Would you rather be dumb and happy or brilliant and miserable?

DH or BM


  • Total voters
    88
Brilliant as in IQ test kind of brilliant? High marks in school? Or brilliant as in being able to adapt to whatever life throws at you, or being especially creative?.
The third you mentioned is most important. It is survival of the fittest after all (not survival of the isolated tortured genius).
 
I'd like to think I'm not vain enough to choose the wrong option (brilliant and miserable), but I dunno.
 
Dumb and happy. If I was miserable, there might be a chance I'd off myself. Could you imagine another brilliant mind killing himself? It'd be an absolute waste!

Better to be dumb and happy as I would never have been brilliant.
 
I was brilliant and miserable once. I'd rather be somewhere in between.
 
I'm not happy if I don't have knowledge.
 
If you're truly brilliant, wouldn't you find a way to make yourself happy? I guess if I couldn't then I would be dumb and happy.
 
The OP doesn't even give reasons why these pairs are together. :dunno:
 
Simply being 'above average' isnt exactly brilliant.

I think the point is that the people who are of above average intelligence value this attribute, and would prefer to be brilliant (e.g. more smart) than to lose their intelligence. I don't see how this is hard to comprehend.
 
I think that's the problem -- people who are already pretty smart would want to be very, very smart, whereas happy people are perfectly content being happy. I think being constantly dissatisfied with your own achievements or intellectual ability would make you pretty miserable.
 
I think the point is that the people who are of above average intelligence value this attribute, and would prefer to be brilliant (e.g. more smart) than to lose their intelligence. I don't see how this is hard to comprehend.

/shrug. Again, one of the people that I have respected more in life than anyone else was an aunt of mine who probably didnt break 3 digits for her IQ....and yet, she was one of the happiest, generous, most wholesome people I have ever met in my life.

I value my intelligence. But I am 'brilliant' enough to realize that simply being intelligent in of itself doesnt necessarily impart wisdom about life, or automatic enjoyment of it.

For me, life is short enough, I have no time to be 'miserable' for any amount of it. Thats just a deal breaker - even for brilliance.
 
You did you become dumb?
I think you meant "How did...". It's antidepressant drugs. Before the drugs, I was capable of extreme focus on mental tasks, whether they were artistic or left-brained. Now, that capability for incredible focus is nearly entirely gone. 'Twould be nice to have it back, without the soul crushing depression and permanent anxiety. Also, that extreme focus capability I used to have was only infrequent, so I'm not really missing too much.
 
I think you meant "How did...". It's antidepressant drugs. Before the drugs, I was capable of extreme focus on mental tasks, whether they were artistic or left-brained. Now, that capability for incredible focus is nearly entirely gone. 'Twould be nice to have it back, without the soul crushing depression and permanent anxiety. Also, that extreme focus capability I used to have was only infrequent, so I'm not really missing too much.
Which drugs, out of curiosity? Not that I plan to take pharmaceutical psychoactives ever again (except maybe in an emergency for sleep), I'm just curious to know which drugs are effecting you this way.
 
Life is completed not when you have awards, a career, luxuries, knowledge. It is complete when you are happy.

I choose dumb and happy.
 
We talked about it already. Zoloft and Sertraline (the generic).
Hmm, actually Sertraline is one I've never heard of, is it new?

I only lasted a few weeks on Zoloft, it got to the point I couldn't sleep at all, it's funny how different drugs effect different people though, Effexor for example made me manic as hell but I knew one girl it actually calmed down. The only drug I feel gave me significant brain damage was Ritalin which I was on in my formative years.
 
/shrug. Again, one of the people that I have respected more in life than anyone else was an aunt of mine who probably didnt break 3 digits for her IQ....and yet, she was one of the happiest, generous, most wholesome people I have ever met in my life.

Well, 50% of the population doesn't break 3 digits for their IQ... I would hope most people wouldn't automatically discount this half of the population from being worthy of their respect.
 
Life wouldn't be fun if I wasn't miserable. Brilliant and miserable.
 
Back
Top Bottom