SS-18 ICBM
Oscillator
But fine, if you insist: You could argue with some justification that marriage is a purely social construction, which is recognized by the government for reasons of social benefit. But since society at large does not believe in gay marriage (At the very least, it generally fails when it comes to a vote) government recognition of gay marriage is effectively a governmental imposition of unwanted cultural values, something which is arguably Not The Government's Job in a democracy. We generally think of governments as serving the people, not telling them that they should hold different values -- especially when it concerns the allocation of privileges, rather than fundamental human rights. (I actually do think that government recognized marriage is a privilege, not a fundamental human right -- although the equally strong counterpoint is that even if marriage isn't a right, equality and fair treatment are, which would count against the unfair denial of privileges just as much as rights)
Excellent points. You always have been one of the better posters.
