None Shall Pass [Game Thread - Concluded]

[sirtommygunn]

I thought you said you weren't Sith, didn't know who the Sith were and basically told me to go away?

I'm not Sith, I'm just genuinely curious about what you wanted to say, and I figure any discussion with the cult should be at least be publicly acknowledged.

 

[Takhisis]

That's true, Arakhor's discussion with the cult should be publicly acknowledged.

 

[Zack]

TALLY:

[TIMER=11/16/2013 11:59 PM EST; Day Eight Over][/TIMER]

 

[spaceman98]

Oh, good grief. I'm not sticking up for Takhisis: I'm still half-convinced he's scum. Spaceman needs to die though.

Besides, if we were cult partners, why would I draw so much attention to it?

If taki is vader, then you would be desperate to save him. The case against him is stated clearly in the message today IIRC

 

[spaceman98]

or not. Here is the case against Taki as I see it:

1: The ability he claims is relatively easy to fake, just by looking at how people voted on the "war of the vigilantes"
2: He was one of Visor's and Pizza's primary suspects. Sure, Pizza was cult, but Pizza was SW cult, and SW cult has an incentive to hunt LOTR cult (though if he did, that would make him the only SW cultist to do so)

At the same time, I still think unvote: vote: topsecret is better, since he claims nothing except masonry to a dead player, and Zack said that there are no vanilla townies in this game. The Balrog makes sense as a one shot ability and "no ability" makes sense as a claim if you have a one shot. I am willing to see either Taki or topsecret hang

 

[spaceman98]

If any other mason has no abilities, please come forward as that would give evidence in support of topsecret's innocence

 

[Takhisis]

or not. Here is the case against Taki as I see it:

1: The ability he claims is relatively easy to fake, just by looking at how people voted on the "war of the vigilantes"
2: He was one of Visor's and Pizza's primary suspects. Sure, Pizza was cult, but Pizza was SW cult, and SW cult has an incentive to hunt LOTR cult (though if he did, that would make him the only SW cultist to do so)

2. Maybe Visor didn't want me scanning him so that I didn't find out he was Ganondorf? The only cultist I scanned was Backwards on N1 but he may have been converted after that. Palpy and Dooku went around killing before Maul was noticed.

1. I repeat, I did scan Frozen as SW when he was pretending to be LotR like sirtommygunn was and that was the basis of Visorslash's accusations against him.

At the same time, I still think unvote: vote: topsecret is better, since he claims nothing except masonry to a dead player, and Zack said that there are no vanilla townies in this game. The Balrog makes sense as a one shot ability and "no ability" makes sense as a claim if you have a one shot. I am willing to see either Taki or topsecret hang

I actually think vote:sirtommygunn is a better lynch but I see no momentum for that. He did try to wreck the peace between towns with his infiltration and all that and now let's make some vote analysis. In each of the last three lynches we lynched a Star Wars cultist. Whom did sirtomymgun vote? Other people. When we lynched Camikaze (Palpatine, by then admitted even by himself) he voted for spaceman98. When we lynched Backwards Logic (Darth Maul) he wanted to lynch town leader Visorslash. When we lynched Pizzaguy (Dooku) he voted for Gong 4 teh Cello Gone 3 the Celt. It's too fishy, he never ever votes for the Star Wars cult, and it's too much of a coincidence. And that is my vote.

 

[johnhughthom]

I love it, so predictable. You are probably both scummers, the old "bring up another target for tomorrow and hopefully I survive this lynch and can work on making a case on this name I've pulled from my underpants" routine.

 

[spaceman98]

2. Maybe Visor didn't want me scanning him so that I didn't find out he was Ganondorf? The only cultist I scanned was Backwards on N1 but he may have been converted after that. Palpy and Dooku went around killing before Maul was noticed.

1. I repeat, I did scan Frozen as SW when he was pretending to be LotR like sirtommygunn was and that was the basis of Visorslash's accusations against him.

I actually think vote:sirtommygunn is a better lynch but I see no momentum for that. He did try to wreck the peace between towns with his infiltration and all that and now let's make some vote analysis. In each of the last three lynches we lynched a Star Wars cultist. Whom did sirtomymgun vote? Other people. When we lynched Camikaze (Palpatine, by then admitted even by himself) he voted for spaceman98. When we lynched Backwards Logic (Darth Maul) he wanted to lynch town leader Visorslash. When we lynched Pizzaguy (Dooku) he voted for Gong 4 teh Cello Gone 3 the Celt. It's too fishy, he never ever votes for the Star Wars cult, and it's too much of a coincidence. And that is my vote.

