"Minutemen" plan to patrol Arizona border

Uiler said:
Unless you're N. Korean. China has tons of illegal N. Korean immigrants.

Then I guess their little military branch of border gaurds isn't working is it?


What I would like to hear from someone is what do you do about the migrant farm workers. The american agricultural industry depends on this labor. I have a solution to this problem. But I'd really like to hear from somebody that really thinks that we ought to blanket close down all illegal immigration.
 
i have an uncle in Texas who has a rather large cotton and peanuts farm... alot of his seasonal workers are immigrants... 1 min nobody on the farm, next minute theres a million ppl in the fields..lol
 
Xen said:
Perhaps you all are forgetting; illegal immigration is a good thing. as sad a fact as it is, Mexicans are the slave labour of the 21st century, and half the amercian economy cant stand to be without them. Sure, people say that those jobs that they take are better left for americans; but they forget, mexicans take all those low paying jobs that americans constantlly refuse, on the basis of what they are, and how much they pay.

take away mexicans, and sadlly enough, the greatest single leg of the amercian home- economy falls away.

Nope, you're wrong. Legal immigration is a good thing. Illegal is what it is - breaking the law and disregarding the rule of law, which is the foundation on which civilized societies are based upon. We should either enforce the law, or do away with it. The double standard created by our government is a paradox without logic.

And you're wrong about Mexicans taking jobs Americans don't want, too. Most of the jobs that are being taken by illegal immigrants are jobs that should be filled by the millions of folks sucking on our socialist welfare system. But when an American citizen can "make" more income from the government teat than actually working a low level job, they seem to gravitate toward dependent laziness and a vacuum is created in the job field (which, of course, is filled by illegal immigrants).

You are right about raising the wages of pay for all workers, regardless of legality. But the problem is that these workers are undocumented, so how do you enforce it? Many are paid "under the table" (ie. cash), so employers are hiding it to begin with. And since these workers have already broken federal law just by their illegal entry, what is another law to break if we pass a mandatory minimum wage law?

I know many, many people down here in Texas who are losing their jobs SOLELY because of the massive influx of illegal immigrants. In most cases, employers are paying them a couple of dollars an hour, far below the federal minimum wage. Plus, without any medical benefits, guess who gets to pay for their medical care when they get hurt and are rushed to the hospital? (hint: Taxpayers).

Add to that the fact that tens of billions of dollars are NOT being spent in the U.S. by the illegal workers, but rather are being sent back to Mexico to buy cheap imported Chinese goods and whatever.

And then we have the ideology of "reconquista" (or reconquest of the southwest U.S.), which urges Hispanics to have allegiance to ideals contrary to U.S. interests (as vividly expressed by the Movimiento Estudiantil de Chicanos de Aztlan "The Student Movement of Aztlan Chicanos" — better known by its acronym, MEChA). In calling for the re-partition of the American Southwest, MEChA is not just seeking the overthrow of the American government but the overthrow of its people as well. This is not pie in the sky. I have been told on many occassions that this movement is quickly gaining momentum, and this information comes from Mexican-Americans of legal immigration descent that are upset by the social upheaval that it is causing within their community.
 
Damnyankee said:
Well ya, pretty much, but that would make more people join, and border patrol is in my opinion a vital thing

A. The military is not for sissies.

B. THe Border is huge, all the coastline of America plus the borders with the two coutries. Not an easy thing to guard.
 
MarineCorps said:
A. The military is not for sissies.

B. THe Border is huge, all the coastline of America plus the borders with the two coutries. Not an easy thing to guard.

Listen, I am not saying the military is for sissys, but some people want to serve and don't want to go to Iraq. This is a alternative that people might join. the Guard I am talking about would guard the Mexican border, no need to guard the Canadian border
 
Xen said:
P
a better solution is to just force jobs that they occupy to pay minimum wage

You can't force a worker to earn minimum wage when you don't know he exists.

Anyway, if the government somehow magically found out the employment information of all the illegal immigrants, and made them earn minimum wage, that would take out the leg you said our economy stands on.
 
They are called minute men because they would last only a minute on the battlefield before breaking and running ?
 
Xen said:
Perhaps you all are forgetting; illegal immigration is a good thing. as sad a fact as it is, Mexicans are the slave labour of the 21st century, and half the amercian economy cant stand to be without them.
So the U.S. couldn't possibly stand on its own if illegal Mexican labor suddenly stopped? I find it hard to believe.
Xen said:
Sure, people say that those jobs that they take are better left for americans; but they forget, mexicans take all those low paying jobs that americans constantlly refuse, on the basis of what they are, and how much they pay.
If the Mexicans weren't here taking the jobs 2 things would result,

1. Whites and others would take the jobs and not refuse them because the jobs would pay more. The reason they pay so little is because Mexicans will work for next to nothing, this is bad for working class "native" Americans.

