Dreadnought
Deity
Like I said before, it doesn't matter if you're scum in game 1, 2, or 3... you're going to act scummy every day.
TRIMAFIA [Game Thread]
- Thread starter Zack
- Start date
Like I said before, it doesn't matter if you're scum in game 1, 2, or 3... you're going to act scummy every day.
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
Darn. Can I has dead quick topic?
cardith_lorda
Warlord
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2012
- Messages
- 180
vote: Mat93 - All I want is some sleep between these crazy days, and then he started yelling and pointing figures. Just let me get some rest!
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
well because, as a townie in all three games, I don't really care who I vote for as there is a good enough chance they are scum in one of the games.
people that care the most are people who are scum in 1 game or 2 games, know that, and wish to win the other games with their mafia teammates and also win as town in one. I.e. people who were mafia this game, xenoneb and samsniped, didn't know each other were mafia in this game, and couldn't try to do silly little bandwagon things game 1 and 2 if needed.
Though I asked the GMs before the game started and they never confirmed nor denied that would be the case [that mafia do not know each other in future games at the start], but guessing by getting townie role PMs in game 2 after game 1 finished its phase I assume it is universally* true
which yeah, I didn't scum hunt in this game (or really not at all).
*huehuehue because we're universe hopping
Everybody should join Jarrema's game:
http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showthread.php?595727-Savanna-Mafia
http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showthread.php?595727-Savanna-Mafia
Back.
Bot sure why we lynched either of them - ninja was 85% meta confirmed in this game, and I see no case as to scummy play in previous days, while I thought Optical was making some sense.
A semi-confirmed townie in this game shouldn't have been the target of what I see as a random lynch.
I'm not particularly liking Kennigt play lately - I don't see how putting reason/scumhunting into votes today helps scum in other games rather then town.
And if you're suggesting that we shouldn't be finger pointing at illogical behaviour like ninjas lynch then :rolleye:
Bot sure why we lynched either of them - ninja was 85% meta confirmed in this game, and I see no case as to scummy play in previous days, while I thought Optical was making some sense.
A semi-confirmed townie in this game shouldn't have been the target of what I see as a random lynch.
I'm not particularly liking Kennigt play lately - I don't see how putting reason/scumhunting into votes today helps scum in other games rather then town.
I'm not sure what you're trying to say here, obviously people won't forget alignments between games - but obviously game 3 scum won't be acting scummy day 1 or 2...so I'm not sure why you're attacking spaceman here.
And if you're suggesting that we shouldn't be finger pointing at illogical behaviour like ninjas lynch then :rolleye:
Dreadnought
Deity
Of course they will. What difference does it make if they're only scum in one game? If they get lynched in one game they're dead in all three. They'll exhibit scummy behavior in all three games.
I'm defending spaceman. Have you read any of the posts since the end of day?
Not only do I think Ninja's lynch was a mistake now, I thought it before the lynch happened. You're completely contorting my words. Please reread what I said in the thread.
Dreadnought
Deity
Darth Feather, MartinLuther, sirtommygunn, Double A, and azzaman333. I'm 95% confident that a scum's hiding amongst these guys in at least one game.
I'd wager roughly 1/4 to 1/3 of the players are scum in a game. You could pick any random five names and say someone's a scum in that list.
azzaman333
meh
Care to share your thoughts on why? Because basic probability says that you could pick any 5 people at random, and its quite likely at least one of them is scum in at least one game.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Apologies if I mistook your intent, but to me this:
Was a strong expression of support for the two, so I suppose I addressed their views through you.
As to misreading intent, umm:
And scum wouldn't know they were until after that point so I'm not sure what you're trying to say. Sure scum in day 4/5 will play in a scummy mindset (and possibly more so as they are playing against scumbuddies between formats?) but that doesn't apply in days 1/2 when they didn't even have their roles.
Was a strong expression of support for the two, so I suppose I addressed their views through you.
As to misreading intent, umm:
I think I quite clearly stated day 1/2 we wouldn't get scummy reads from them.
And scum wouldn't know they were until after that point so I'm not sure what you're trying to say. Sure scum in day 4/5 will play in a scummy mindset (and possibly more so as they are playing against scumbuddies between formats?) but that doesn't apply in days 1/2 when they didn't even have their roles.
Err well done, you manage to defend spaceman (for legitimate reasons) with a unclear post that simply states you think people will be suspicious day 3. Very impressive job defending! /sarcasm
I have reread, and can only find you making an unuseful remark about the town sheeping. I realise I mistook your intent earlier, but please don't act like I'm not reading the thread properly, you're not exactly being a very clear poster, and claiming you were right about everything hardly helps if your not going to take the time to discuss and argue it.
End of Night Three
Two prisoners died this night. One, Dumanios, had been bludgeoned to death with a carpet slipper, and another, BigTin, was found peacefully sleeping or not, he had actually been smothered with a pillow. Since no true American patriot would be as cowardly as to attack by night, it was concluded that both were town.
Spoiler :
Vote for a lynch in bold! Unvote with the unvote tag or strike the name out for the GM's ease of mind, and that of his mom's!
There is [TIMER="4/29/2013, 1:00 AM UTC"]no time[/TIMER] left for this phase.
Kennigit.
Horrible post and reasoning.
I really dislike the pushing of "I'm a townie in all three games" which he seems to be trying to reinforce, and the pushing the idea that those putting effort into the game are scum - feels like lurker scum trying to breeze through.
All in all, it seems like a typical lurker scum, trying to appear helpful while avoiding effort and throwing flak on anyone who puts work in.
spaceman98
Plotting something
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2010
- Messages
- 3,639
vote: Kennigit. I agree with the above.
Also, is it Zack's game now?
Also, is it Zack's game now?
