So I went for an optimistic attempt at keeping total score on all players, based on what impression I get from each posts. But I'm at page 20 now and I just remembered that I also have a life
I originally had in mind for it to be a wolf % equity, starting at 25 - but I don't think the numbers as they ended up, really reflects that. But just to clarify, the higher the number, the worse(the higher chance of being scum)
Keep in mind that many players barely wrote anything at the first 20 pages, so obviously this isn't a complete read list, but still something that I believe is worth adding here, as I feel these reads may be made more accurately than on just reading through with a few notes.
Started to note post# and point movement on page 6, so some points from the first pages are not "documented", which can leave some "shadow" points
al sipsclar 24,5 -0,5#337(somehow I like this post a little now, the mention of him being on a specific page)
arakhor 26 +1#126
autolycus 25
backwards logic 25
bsmith 25
cass_ 19 -1#120
choxorn 28,5 +1#129 +0,5#200 +0,5#218 +0,5#299
cuthilius 29,5 +1#139 +2#151 +1#158 -0,5#163 +1#371
edse 26
glossysushi 20 -1#132 -0,5#138 -0,5#181 -0,5#183 +0,5#186 +1#204 -1#233 -0,5#237 -1#241 +1#260(pocketing gut feel lol) -0,5#287 -1#348 -0,5#364
golden1knight 25
jarrema 22,5 +0,5#326 -1#329 -1#355 -0,5#359 -0,5#370
kennigit 20,5 -1#118 -1#127 -1,5#242 -1#256
kingmorgan 26 +1#374
landlubber 26 +1#122 #283(not giving points in either direction, but if Visor is scum, this could be slight TMI for him to pop in say just that)
legato endless 25
lohrenswald 20 -1#185 +0,5#194 -0,5#202 -1#336
mat93 25 -0,5#259 +1#271 +0,5#286 -0,5#344 -0,5#373
murska 24 -1#331
newyn 25
pouter pigeon 22,5 -1,5#325
sooh 21,5 -1#333
takhisis 25 -1,5#198 +1#257 +0,5#314
visorslash 34,5 +1#125 -0,5#133 +0,5#150 -0,5#168 +1#170+#171+#173+#179 +8#210+#214(!!!see#141 - he should had known that already) -0,5#250 +0,5#285 +0,5#315(feels like faked paranoia) +0,5#342
xym 28 +3#272("pressure vote" lol)
zack 21 -0,5#222 -0,5#238 -0,5#243 -0,5#247+#248 -1#253
Glossy+Sushi != W/W
Landlubber+Visor possible W/W based on #283-#307
Cuth+Visor it's mostly a gut feel, but I could see them being W/W based on a few posts, like Cuth's #380
These points are all based on individual posts and what impressions they have given me. Surprisingly Visorslash looks really bad based on my impressions, especially because of 2 posts, which are #214 + #141. It may seem a bit over the top to give it that many + points towards scum, but I really think that is super odd.
Look at them:
#141:
nah this is lenore afaict
This is comment to Cuth, that he thinks Glossy is Lenore(who it in fact is). They proceed to have a good amount of interactions, and Glossy has not corrected Visor in thinking that she is who she is - so obviously he has no reason not to believe it isn't her(since if it wasn't Lenore, she would had most likely had corrected him at the time he said it).
Yet he writes these posts, #210+#214, when Glossy talks about knowing about some of his games:
Alright, GS, who are ya?
What past games have ya been linked?
+
Suddenly he sounds like he's first realizing that she is Lenore, although he sound fairly knowing of it in #141.
Well if you are Lenore it makes sense how you know some things.
What games have you been linked?
Just to prove my point about it being weird, Lenore did also notice it and had same thought as me, that he should already had known that it was her:
I thought you knew this? [emoji14]
Didn't you say my name before?
And why is it so scummy? If he is pretending to not know who she is, while forgetting that he has already expressed knowledge of this, that is a huge scum tell, imo. There would be no reason as town for him to fake not knowing who she is - and as I read those posts, he should had known it at the point he is suddenly asking her.
Surely there will be someone or many who will disagree.
So mainly I'd like to see a lynch of either Visorslash or Cuthalion.
I believe there's a good chance of scums in each one of them, and I could see them as likely scum partners based on some posts too.
Also, Visor has been trending down for me, here at the later part of the game. He has given some bad responses on questions for him.
So
vote Visorslash, and I hope to see Cuth as counterwagon
I wouldn't cry if Xym, choxorn or KingMorgan got lynched either, but not feeling as convinced about them as with Visor and Cuth.
Vote: Lassie.