2. Equipment would out of necessity be invented and produced that would effectively replace the cheap and common labor these migrants are already performing. If they get paid so damn little, it stands to reason that a machine could duplicate the work of many migrants.
Xen said:
take away mexicans, and sadlly enough, the greatest single leg of the amercian home- economy falls away.
Not even hyperbole will sway me.
Xen said:
a better solution is to just force jobs that they occupy to pay minimum wage; as the effect will mean any inclination as far as payment goes to hire mexicans being cheaper is taken away, and regardless, they will have more money to buy products with, and so pay sales tax, and help out the nation in the tax respect. Moreover, if it happens that Amercians actually do start doing those jobs, then mexicans wont be; lack of job oppertunties will mean that less, and less mexicans cross the boarder, looking for a job in the first place.
The thing to do is to take illegal immigrants and send them to fight in Iraq. Thus by serving for a stated amount of time, they would have legally "earned" citizenship plus all of the benefits of being a U.S. veteran.
 
actually they were called that because they could be ready to fight in a minutes notice. The border is a very big place, and yes it is hard to guard. As far as ppl in the military joining but not wanting to fight? What the heck do they think they signed up for? You dont get your choice of assignments and well u learn to fight... to kill the enemy, heck if u are an officer u have to take an oath to fight all enemies forein and domestic....As far as Im concerned ifi didnt want to go to Iraq and fight i probally wouldnt have joined the military. There is a marine corps defector living here in Ontario somewhere... he had a trial because he didnt want to go back to the us cause hed be tried for desertion... too friggen bad, i think its about time ppl realised what armies do and what they are for.... its not a place to sleep all day...
 
Good for them, illegal immigration is getting out of hand. I can see how this can work out, either the "minute men" help stem the immigration without violence, or violence is used and the government is forced to step in with an alternative.
 
cidknee said:
actually they were called that because they could be ready to fight in a minutes notice. The border is a very big place, and yes it is hard to guard. As far as ppl in the military joining but not wanting to fight? What the heck do they think they signed up for? You dont get your choice of assignments and well u learn to fight... to kill the enemy, heck if u are an officer u have to take an oath to fight all enemies forein and domestic....As far as Im concerned ifi didnt want to go to Iraq and fight i probally wouldnt have joined the military.

Finially. Someone with sense. :)



cidknee said:
There is a marine corps defector living here in Ontario somewhere... he had a trial because he didnt want to go back to the us cause hed be tried for desertion... too friggen bad, i think its about time ppl realised what armies do and what they are for.... its not a place to sleep all day...


You don't say... ANd is no one wasnting to chase him out of town?
 
Damnyankee said:
Listen, I am not saying the military is for sissys, but some people want to serve and don't want to go to Iraq. This is a alternative that people might join. the Guard I am talking about would guard the Mexican border,

Well seeing as the entire purpose of serveing is to go and fight wars.....


Damnyankee said:
no need to guard the Canadian border

I am far more concerned about certian people leaving this country then people getting into this country on that border.
 
cidknee said:
actually they were called that because they could be ready to fight in a minutes notice. The border is a very big place, and yes it is hard to guard. As far as ppl in the military joining but not wanting to fight? What the heck do they think they signed up for? You dont get your choice of assignments and well u learn to fight... to kill the enemy, heck if u are an officer u have to take an oath to fight all enemies forein and domestic....As far as Im concerned ifi didnt want to go to Iraq and fight i probally wouldnt have joined the military. There is a marine corps defector living here in Ontario somewhere... he had a trial because he didnt want to go back to the us cause hed be tried for desertion... too friggen bad, i think its about time ppl realised what armies do and what they are for.... its not a place to sleep all day...

Then don't make a Mexican Border Guard a part of the military, make it a part of some other bureaucracy. Homeland Security it can be under.
 
Riesstiu IV said:
This is further proof that our soldiers should be patrolling the border between Mexico and the US instead of occupying Iraq. It’s crazy... Our politicians are doing nothing about the unchecked illegal immigration by thousands if not millions of Mexicans every year. I lived in Texas and you would not believe how lax the border is. Heck just sitting in my dad's car for about 10 minutes, I witnessed several illegal immigrants (drug traffickers?) cross the border with relative ease.

I'm all for legal immigration but anybody who just wants to allow this kind of invasion to happen needs to get a reality check and visit some of the border towns and check points around Southern Texas.

I agree. Our senators and congressmen only care about the corporation's interests. Through illigal immigration being incouraged by our government with incentives such as free healthcare that our own citizens cannot recieve, they are effectively lowering the overall minimal wage by this surge of uneducated, "will work for a dollar" employees.

Additionally, this is causing justified racism against mexicans who willfully disobey our countrys laws. But who can blame them...
 
theres no such thing as "justified racism"

if you wanna be mad, be mad at the people who break the minimum wage law, and hire illegal workers for profit (and the republicans who wanna take away minimum wage altogether)

if a person is willing to risk crossing the border to do a job most whites dont want to do, for less money, that person deserves sympathy not hatred

dont they teach anything about sympathy to white americans? only hate?
 
Back
Top Bottom