Ask a Soldier

First of all, only special forces get to use them anyway (and some CP RMP units have them I think). For an SAS soldier to put 2 rounds on a rifle target from twenty paces is good going - basically; double-tapped shots to the head from combat distance (bearing in mind that a pistol is a CQB weapon and so is unlikely to ever have to shoot further than about 30 yards). Ordinary squaddies would be looking to hit the enemy soldier at ten paces.
 
What he meant was that in the case of a Soviet invasion of NATO territory, the Germans are just there to clog up the Soviet meat-grinder.
 
Correct. They exist to get killed, which they're pretty good at.

BTW; no offence meant. If you ask anyone from the forcess their opinion of another country's military, it will generally be bad.

Don't the Australians have a pretty good reputation, though?

ANZACs are very good, as are the Ghurkas (especially at drinking). That's only because their decent ones turf up and join the Empire, though ;)
 
Correct. They exist to get killed, which they're pretty good at.

BTW; no offence meant. If you ask anyone from the forcess their opinion of another country's military, it will generally be bad.



ANZACs are very good, as are the Ghurkas (especially at drinking). That's only because their decent ones turf up and join the Empire, though ;)

No, no, the decent ones stay in the NZ army so they can thrash English army rugby teams often ;)
I'm sure we in support company took on a Para team in Malaya, cause the mad sod propping against me was only around thirteen stone.
Brave as lions but too small and it was obvious a lot of them had played sod all rugby.

I thought I was the only one to have used the worlds best military all round bolt action rifle on this board.
I was in the cadets at the time, and we had a retired Sergeant from the Small arms school corps teaching us the forth finger trigger method.
Great way to get a lot of rounds down range :D
 
Sorry, not reading through 9 pages to see if these have been asked.

If one of your friends gets killed by the "enemy"(whoever it is) do you consider the enemy soldier who shot them a murderer?

Do you think women should be allowed to serve in the military?

Did you ever consider quitting the military in those 25 years?
 
If one of your friends gets killed by the "enemy"(whoever it is) do you consider the enemy soldier who shot them a murderer?

I'm broadly philosophical about that sort of thing - while he's shooting, stabbing and all the rest at me and I'm giving him the same back, he's still an ordinary bloke who has a favorite band and an opinion on politicians. Since I don't consider myself a murderer for shooting dozens of people like him, I don't consider him one. I'll still shoot him back, though, and I once got a bit of a name for myself by leading what was meant to be a section on a bayonet charge and ended up as just me - fun times!

Do you think women should be allowed to serve in the military?

I don't buy the idea that all women are inherently not good enough. IMO, if a woman can pass the selection then she's fit for any regiment - but not alongside men, since that raises deeper issues (the Israelis have real problems with that). I support the founding of a Women's Royal Infantry Corps for that reason.

Did you ever consider quitting the military in those 25 years?

You have no idea how many times. Generally just after a tour you get back and you think 'I've done my bit, I've got my medals, time to go' but something made me stay on for a very long time. I actually only left when I felt in danger of becoming a desk man - above captain it's hard to lead from the front, and my methods generally boil down to 'point, run and shout' in action.
 
I don't buy the idea that all women are inherently not good enough. IMO, if a woman can pass the selection then she's fit for any regiment - but not alongside men, since that raises deeper issues (the Israelis have real problems with that). I support the founding of a Women's Royal Infantry Corps for that reason.

What about outside the infantry? Can women and men, say, fly in the same flight squad?
 
Who do you think is the better man, a man who has put his life on the line on behalf of his countrymen or a man who has never fired a shot in anger?
 
I meant more what FP thinks - but, for that matter, what do you think about it?

Being a pilot is one of those skill sets that relies more on eye/hand coordination, and depth perception w/good decision making. In those regards males dont carry any real advantage over females, and woman have indeed proven to be more than capable of being excellent pilots. I even know more than a few.
 
Being a pilot is one of those skill sets that relies more on eye/hand coordination, and depth perception w/good decision making. In those regards males dont carry any real advantage over females, and woman have indeed proven to be more than capable of being excellent pilots. I even know more than a few.

