Jon Stewart debates Fox News contributor ... and has a panel live fact check him!

Aroddo

Emperor
Joined
Feb 8, 2011
Messages
1,127
Location
Sauerkrautistan
Judge and Fox News contributor Andrew Napolitano came to Stewart's attention for his Feb. 14 appearance on the Fox Business channel by argueing that former President Abraham Lincoln’s Civil War was unnecessary — and may not have even been about slavery, anyway!

"At the time that [Lincoln] was the president of the United States, slavery was dying a natural death all over the Western world," Napolitano said. "Instead of allowing it to die, or helping it to die, or even purchasing the slaves and then freeing them — which would have cost a lot less money than the Civil War cost — Lincoln set about on the most murderous war in American history."

On the March 11 Daily Show, Napolitano appeared as a guest to plug his book and to have a spirited discussion with Jon Stewart about his controversial claims (see part 1 and part 2).

However, after the debate Napolitano stayed for a mock gameshow segment, in which Stewart quizzed him and co-host Jessica Williams (dressed up as Abe) about the key points of the interview ..... and then had a panel of three history professors fact check him.


http://www.thedailyshow.com/watch/tue-march-11-2014/exclusive---the-weakest-lincoln

Needless to say that this was highly entertaining. And I actually can't praise Napolitano enough for agreeing to take part in this, knowing beforehand that his Fox News quality research will have to stand up to live, professional fact checking.

I wish news channels would adopt this novel idea of fact checking the statements of their guests and contributors while they are still there ....
 
I'm sure Stewart's people had a lot of prior notice on what facts that they needed to check.
 
Napolitano: "I don't know the answer ... That was not in one of the questions you gave me ahead of time"
Stewart (exasperated): "We were supposed to pretend we are all smart, Judge!"
 
Judge Napolitano had a cool show once on that 'news' channel :\ I have only seen less than one hour overall from various parts of that short-lived tv program, but it sounded vastly better than most US mainstream 'news' tv :)

Stewart is ok, although i think he has become a lot more important 'politically' than any comedian should be in a healthy country (Creon would agree :yup: ).
 
I wish news channels would adopt this novel idea of fact checking the statements of their guests and contributors while they are still there ....
And three false statements gets you a Nickelodeon-style sliming
 
A more important question is why he colored his hair.

Unless it naturally turned black from white, out of sheer anger with the shredding of the constitution :)
 
Why is Napolitano still referred to as a judge? He hasn't been one for nearly two decades.

Same way that Jimmy Carter is still supposed to be addressed as Mr. President?
 
Why is Napolitano still referred to as a judge? He hasn't been one for nearly two decades.

Same way that Jimmy Carter is still supposed to be addressed as Mr. President?

One is as stupid as the other. Military and political ranks both do this, it's ridiculous. It's a title for office HOLDERS, it's not a lifelong honorary. They are not barons and dukes.
 
He has made a fortune from lecture-giving in the US, and introducing him always was centered on his old title, long inactive by then ;)

Although mostly i was making a comment against other types of nepotism :D
 
maybe it's just courtesy to the guest who agreed to be taken apart by the professorial panel.
 
One is as stupid as the other. Military and political ranks both do this, it's ridiculous. It's a title for office HOLDERS, it's not a lifelong honorary. They are not barons and dukes.

Umm, actually military ranks are lifelong if you attain certain ranks. For enlisted personnel I believe E-7 is the first rank that is your lifelong rank. For commissioned officers all of their ranks are held for life if I am not mistaken. The reason for these lifelong ranks is that those ranks can only be stripped from the holder by an act of Congress. So if Congress never strips you of that rank you hold it forever. It makes even more sense in the case of commissioned officers because they can be called back to service if needed for the remainder of their lives. So technically, they never truly separate from the military.

I agree it is ridiculous for political figures though.
 
Soon after, Stewart turned to Wilmore, who noted that the Confederacy was “so committed to slavery that Lincoln didn’t die of natural causes.” Wilmore next pointed out that people who “think Lincoln started the Civil War because the North was ready to kill to end slavery” are mistaken. “[T]he truth was,” Wilmore said, “the South was ready to die to keep slavery.”

Stewart and Wilmore next highlighted that Napolitano doesn’t hate all wars, and in fact has a history of praising the Revolutionary War as necessary and just. “So it was heroic to fight for the proposition that all men are created equal, but when there’s a war to enforce that proposition, that’s wack?” Wilmore asked. “You know, there’s something not right when you feel the only black thing worth fighting for is tea.”

As the final dagger, Stewart and Wilmore noted that Napolitano has ranted at length on Fox about how taxation is immoral and unjust, prompting Wilmore to elegantly outline the problems with Napolitano-style libertarianism in a single paragraph. Speaking to Napolitano, Wilmore said:

You think it’s immoral for the government to reach into your pocket, rip your money away from its warm home and claim it as its own property, money that used to enjoy unfettered freedom is now conscripted to do whatever its new owner tells it to. Now, I know this is going to be a leap, but you know that sadness and rage you feel about your money? Well, that’s the way some of us feel about people.

http://www.salon.com/2014/02/25/the...for_blaming_the_civil_war_on_abraham_lincoln/

:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::goodjob:

Iam sure that the US could have raised a TAX on owning slaves
And used this tax to free to slaves

Problem SOLVED !
 
Back
Top Bottom