None Shall Pass [Game Thread - Concluded]

[azzaman333]

Please PM me your role name.

Just a name, that's all I ask.

I'd like to see your list of potential SW cultists first, if you don't mind.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Absolute impossibility to be Palpatine

Buddhafish- SW Mason
dcmort93- SW Mason
SouthernKing- SW Mason
Nintz- Reasons
choxorn- Kennigit's LOTR double
BSmith1068- Reasons
KingMorgan- LOTR Mason
Double A- Reasons
Arakhor- Reasons
Darth Feather- Demonstrably elsewhere
Visorslash- Reasons

Very improbable to be Palpatine

SamSniped, due to LOTR
Takhisis due to LOTR

Unlikely

azzaman333- Injury
Askthepizzaguy- Absolutely impossible to be Palpatine but you don't know that.

Remainders:

Backwards Logic- Force User, can be tracked / found via dcmort
Camikaze- Force User, can be tracked / found via dcmort
Stuck in Pi- Force User, can be tracked / found via dcmort
Frozen In Ice- Force User, can be tracked / found via dcmort
Jarrema- Force User, can be tracked / found via dcmort- (Unlikely)
sirtommygunn- Play choices extremely risky for Palpatine.- (Unlikely)

Questionables:

Gone 3 the Celt- Force user unknown location last night, was supposed to be found by dcmort.
topsecret- total unknown

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Afraid the "likely nonPalpy SW cultist list" cannot be narrowed down to anyone but SW peoples.

No guarantees that non-force users cannot be turned into converts, such as bounty hunters, sith assassins, general grievous, and the usual suspects from the Imperial admirals etc.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

I also think Takhisis is a great target, as I have been saying for many rounds, and silly peoples did not listen, and wanted to lynch townies instead.

Like, you know, Kennigit. Who could have lynched Takhisis but no, that wasn't cool, and we had to also lie to pizza about being a nobody tracker who was expendable instead of being the most vital role we had, silly banana.

We could have slain Sauron on fricking Day One.

Vote: Takhisis

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Sorry, Day "Two".

Since Day One didn't matter.

 

[azzaman333]

It makes me uncomfortable that you're hunting LotR cult over SW cult.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

It makes me uncomfortable that you're hunting LotR cult over SW cult.

That's gratitude for you.

Very well, claim your name to someone else you trust.

 

[Arakhor]

Well, SW Cult does seem to be breeding, but I suppose that Dooku might be a serial killer or the like. I suspect FrozenInIce, Tommy and especially StuckInPi for his hit-and-run lazy-lynch last night.

 

[SamSniped]

After reading over ATPG's analysis, FoS: Takhisis and TopSecret, and Vote: G3TC, all four of whom should explain themselves somewhat soon. I point to ATPG's post for my evidence.

 

[Camikaze]

Well unless someone actually has anything more than conjecture, I'm happy to go with Gone 3 the Celt.

 

[Frozen In Ice]

I successfully blocked topsecret last night, so he isn't as unknown now.

 

[Frozen In Ice]

Also Pizza, I think I should get moved to the top category for my not-Palpyness considering you can't attack yourself.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Also Pizza, I think I should get moved to the top category for my not-Palpyness considering you can't attack yourself.

Ha! Excellent point. I hadn't marked it down in my notes.

 

[Darth Feather]

So going about ATPG's list I am going to Vote: Spaceman for being on the baddies list of ATPG. (although G3TC is probably going to be lynched. ) If someone can vouch for him I will remove my vote.

 

[spaceman98]

A few more comments:
1: Visor is ok for now.
2: Regarding Celt, I'm not sure about the specifics of the case against him/her and I'm not sure that I should be told these specifics. I will wait for dcmort to post more, as he said he would "after consulting his peers".
3: I can definitely see Taki, jht and topsecret being Sauron, Saruman and possibly a convert. I can also see myself being a cultist, but strangely I am not. Maybe I am unconvertible, though I was never made NC? I'm Gandalf btw.
4: I still think Pizza is a cultist, likely a convert.

 

[BSmith1068]

I think there needs to be a lot more effort to find the SW cult. This double kill smells of a cult getting stronger. They may need more than one member to effectively kill together, as evidenced by the sole Palpatine attack on N1.

So far we have seen nothing public from the LOTR cult. This combined with the fact that LOTR has been pretty effective at getting people inconvertible leaves me to believe they are struggling to gain members. SW Cult has no such barriers (with Kennigit out of the way) and is an active threat.

This combined with the fact that it is SW’s “turn” for the lynch means we must lynch a SW person today. No exceptions (unless some pretty damning evidence appears).

vote: Gone3TheCelt fits the above criteria, plus he has the inconvenient situation of not doing what he was supposed to be doing last night.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

A few more comments:
1: Visor is ok for now.

You couldn't get him lynched either way.

2: Regarding Celt, I'm not sure about the specifics of the case against him/her and I'm not sure that I should be told these specifics. I will wait for dcmort to post more, as he said he would "after consulting his peers".

If what I am hearing is true, Celt will have roleblocked someone who, apparently, was already injured. Which is a real waste of a blocking power.

At the same time, that particular roleblock appears to be the correct choice, and I would recommend continuing to roleblock the person in question or resolving him outright. I realize the injured party is LOTR, so I might not get support to lynch him, but I'd like permission to continue blocking him.

3: I can definitely see Taki, jht and topsecret being Sauron, Saruman and possibly a convert. I can also see myself being a cultist, but strangely I am not. Maybe I am unconvertible, though I was never made NC? I'm Gandalf btw.

You might be barking at potential converts all, but not Sauron.

4: I still think Pizza is a cultist, likely a convert.

The continued lynch likelihood on me is why I haven't been converted yet.

Every day people say I'm the bestest conversion choice, which makes me not the worst one, but one that has little odds of surviving to the next round.

 

[choxorn]

vote: Gone3TheCelt fits the above criteria, plus he has the inconvenient situation of not doing what he was supposed to be doing last night.

What was he supposed to be doing last night?

Every day people say I'm the bestest conversion choice, which makes me not the worst one, but one that has little odds of surviving to the next round.

But you're also Askthepizzaguy. You find ways to not get killed.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

What was he supposed to be doing last night?

Giving his ability to dcmort, by blocking him, which was agreed to by a very large number of SW people.

That way, it would give us the precise location of Gone 3 the Celts that night, eliminating him as a suspect for any Star Wars murderers we might see in the writeup. Instead he chose to block an injured party, is what I am told.

But you're also Askthepizzaguy. You find ways to not get killed.

I do, at that.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

I am not fully convinced G3 is the correct lynch today based off of just that.

If he is who he says he is, one more try, insisting he blocks dcmort, may prove superior.

Topsecret, on the other hand, I would be willing to put lynch pressure on, regardless of his claim.