1: Sirtommy's knowledge of Darth Vader basically confirms that he/she is cult
2: Sauron is the bigger problem right now though. You realize this, and it has been repeated multiple times. Your sudden switch, without any justification for doing so looks suspicious unvote: vote: Taki, possibly a ploy to divert attention from the problem at hand

Also, I just realized something: Arakhor claims to have been attacked, so unless someone can counterclaim, he/she is not cult

 

[spaceman98]

I love it, so predictable. You are probably both scummers, the old "bring up another target for tomorrow and hopefully I survive this lynch and can work on making a case on this name I've pulled from my underpants" routine.

I'm still not sure what part of the case against me I have not addressed, though the large voter turnout for the Takhisis lynch makes me think that Taki probably isn't Sauron. The minions have kills to though

 

[johnhughthom]

1: Sirtommy's knowledge of Darth Vader basically confirms that he/she is cult
2: Sauron is the bigger problem right now though. You realize this, and it has been repeated multiple times. Your sudden switch, without any justification for doing so looks suspicious unvote: vote: Taki, possibly a ploy to divert attention from the problem at hand

Also, I just realized something: Arakhor claims to have been attacked, so unless someone can counterclaim, he/she is not cult

 

[sirtommygunn]

1: Sirtommy's knowledge of Darth Vader basically confirms that he/she is cult

Except for the fact that I don't know who Darth Vader is, Arakhor merely assumed that I knew and asked me if I would pass along some information to him.

 

[Darth Feather]

Unvote; Vote: Takhisis (still got my eye on you, Spaceman)

 

[Arakhor]

In shock news, a LotR town member attempts to contact SW Cult, because at least they will be interested in taking down Sauron, however monumentally stupid Vader's kill was last night. Since I'm likely going to be attacked again tonight, it would be a shame to not have someone to whom to give the information I'm holding.

 

[SamSniped]

For now, Vote: Spaceman, and I'll explain stuff tomorrow once I finally have some free time.

 

[topsecret]

At the same time, I still think unvote: vote: topsecret is better, since he claims nothing except masonry to a dead player, and Zack said that there are no vanilla townies in this game. The Balrog makes sense as a one shot ability and "no ability" makes sense as a claim if you have a one shot. I am willing to see either Taki or topsecret hang

No, if I had the Balrog, I would've admitted it. And if I was a cultist, I would claim to be something besides a townie with no abilities other than a mason...

 

[topsecret]

Oh, and a "vanilla" townie has absolutely no abilities. A mason is not a vanilla townie.

Vanilla Townies are defined by having no special abilities beyond being able to post and vote during the Day like everyone else. During the Night they do nothing.

Masons are a group of players who can speak to each other privately and know that everyone in their group is not a member of the Mafia. Whether the Masons' ability to privately communicate can be used at any time or at Night only is up to the moderator's discretion.

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Mason

 

[Buddhafish]

No, if I had the Balrog, I would've admitted it. And if I was a cultist, I would claim to be something besides a townie with no abilities other than a mason...

If you had the Balrog? Shouldn't that be: If I was the Balrog?

PIS maybe?

 

[Takhisis]

1: Sirtommy's knowledge of Darth Vader basically confirms that he/she is cult

And you're not voting for someone you claim is confirmed cult because…

2: Sauron is the bigger problem right now though. You realize this, and it has been repeated multiple times. Your sudden switch, without any justification for doing so looks suspicious unvote: vote: Taki, possibly a ploy to divert attention from the problem at hand

You're really freaking out, man. I wonder how you'd've freaked out if I'd voted you.

It's not a 'ploy', you numbknuts. I'm not gonna vote for myself and I trusted you enough to scan topsecret, whose claim, surprisingly, actually checks out. Ish, after Buddhafish prodding him on the issue of Roger. So, yes, I should actually be voting for you instead of your confirmed cultist with the convenient voting patterns.

Also, I just realized something: Arakhor claims to have been attacked, so unless someone can counterclaim, he/she is not cult

He was attacked by the Witch-King and Saruman. Do you think either of them is going to come forward and say 'No really, we attacked someone else! Arakhor is claiming to have been attacked!'?

No, if I had the Balrog, I would've admitted it. And if I was a cultist, I would claim to be something besides a townie with no abilities other than a mason...

If you had the Balrog? Shouldn't that be: If I was the Balrog?

PIS maybe?

Well spotted. topsecret's still not off the hook.

 

[spaceman98]

No, if I had the Balrog, I would've admitted it. And if I was a cultist, I would claim to be something besides a townie with no abilities other than a mason...

Why would you have admitted to having an anti-town ability? Especially one that was referred to as being linked to Sauron in the very first update?

unvote: vote: topsecret