Dutch authorities sue parents of 13 year-old to stop solo sail trip around the world

Should Laura be able to sail the world solo?


  • Total voters
    88
  • Poll closed .
16-year-old girl feared lost at sea.

100610_sunderland-sailor.rp600x350.jpg


Spoiler :
Round-the-world teen sailor feared lost at sea

Sunderland, 16, has lost contact with her crew after rough night of storms
The Associated Press

updated 6:26 p.m. ET, Thurs., June 10, 2010

A 16-year-old Southern California girl attempting a solo sail around the world was feared in trouble Thursday thousands of miles from land in the frigid, heaving southern Indian Ocean after her emergency beacons began signaling and communication was lost.

Australian Maritime Safety Authority spokeswoman Carly Lusk said three vessels were sent from the French territory of Reunion Island and an aircraft was to depart from Perth on a four-hour flight to Abby Sunderland’s location more than 2,000 miles from both Africa and Australia.

It was not clear when the vessels left, but it would take a day for the nearest ship to reach the area. Reunion Island is off Madagascar, the very large island along the east coast of Africa.

Conditions can quickly become perilous for any sailor exposed to the elements in that part of the world.

“We’ve got to get a plane out there quick,” said family spokesman Christian Pinkston, adding that the teen’s family in Thousand Oaks was asking for prayers for her safety.

Her brother Zac, also a teenage solo sailor, said Abby was prepared and mentally tough. “I really wish I could see her and hope she gets through this one,” he told reporters outside the family home.

Abby last communicated with her family at 4 a.m. PDT and reported 30-foot swells but was not in distress, Pinkston said.

An hour later the family was notified that her emergency beacons had been activated, and there was no further communication. Pinkston said the beacons were manually activated.

Her brother said the boat was most likely not completely submerged because another beacon would be triggered at a depth of 15 feet.

Derrick Fries, a U.S. sailing instruction and safety expert, said Abby’s circumstances were very unclear.

“It’s hard to determine if she’s rolled over, swamped, or washed overboard. She has to have a dry suit on to have any chance,” he said. “To be capsized in the middle of the ocean with waves crashing relentlessly down, not just for hours, but days, I can’t tell you how difficult those conditions are.”

A lifelong sailor whose father is a shipwright and has a yacht management company, Abby set sail from Los Angeles County’s Marina del Rey in her 40-foot boat, Wild Eyes, on Jan. 23 in an attempt to become the youngest person to sail around the world alone without stopping. Her brother briefly held the record in 2009.

Before Abby’s voyage began, her brother described her as having more skill and experience than most sailors in their 20s and 30s. Her father said she had more solo sailing experience than Zac did before he started out.

“He totally thinks that I’m ready to do it, so that does help,” she said at the time.

Abby soon ran into equipment problems and had to stop for repairs. She gave up the goal of setting the record in April, but continued on.

On May 15, Australian 16-year-old Jessica Watson claimed the record after completing a 23,000-mile circumnavigation in 210 days.

Abby left Cape Town, South Africa, on May 21 and on Monday reached the halfway point of her voyage.

On Wednesday, she wrote in her log that it had been a rough few days with huge seas that had her boat “rolling around like crazy.”

“I’ve been in some rough weather for awhile with winds steady at 40-45 knots with higher gusts,” she wrote. “With that front passing, the conditions were lighter today. It was a nice day today with some lighter winds which gave me a chance to patch everything up. Wild Eyes was great through everything but after a day with over 50 knots at times, I had quite a bit of work to do.”

Information on her website said that as of June 8 she had completed a 2,100-mile leg from South Africa to north of the Kerguelen Islands, taking a route to avoid an ice hazard area. Ahead of her lay more than 2,100 miles of ocean on a 10- to 16-day leg to a point south of Cape Leeuwin on the southwest tip of Australia.

Charlie Nobles, executive director of the American Sailing Association, said the best-case scenario would be that she had had a severe knockdown or roll by a strong wave that caused her communication equipment to go out, or the boat sustained structural damage that was preventing her from sailing.

The worst case would be if she was in the water or in her life raft.

“It’s an extreme set of conditions with the winds, the force of the waves,” he said.

A person lost at sea can typically survive 12 days on average without fresh water and a month without food, according to survival experts.

If the boat capsized, survival will depend on factors including water temperature, sea conditions, safety gear and whether there was something to hold on to.

