I'm 4 or 5 episodes into
The Alienist. At first, I was ready to toss it onto the pile of unappealing adaptations of books I loved, alongside
Altered Carbon. It was too... I dunno... stiff? Daniel Bruhl had these weird mannerisms and Dakota Fanning seemed to be phoning it in. Luke Evans and the guys playing the Isaacsons were at least a bit charming, but seemed to be playing archetypes more than characters. Robert Wisdom and Q'orianka Kilcher were barely-there supporting characters, so even though they pulled their weight I couldn't watch it just for them. And the plot - a serial killer stalking New York at the dawn of criminal psychology and forensic science - was already getting a little bit tired when the book was published, in 1994. The blend of the period setting with the serial killer plot was inventive, at least as far as I knew, and the writing was good.
Ripper Street was a descendant of Caleb Carr's novel, and that show ended its run a couple of years ago. And that, in turn, was years after shows like
Criminal Minds and
CSI had gone from cutting edge dramas to meme-worthy punchlines.
But strangely enough, this show has caught my attention. I can't really defend watching it over
Orphan Black or
Legion or
Mr. Robot or
The Magicians, and yet I've done just that the last few days. Go figure. Fanning in particular is growing on me. Her performance is so minimalist, it's like watching one of those "Living Statue" performances in the park, waiting for them to wink at a child or reach out to accept a flower. I don't remember the character being so rigid in the book, but it's been a few years since I've read it (
The Alienist is one of the few books I've read a second time).
Is this a recommendation? Um... Er... Uh...
As an aside, years after I first read the novel I was walking through a subway corridor in New York and randomly came across an illustration of the old Manhattan reservoir on the wall. I had never heard of it until I read
The Alienist and got a little thrill from seeing it "in person", so to speak. The actual reservoir is long gone, of course. The site is the main branch of the New York Public Library now, which is itself over 100 years old (and worth a visit if you're ever looking for something to do in New York that doesn't cost you a week's pay).