Do women fly fighter jets, though? The g-forces require some strength physical fitness and IIRC that was the issue before, although today we have fly-by-wire and g-suits. Would be interesting to see if we have any women piloting the F-22 or F-35.
 
Do women fly fighter jets, though? The g-forces require some strength physical fitness and IIRC that was the issue before, although today we have fly-by-wire and g-suits. Would be interesting to see if we have any women piloting the F-22 or F-35.

There's a woman in the Red Arrows. The RAF don't have many of the problems that come from integrated units, so they're generally OK
 
Do women fly fighter jets, though? The g-forces require some strength physical fitness and IIRC that was the issue before, although today we have fly-by-wire and g-suits. Would be interesting to see if we have any women piloting the F-22 or F-35.

I seem to recall there is a female member of the Blue Angels.

Just checked and yup, I was right. Check out these credentials: http://www.blueangels.navy.mil/index.htm

Lieutenant Amy Tomlinson is a native of Carlsbad, Calif., and graduated from San Dieguito High School in 1996 where she lettered in gymnastics and surfing. She attended the University of Southern California where she graduated with a Bachelor of Arts degree in Public Relations in 2000.

In May 2000, Amy received her commission from the Navy ROTC program at USC. She reported to Naval Air Station (NAS) Pensacola, Fla., for aviation indoctrination and completed Naval Flight Officer Training flying in the T-34C Turbo Mentor, the T-39D Sabreliner and the T-2C Buckeye. She received her wings of gold in November 2001.

Amy then reported to Navy Fighter Squadron 101 (VF-101), the "Grim Reapers," at NAS Oceana, Va., for training in the F-14D Tomcat. In August 2002, she reported to VF-213, the "Fighting Blacklions," where she completed two combat deployments aboard the aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt (CVN 71). She is a designated Forward Air Controller Airborne and Aircraft Mission Commander, and flew 33 combat missions, totaling 135 hours, during her deployments to the Persian Gulf in support of Operations Iraqi Freedom. While with the "Blacklions," Amy served as the Public Affairs Officer, Aircraft Division Officer, Air-to-ground Weapons Training Officer and Personnel Officer.

In April 2006, Amy transitioned to the F/A-18E/F Super Hornet with Strike Fighter Squadron 122 (VFA-122), the "Flying Eagles," at NAS Lemoore, Calif. While at VFA-122, she served as a Forward Air Controller (FAC-A), Close Air Support Phase Head, Assistant Fighter Phase Head, and Schedules Officer in addition to her duties as a qualified Weapons System Officer (WSO) instructor.

Amy joined the Blue Angels in September 2008. She has accumulated more than 1,600 flight hours and 220 carrier arrested landings. Her personal decorations include two Strike Flight Air Medals, Navy and Marine Corps Commendation Medal with Combat V, Navy and Marine Corps Achievement Medal and various personal and unit awards.

Pretty darn impressive if you ask me.
 
I don't have a question, but I'd like to salute all of the men and women serving in overseas operations in Iraq and Afghanistan.

This guy who just finished his tour in Iraq showed me some pictures he took while there and I shivered from the gruesomeness of those pics. Hats off the people that do it and risk their lives.
 
what does it feel like to kill a human being? Was there some psychological impact or was it just something that needed to be done and not thought about?

What was your first kill like?
 
Do you think women should be allowed to serve in the military?
The Danish army has very good experience with women in the military, especially since it's extremely unpopular for a male western soldier, to search a female Afghan woman or give her first aid. Having a famale at the checkpoint of in the medic section, enables your unit to do it's job, without alienating the local population.

The problems you could imagine with women and men serving on the front line, are in fact negliable, at least in our army. Of course it's takes a special kind of woman to fit in, so preselection is important. Also, only a few women are tough enough and strong enough to serve in the combat troops, but those who are do so on par with their male counterparts. Hell, we even had a female heavy machine gunner in a Mech. Inf. Coy in Helmand :)
 
Back
Top Bottom