Last year a Netherlands court concerned about safety blocked a 13-year-old girl’s plan to sail around the world, sparking debate on the role of authorities and parents when children want to undertake risky adventures.


Such attempts have resulted in success and tragedy.

Last month, 13-year-old Jordan Romero of Big Bear, Calif., became the youngest person to scale 29,035-foot Mount Everest. But in 1996, 7-year-old Jessica Dubroff, her father and a flight instructor were killed in a crash in Cheyenne, Wyo., during her attempt to become the youngest person to fly across the country.

I really can't believe her parents let her try the southern route. While it is much faster than other routes, it is also much more dangerous. I suspect she had to take it in order to break the circumnavigation record for being the youngest person, a record her brother held for a while.
 
Hope they find her. It sucks to be in the right on things like this.

If she's lost, that doesn't make you in the right.
 
I agree.

The 13-year-old boy who just set the record for scaling Mount Everest stated afterwards that it was a really bad idea. And now China has made doing so illegal:

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...n-climbing-Mt-Everest/articleshow/6032359.cms

KATHMANDU: Less than a month after American boy wonder Jordan Romero made mountaineering history by becoming the youngest climber in the world to summit Mt Everest, the highest point on earth, it is now certain that no one else will be able to beat the record with China announcing a curb on kid climbers from autumn.

The China Tibet Mountaineering Association (CTMA), the regulates climbing activities in Tibet – which shares Mt Everest with Nepal – issued new regulations Thursday, informing climbing agencies in Kathmandu that there will be an age bar on Mt Everest.

In a surprising decision, CTMA said climbers applying for a permit to attempt the 8848m peak – and any other Himalayan ranges from the north or Tibet — would have to be at least 18. The Chinese authorities have imposed an upper age limit as well – 60 – which would also frustrate any further attempts to set a new record for the oldest climber from the Tibet side.
 
If she's lost, that doesn't make you in the right.
It makes me in the right in that this is pretty much what I expected to happen (not that I'm unique in that viewpoint). Its unfortunate that parents would let someone so young do so and the outcome will often result in tragedy.
 
Doesn't freedom matter more than happiness?

You yourself should realize this.

Children arent really in a position to determine this. The whole point of parenting is to actually get your kid ready for adulthood......not allow them to kill themselves doing something stupid. In consideration of that I would say a childs safety is more important than their happiness.
 
Children arent really in a position to determine this. The whole point of parenting is to actually get your kid ready for adulthood......not allow them to kill themselves doing something stupid. In consideration of that I would say a childs safety is more important than their happiness.

I agree.

Anyway that American girl has been found again.
 
her ship is pretty damaged. I'm sure its over. Although I suppose she could get it repaired. But it would have to be towed I'd imagine.
 
Here are some details:

Spoiler :
Round-the-world teen sailor alive, well

This was a ‘testimony to her will to survive,’ her father says

TODAY staff and wire
updated 9:42 a.m. ET, Fri., June 11, 2010

A 16-year-old sailor on a round-the-world journey was adrift in the frigid southern Indian Ocean on Friday as rescue boats headed toward her yacht, damaged by 30-foot waves that knocked out her communications and prompted her to set off a distress signal.

After 20 hours of silence, a search plane launched from Australia's west coast made radio contact with Abby Sunderland on Friday.

Her family told TODAY's Meredith Vieira that the wait for news was "tense."

"They're not enjoyable moments, of course, and your mind does play tricks with you," said her father, Lawrence Sunderland, a shipwright who owns a yacht management company. "It's just a waiting game."

He said the family was fortunate the search and rescue team acted as quickly as they did to find Abby.

When the rescuers located her, they found her boat's mast was broken — ruining satellite phone reception — and was dragging with the sail in the ocean, said search coordinator Mick Kinley, acting chief of the Australia Maritime Safety Authority that chartered a commercial jet for the search.

But the keel was intact, the yacht was not taking on water and Abby was equipped for the conditions, Kinley told reporters in Canberra, adding that "she sounds like she's in good health."


This was a "testimony to her will to survive and deal with the situation," Lawrence said on TODAY.

Boats may reach her Saturday

A lifelong sailor, Abby had begun her journey trying to be the youngest person to sail solo, nonstop around the world and continued her trip after mechanical failures dashed that dream.

Abby told searchers Friday that she was doing fine with a space heater and at least two weeks' worth of food, said family spokesman William Bennett.

Support team member Jeff Casher said the boat had gotten knocked on its side several times.

