Why are flowers considered romantic gifts? I mean, they've pretty, but what would a woman actually do with them? Is it just a holdover from when women were expected to be homemakers?
Any contemporary drama on TV shows what happens. The guy turns up at the door with flowers, the woman looks surprised, gives them a cursory sniff, and says she'll find a vase to put them in. After that the flowers are never mentioned unless the woman wants to know what the occasion is or someone else wants to know why she received flowers, and from whom.
I don't own a vase, at least not any big enough for flowers. If anyone turned up here with real flowers, I'd be hard-pressed to find anything to put any medium to large bouquet in. I'd probably have to empty out one of the plastic containers I keep Maddy's dry cat food in.
Flowers are considered pretty, delicate, and fragrant. It's supposed to be meant as a compliment.
But for people like me who are allergic to them, anyone giving me flowers would earn a "thank you" and I'd quickly put them somewhere out of breathing range. If it was someone who knows I'm allergic, I'd be wondering why they're trying to kill me. I can't even stand to be in the same room with a poinsettia - they're really not scentless.
It's a sad fact that when I lived in my house, there were a couple of days in spring when everything in the back yard was in bloom at the same time - crab apple tree, plum trees, lilacs (both kinds), and a couple of other trees. Gorgeous to look at, but I didn't dare go outside to enjoy it.
Vincour said:
Depending on the woman there may be alternatives to what they consider a romantic gesture. Chocolates, for some, can be romantic. A gift, for others, can be romantic. Then you head into unusual territory where for some people a romantic gesture is doing a difficult chore, helping them out with a problem, or gifting them something eccentric that appeals specifically to their interests.
One year my dad's girlfriend pushed him into doing the "traditional Valentine's Day" present she thought suitable for a father to give his daughter. So he gave me a white teddy bear and a box of chocolates. The bear was cute, but the problem with the chocolates is that they had ingredients to which I was allergic. Not his fault; he didn't know, and even I didn't realize until I tried one.
After that when he explained about his girlfriend's suggestion, I told him that what he'd been doing already was just fine. So he happily went back to shopping at the hardware store for my Christmas and birthday presents (either blank VHS tapes, since this was in the day when everyone had VCRs) or something to do with my crafts - new knives, some more glue sticks, some kind of storage bin for the various small bits of stuff needed to make the things I sold).
My boyfriend at that time knew flowers were out of the question, so he got me a scented candle. Sadly, that wasn't any safer; it was a problem, even still wrapped and unlit. It was pretty, though, so I put it up on a high shelf where I could see it but wouldn't smell it. After that he stuck to things he knew I was interested in... nicely painted little wooden box I use for my D&D dice, and a new goblet for SCA feasts.
Vincour said:
Cue the clueless romantic giving his beloved a handful of basil leaves instead of the flower.
Basil is among the worst of the things to which I'm allergic, at least in its raw form. It produces an instant migraine.
So the lesson here is: Before you decide to give your romantic partner (or other sort of friend) a gift, make an effort to find out what allergies they have.