• Civilization 7 has been announced. For more info please check the forum here .

My Little Pony

Status
Not open for further replies.
It came from the same place everything else on the internet came from.
And so, that begs another question: Where is the place everything else on the internet came from? :p
 
I think it's mostly based on adolescents who have just dicovered irony and aren't aware that they can overkill on it

This.

The appeal is mainly of "haha, look at us, we're watching pink ponies cartoons and we don't care what you think". It's actually quite fascinating to observe. So many people will self-identify as "bronies" in a conforming nonconformist kind of way.
 
The appeal is mainly of "haha, look at us, we're watching pink ponies cartoons and we don't care what you think".
That would make more sense if they really didn't, in fact, care what we thought. Many of them do.
 
Why is it hard to believe that some people actually genuinely like the show? And what's the deal with reducing bronies' motivations to the need to conform, i.e. the lowest common denominator in fandom? If you're going to psychoanalyze anyone, at least pick on Power Rangers enthusiasts. Those guys are just weird.
 
@Vr: So Harry Potter is unisex, whereas My Little Pony is for girls. Harry Potter is for 12-14 yr olds whereas My Little Poony is for 6-7 year olds. HP is dramatic whereas MLP is whimsical. Big whoop! They're both for children but adults watch them. If there's nothing weird about Harry Potter then there shouldn't be anything weird about My Little Porny.

Well that works well for me; I find it weird that adults can care so much about a some book series about witches and the invisible world they live in, I can find it weird that adults can care so much about anthropomorphic cartoon ponies.
 
Why is it hard to believe that some people actually genuinely like the show? And what's the deal with reducing bronies' motivations to the need to conform, i.e. the lowest common denominator in fandom? If you're going to psychoanalyze anyone, at least pick on Power Rangers enthusiasts. Those guys are just weird.
Like I said: it's just a supplement for gaydar. No big psychoanalysis necessary. Moving on.
 
That would make more sense if they really didn't, in fact, care what we thought. Many of them do.

Like I said, a "sounds odd at first" sense of conformist nonconformism.

Kind of just ironically watching a super pony cartoon show, knowing that people will think "what the heck? Why would an adult watch this?", but don't you dare actually say that out loud! Or maybe saying it out loud strengthens the bond of the "nonconformists".

Why is it hard to believe that some people actually genuinely like the show? And what's the deal with reducing bronies' motivations to the need to conform, i.e. the lowest common denominator in fandom? If you're going to psychoanalyze anyone, at least pick on Power Rangers enthusiasts. Those guys are just weird.

Key word "some". My analysis is not rigorous, and intentionally meant to paint a very broad stroke. I would venture to say that even those "some" enjoy the brotherhood of "bronies" as a way to go against what other people may think, even if it isn't the primary motivation.
 
Why is it hard to believe that some people actually genuinely like the show? And what's the deal with reducing bronies' motivations to the need to conform, i.e. the lowest common denominator in fandom? If you're going to psychoanalyze anyone, at least pick on Power Rangers enthusiasts. Those guys are just weird.

Because it's a cartoon specifically made and targeted towards prepubescent girls based on a toy specifically made and targeted to prepubescent girls.

I understand when people like cartoons, because it's nostalgic; they watched it when they were 8 or something, like TMNT, or when the target market is not 11 year old girls, but if you're making an effort to watch a cartoon made for kids, especially one of such a specific demographic, and you're above the age of 13, there is something deeply wrong with you.
 
Man I hope they are being genuine about the pony thing. If they are being ironic then screw 'em. I only brake for genuine bronies.
 
Kind of just ironically watching a super pony cartoon show, knowing that people will think "what the heck? Why would an adult watch this?", but don't you dare actually say that out loud! Or maybe saying it out loud strengthens the bond of the "nonconformists".

If you've figured it out, why fall for it? Seems to me like it's the anti-bronies kicking up the most fuss over a little old cartoon show.
 
If you're using the term "anti-bronies", you're taking yourself too seriously.

Hell, when I was past the age of, you know, 12, I was more interested in girls, playing in the park, and stuff which didn't make my parents want to disown me.
 
Because it's a cartoon specifically made and targeted towards prepubescent girls based on a toy specifically made and targeted to prepubescent girls.

...if you're making an effort to watch a cartoon made for kids, especially one of such a specific demographic, and you're above the age of 13, there is something deeply wrong with you.

Oh, did you not see it the first time?

Spoiler :
 
Because it's a cartoon specifically made and targeted towards prepubescent girls based on a toy specifically made and targeted to prepubescent girls.

I understand when people like cartoons, because it's nostalgic; they watched it when they were 8 or something, like TMNT, or when the target market is not 11 year old girls, but if you're making an effort to watch a cartoon made for kids, especially one of such a specific demographic, and you're above the age of 13, there is something deeply wrong with you.

Just because something is marketed towards prepubescent girls doesn't make it immoral to watch, nor does it mean that it can't transcend those artificial boundaries. For the record, I've never once had the urge to buy a toy from the show and probably never will, but would never misjudge those who do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom