spaceman98 - tried to network early on - maybe trying to infiltrate network - lean town atm

 

[Visorslash]

Glad to hear it, remake

Not glad to hear about the lynch though.

I mean, this just screams scum to me to be honest.

 

[Zack]

There were kills night 1 and 2 though.

I was just spitballing. Apparently that's a lynchworthy offense now.