The CROSS maritime rescue center on the island of Reunion, off Madagascar, said it had sent three boats in her direction and they were expected to reach her Saturday.

Philippe Museux, CROSS director, told French RFO television station in Reunion that it had asked a fishing boat to head to the zone.

"This zone is not frequented by ships very often. We asked a fishing boat from Reunion to reroute to that zone," he said, adding that a maritime affairs vessel, the Osiris, and the commercial ship Skandia Bergen were also rerouted.

Friday's communication with Abby was the first since satellite phone communications were lost early Thursday.

She had made several broken calls to her family in Thousand Oaks, California, and reported her yacht was being tossed by 30-foot waves — as tall as a 3-story building. An hour after her last call ended, her emergency beacons began signaling.

The observers aboard the search plane — a chartered Qantas Airbus A330 jet that left Perth early Friday — spoke with her by close-range VHF marine radio, western Australia state police spokesman Senior Sgt. Graham Clifford said.

He said the jet faced a 4,700-mile round trip from Perth to Sunderland's boat, which is near the limit of its range.

Qantas spokesman Tom Woodward said the airliner flew five hours out to sea to reach the area where the beacons were transmitting, then maneuvered for another hour before spotting the 40-foot yacht.

She's 'more than capable'

Abby's family and support team told TODAY that she had all of the skills needed to survive and hoped for the best as they waited for news from the search and rescue team.

"She's proven herself on more than one occasion before now to deal with the adversities of the ocean," Lawrence Sunderland said. "It's not to do with her ability — the boat was demasted because of a condition. And she's proven herself more than capable of dealing with this."

Her brother Zac, who successfully completed a solo sail around the world at age 17, called the Indian Ocean a "pretty crazy Ocean."

"No one really gets through it without getting a few fair knocks," he told Vieira on TODAY. "The situation as it turned out was actually a pretty good outcome for the emergency beacons going off."

But renowned Australian round-the-world sailor Ian Kiernan said Abby should not have been in the southern Indian Ocean during the current southern hemisphere winter.

"Abby would be going through a very difficult time with mountainous seas and essentially hurricane-force winds," Kiernan told Sky News television.

Conditions can quickly become perilous for any sailor exposed to the elements in that part of the world.


Her journey

Abby set sail from Los Angeles County's Marina del Rey in her boat, Wild Eyes, on Jan. 23 in an attempt to become the youngest person to sail around the world alone without stopping. Her brother briefly held the record in 2009.

Abby soon ran into equipment problems and had to stop for repairs. She gave up the goal of setting the record in April, but continued on.

On May 15, Australian 16-year-old Jessica Watson claimed the record after completing a 23,000-mile circumnavigation in 210 days. Jessica and her family sent a private message of hope to Abby's family, spokesman Andrew Fraser said.

Abby left Cape Town, South Africa, on May 21 and on Monday reached the halfway point of her voyage.

On Wednesday, she wrote in her log that it had been a rough few days with huge seas that had her boat "rolling around like crazy."

Information on her website said that as of June 8, she had completed a 2,100-mile leg from South Africa to north of the Kerguelen Islands, taking a route to avoid an ice hazard area. Ahead of her lay more than 2,100 miles of ocean on a 10- to 16-day leg to a point south of Cape Leeuwin on the southwest tip of Australia.
It was a very foolhardy attempt. Many ships much larger than her 40-foot sailboat have sunk in that part of the ocean. She apparently deliberately took this route just to beat the stupid record, and then continued on this extremely dangerous route even after mechanical difficutles made breaking it no longer possible.

Here is hoping that nothing more happens to her during the time it will take for the rescue ships to get to her.
 
The court has determined that Laura Dekker is now allowed to begin her solo sail trip around the world.

Her trip begins in two weeks. I'd say: good luck.
 
The court has determined that Laura Dekker is now allowed to begin her solo sail trip around the world.

Her trip begins in two weeks. I'd say: good luck.

What changed? But okay. Good luck.
 
Will she still be the youngest person ever to do this? If not, I'd be pretty angry with the authorities, because she will never get that chance again.
 
What changed? But okay. Good luck.

She had to do a first aid training, improve her sailing skill and arange something with her school amongst others.

Will she still be the youngest person ever to do this? If not, I'd be pretty angry with the authorities, because she will never get that chance again.

Yes.
 
Where's she leaving from, because if she's leaving from the netherlands she'd have to backtrack quite a bit?
 
Back
Top Bottom