Kmart_Elvis
King
This thread is moderator approved.
It's been several months since the release of Gathering Storm, so let's kick off with the first elimination game. Last year we did an elimination thread for unique units, but quite a bit has changed since Rise and Fall. Not only do we have more unique units, but strategic resources are in play now, as well as rebalancing of existing units and combat in general.
Rules
Top Tier (S)
1) Pítati Archer (Nubia)
2) Toa (Maori)
3) War-Cart (Sumeria)
4) Eagle Warrior (Aztecs)
5) Legion (Rome)
6) Hetairoi (Alexander/Macedon)
7) Jong (Indonesia)
8) Janissary (Suleiman/Ottomans)
Upper Tier (A)
9) Conquistador (Spain)
10) Varu (India)
11) Minas Gereas (Brazil)
12) Digger (Australia)
13) Immortal (Persia)
14) Hypaspist (Macedon)
15) Warak'aq (Inca)
16) Mamluk (Arabia)
Above Average Tier (B)
17) Black Army (Corvinus/Hungary)
18) Cossack (Russia)
19) Viking Longship (Harald/Norway)
20) Redcoat (Victoria/England)
21) Winged Hussar (Poland)
22) Barbary Corsair (Ottomans)
23) De Zeven Provinciën (Netherlands)
24) Mandekalu Cavalry (Mali)
Below Average Tier (C)
25) Huszàr (Hungary)
26) Ngao Mbeba (Kongo)
27) Bireme (Phoenicia)
28) Samurai (Japan)
29) Mountie (Canada)
30) Keshig (Mongolia)
31) Rough Rider (Teddy Roosevelt/America)
32) Hwacha (Korea)
Lower Tier (D)
33) Impi (Zulu)
34) Carolean (Sweden)
35) Maryannu Chariot Archer (Egypt)
36) Malón Raider (Mapuche)
37) Sea Dog (England)
38) Khevsur (Georgia)
39) Garde Imperiale (France)
40) Okihtcitaw (Cree)
Bottom Tier (F)
41) Domrey (Khmer)
42) Saka Horse Archer (Scythia)
43) Crouching Tiger (China)
44) Hoplite (Greece)
45) Berserker (Norway)
46) U-boat (Germany)
47) Highlander (Scotland)
48) P-51 Mustang (America)
It's been several months since the release of Gathering Storm, so let's kick off with the first elimination game. Last year we did an elimination thread for unique units, but quite a bit has changed since Rise and Fall. Not only do we have more unique units, but strategic resources are in play now, as well as rebalancing of existing units and combat in general.
Rules
- Only strength of units/usefulness is compared. This also includes, range, cost of the units, availability and whether it can evolve from earlier units/to later units.
- Vote roughly once per 24 hours. Voting significantly earlier must be explained.
- Add one point to a unit, take away three points from a different unit.
- You must give a reason. Posts without reason will not be counted until a reason will be added.
- Voting for the same unit several times is not forbidden, however try to spread your votes around and be fair in your assessments.
Top Tier (S)
1) Pítati Archer (Nubia)
2) Toa (Maori)
3) War-Cart (Sumeria)
4) Eagle Warrior (Aztecs)
5) Legion (Rome)
6) Hetairoi (Alexander/Macedon)
7) Jong (Indonesia)
8) Janissary (Suleiman/Ottomans)
Upper Tier (A)
9) Conquistador (Spain)
10) Varu (India)
11) Minas Gereas (Brazil)
12) Digger (Australia)
13) Immortal (Persia)
14) Hypaspist (Macedon)
15) Warak'aq (Inca)
16) Mamluk (Arabia)
Above Average Tier (B)
17) Black Army (Corvinus/Hungary)
18) Cossack (Russia)
19) Viking Longship (Harald/Norway)
20) Redcoat (Victoria/England)
21) Winged Hussar (Poland)
22) Barbary Corsair (Ottomans)
23) De Zeven Provinciën (Netherlands)
24) Mandekalu Cavalry (Mali)
Below Average Tier (C)
25) Huszàr (Hungary)
26) Ngao Mbeba (Kongo)
27) Bireme (Phoenicia)
28) Samurai (Japan)
29) Mountie (Canada)
30) Keshig (Mongolia)
31) Rough Rider (Teddy Roosevelt/America)
32) Hwacha (Korea)
Lower Tier (D)
33) Impi (Zulu)
34) Carolean (Sweden)
35) Maryannu Chariot Archer (Egypt)
36) Malón Raider (Mapuche)
37) Sea Dog (England)
38) Khevsur (Georgia)
39) Garde Imperiale (France)
40) Okihtcitaw (Cree)
Bottom Tier (F)
41) Domrey (Khmer)
42) Saka Horse Archer (Scythia)
43) Crouching Tiger (China)
44) Hoplite (Greece)
45) Berserker (Norway)
46) U-boat (Germany)
47) Highlander (Scotland)
48) P-51 Mustang (America)
Last edited: