dcmort93
The Stig
******** Double posts
None Shall Pass [Game Thread - Concluded]
- Thread starter Zack
- Start date
spaceman98
Plotting something
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2010
- Messages
- 3,639
vote: Asktheusurperpizzaguy, as I said, confirmed cult, basically. I can buy Yoda being nonconvertible, I can buy Luke being NC, but Mace Windu? Very unlikely, and the cult would have converted or killed him by now, especially since as we see, Palpatine is not one shot.
Several notes:
1: I don't like Visor very much either, his (or her) head should also roll eventually. Why? I have received conflicting reports on who has been protected at night, as far as I know, Visor is still convertible, and a prime target for conversion. If you wish, I can elaborate in private (if I trust you).
2: Methinks that Count Duku is a third party. Its very unlikely that SW has two viges, on opposite sides of the Prequel trilogy. Its unlikely that he is cult, given that they both decided to attack the same person, a sign of clear uncoordination, and besides, a cult with two vigelantes, at least one of which has many shots, would be OP. LOTR might have something similar, I recall someone claimed Gollum a while ago, but I was never told whom. Someone should look into this.
3: Sprig being town is a good sign for Choxorn, since Choxorn knew that Sprig knew a lot, so if Choxorn was cult, then Sprig would have been converted.
Several notes:
1: I don't like Visor very much either, his (or her) head should also roll eventually. Why? I have received conflicting reports on who has been protected at night, as far as I know, Visor is still convertible, and a prime target for conversion. If you wish, I can elaborate in private (if I trust you).
2: Methinks that Count Duku is a third party. Its very unlikely that SW has two viges, on opposite sides of the Prequel trilogy. Its unlikely that he is cult, given that they both decided to attack the same person, a sign of clear uncoordination, and besides, a cult with two vigelantes, at least one of which has many shots, would be OP. LOTR might have something similar, I recall someone claimed Gollum a while ago, but I was never told whom. Someone should look into this.
3: Sprig being town is a good sign for Choxorn, since Choxorn knew that Sprig knew a lot, so if Choxorn was cult, then Sprig would have been converted.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Absolute impossibility to be Sauron
Askthepizzaguy- Self
Buddhafish- SW Mason
dcmort93- SW Mason
SouthernKing- SW Mason
Nintz- Proven
Highly improbable to be Sauron
choxorn- Kennigit's LOTR double
BSmith1068- Reasons
KingMorgan- LOTR Mason
Double A- Reasons
Arakhor- Reasons
Very improbable to be Sauron
Frozen In Ice- Demonstrably elsewhere
Gone 3 the Celt- Demonstrably elsewhere
Jarrema- Demonstrably elsewhere
Darth Feather- Demonstrably elsewhere
Stuck in Pi- Demonstrably elsewhere
SW impossible to be Sauron due to the Force (simply scan them as Not Having the Force to prove them guilty)
Backwards Logic- If you have the Force, you are legit SW.
Camikaze- If you have the Force, you are legit SW.
SW improbable to be Sauron due to being Star Wars. (simply scan them as Not Star Wars to prove them guilty)
azzaman333
sirtommygunn
In my personal opinion highly unlikely to be Sauron due to play choices:
Visorslash- And there may be other reasons, on top of that, that I don't even know about.
REMAINING CONTENDERS:
SamSniped- LOTR Gollum. Has a power Sauron might have. He's an interesting candidate to say the least. But Gollum is a cover role that won't really protect someone from being lynched, and that's what's holding me back.
Takhisis- LOTR with a power that Sauron would have. However, it's a duplicated power, and SW has a duplicated power.
johnhughthom- LOTR unknown
spaceman98- LOTR unknown
topsecret- LOTR (or SW, not even sure) total unknown
Askthepizzaguy- Self
Buddhafish- SW Mason
dcmort93- SW Mason
SouthernKing- SW Mason
Nintz- Proven
Highly improbable to be Sauron
choxorn- Kennigit's LOTR double
BSmith1068- Reasons
KingMorgan- LOTR Mason
Double A- Reasons
Arakhor- Reasons
Very improbable to be Sauron
Frozen In Ice- Demonstrably elsewhere
Gone 3 the Celt- Demonstrably elsewhere
Jarrema- Demonstrably elsewhere
Darth Feather- Demonstrably elsewhere
Stuck in Pi- Demonstrably elsewhere
SW impossible to be Sauron due to the Force (simply scan them as Not Having the Force to prove them guilty)
Backwards Logic- If you have the Force, you are legit SW.
Camikaze- If you have the Force, you are legit SW.
SW improbable to be Sauron due to being Star Wars. (simply scan them as Not Star Wars to prove them guilty)
azzaman333
sirtommygunn
In my personal opinion highly unlikely to be Sauron due to play choices:
Visorslash- And there may be other reasons, on top of that, that I don't even know about.
REMAINING CONTENDERS:
SamSniped- LOTR Gollum. Has a power Sauron might have. He's an interesting candidate to say the least. But Gollum is a cover role that won't really protect someone from being lynched, and that's what's holding me back.
Takhisis- LOTR with a power that Sauron would have. However, it's a duplicated power, and SW has a duplicated power.
johnhughthom- LOTR unknown
spaceman98- LOTR unknown
topsecret- LOTR (or SW, not even sure) total unknown
Visorslash
Deity
Camikaze - Count Dooku - Serial killer?
Calling it.
Topsecret/takhisis are now our two biggest leads.
Calling it.
Topsecret/takhisis are now our two biggest leads.
dcmort93
The Stig
Gollum could still be cult though. Keep him on the watch for now until we find the snakes head
Visorslash
Deity
I want to see SW focused on Palpatine and Dooku today. You have two known killers - Sauron (or Saruman?) haven't killed.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Furthermore, out of my 5 red candidates, 3 must be Lord of the Rings cult.
Isn't that beautiful?
Isn't that beautiful?
Visorslash
Deity
I think I may know who Sauron is. We will be taking him out tonight.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Wrong about Askthepizzaguy, wrong about Visorslash as well.
There's a level of wrongness here that I find only possible from townies not in the know.
Visorslash said:
Can you firmly discount johnhughthom as being the starting LOTR cultist?
Similar but unrelated question, can you firmly discount johnhughthom as being LOTR cultist at all?
I have a feeling our suspects sheets are matching but you know something I don't about some of these candidates.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
In case of guessing wrong, backup guesses?
Visorslash
Deity
I have them, it is only a matter of time before he dies.
Visorslash
Deity
Unvote; Vote: Gone 3 the celt
Yeah, if you could not tell everyone about the things that I know people know, that would be great.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
According to Visor, this guy is not clear by any means.
I doubt he's Sauron but he's sounding like a convert.
azzaman333
meh
Given I was roleblocked due to my injuries last night, the night result proves I'm not Palpatine or Dooku.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
I realize you guys want no votes on LOTR people. I understand today is, in fairness, a lynch a SW guy day. However, I propose a new format, seeing as we now nearly even in terms of numberology:
1) LOTR people vote for SW people who could be cult, state who is probable LOTR cult
2) SW people vote for LOTR people who could be cult, state who is probable SW cult
In good faith, I say that Gone 3 is a top question mark due to where was he last night, however I'm not completely convinced. Dudes who have the Force are also obvious Palpy candidates.
Will go down the listy list.
Took a while to assemble the above list, so assembling SW cult list in a bit.
1) LOTR people vote for SW people who could be cult, state who is probable LOTR cult
2) SW people vote for LOTR people who could be cult, state who is probable SW cult
In good faith, I say that Gone 3 is a top question mark due to where was he last night, however I'm not completely convinced. Dudes who have the Force are also obvious Palpy candidates.
Will go down the listy list.
Took a while to assemble the above list, so assembling SW cult list in a bit.
Askthepizzaguy
Know the Dark Side
Visorslash
Deity
Or we could vote SW one day, LOTR the next.
