Wicca and Neopaganism Thread

Can you try it without making biases against Catholicism?
Surely, as soon as Catholicism stops making itself such good bait.
And perhaps more in detail insted of a one liner attack.

Of course.
Wikipedia article entitled; "Pentagram" said:
A pentagram (sometimes known as pentalpha or pentangle) is a five-pointed star drawn with five straight strokes. The word pentagram comes from the Greek word πεντάγραμμον (pentagrammon), a noun form of πεντάγραμμος (pentagrammos) or πεντέγραμμος (pentegrammos), a word meaning roughly "five-lined" or "five lines".

Pentagrams were used symbolically in ancient Greece and Babylonia. The Pentagram has magical associations, and many people who practice pagan faiths wear them. Christians once more commonly used the pentagram to represent the five wounds of Jesus[1][2], and it also has associations within Freemasonry.

The pentagram has long been associated with the planet Venus, and the worship of the goddess Venus, or her equivalent. It is also associated with the Roman Lucifer, who was Venus as the Morning Star, the bringer of light and knowledge. It is most likely to have originated from the observations of prehistoric astronomers.[citation needed] When viewed from Earth, successive inferior conjunctions of Venus plot a nearly perfect pentagram shape around the zodiac every eight years.

Early history

Sumer
The first known uses of the pentagram are found in Mesopotamian writings dating to about 3000 BC. The Sumerian pentagrams served as pictograms for the word "UB," meaning "corner, angle, nook; a small room, cavity, hole; pitfall," suggesting something very similar to the pentemychos (see below on the Pythagorean use for what pentemychos means). In the Labat (dictionary of Sumerian hieroglyphs/pictograms) it is the number 306, and it is shown as being two points up. In the Babylonian context, the edges of the pentagram were probably orientations: forward, backward, left, right, and "above". These directions also had an astrological meaning, representing the five planets Jupiter, Mercury, Mars and Saturn, and Venus as the "Queen of Heaven" (Ishtar) above.


[edit] Pythagoreans
The Pythagoreans called the pentagram ύγιεια Hygieia ("health"; also the Greek goddess of health, Hygieia), and saw in the pentagram a mathematical perfection (see Geometry section below).

The five vertices were also used by the medieval neo-pythagoreans (whom one could argue were not pythagoreans at all) to represent the five classical elements:

ύδωρ, Hydor, water
Γαια, Gaia earth
ίδέα, Idea or ίερόν, Hieron "a divine thing"
έιλή, Heile, heat (fire)
άήρ, Aer, air
The vertices were labeled in the letters of υ-γ-ι-ει-α. The ordering (clockwise or counter-clockwise) and starting vertex varied.

Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa and others, recognized the letters as being the five beginning letters of the words: udor (water, often transliterated as hydor), ge (earth; Agrippa used gaia), idea (idea, as in the Platonic Idea), eile (heat, sometimes written as heile), and aer (air). However, even if one uses the "elemental" scheme that Agrippa used, it's a definite stretch because it uses heat (heile), which is not an element but a quality of the element fire. Had Agrippa used the Attic Greek, which is the language Pythagoreans back then actually spoke and wrote, he could have used (phonetic) "empreesis" for fire or conflagration.

The ancient Pythagorean pentagram was drawn with two points up and represented the doctrine of Pentemychos. Pentemychos means "five recesses" or "five chambers", also known as the pentagonas — the five-angle, and was the title of a work written by Pythagoras's teacher and friend Pherecydes of Syros.[3] It was also the "place" where the first pre-cosmic offspring had to be put in order for the ordered cosmos to appear. The pentemychos is in Tartaros.

In very early Greek thought, Tartaros (or Chaos, according to Hesiod) was the primordial Darkness from which the cosmos is born. While it was locked away after the emergence and ordering of the cosmos, it still continued to have an influence. In fact, it was known as "the subduer of both gods and men" (Homer), and it was from this that the world got its "psyche" (soul) and its "daimon". The Boundless Darkness held influence through Mychos or Krater. Apart from being the gateway from "there" to "here" it was also a way in the opposite direction, from "here" to "there", as is evident in the many tales about how Greek heroes, philosophers and mystics descended through Krater to Tartaros/Hades (the distinction between the two was very optional back then) in quest for Wisdom. The Underworld as the source of wisdom was the rule.

Tartaros was also later seen as the "chthonic realm" where all the enemies of the cosmic order were locked away, also called the "prison-house" of Zeus. It was said to lay outside of the aither over which Zeus had lordship; what we today would call space, back then called "Zeus' defense-wall," yet it was also beneath the earth. Plato (in Cratylus) said that the aither had a penetrating power that permeates the whole world, and he found it both inside and outside of our bodies. The pentemychos is outside, or in-side, of the aither.

In the play Medea by Euripides, the sorceress Medea calls upon Hecate with the words, "By that dread queen whom I revere before all others and have chosen to share my task, by Hecate who dwells within my inmost chamber, not one of them shall wound my heart and rue it not." Note that she speaks of the Heart. The inmost chamber is the Mychos. Normally, Hecate and Persephone are portrayed solely as the rulers of the Underworld. In Medea, however, Hecate is called the Lady of Tartaros, Phulada (Guardian), Propulaia (Before the Gates), Kleidophoros (Key-bearer) and Kleidoukhos (Key-holder, Priestess). This Underworld of the Greeks and Pythagoreans is also the "inmost chamber" and the Core of Inner Being.

This is an esoteric connection, but the Core is the Greek Goddess Kore (another name for Persephone, alongside Hecate queen of the underworld), whose symbol was the apple. If an apple is cut transversally through its core, it reveals a pentagram. The apple remains a symbol of health ("An apple a day keeps the doctor away").

Religious symbolism

[edit] Christianity

According to Heather Child's Christian Symbols, Ancient and Modern[4], the pentagram is a symbol of the five senses. Also, when the letters S, A, L, V, and S are inscribed in the points, the pentagram is a symbol of health (Latin salūs).

Medieval Christians believed it to symbolize the five wounds of Christ. The pentagram was (ironically) believed to protect against witches and demons.[5]

The pentagram figured in the heavily symbolic Arthurian romances.[5] It appears on the shield of Sir Gawain in the 14th Century poem, Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. In the poem the five lines of the star are given multiple meanings: they represent the five senses, five fingers, the five wounds of Christ[6], the five joys that Mary had of Jesus (the Annunciation, the Nativity, the Resurrection, the Ascension and the Assumption), and the five virtues of knighthood which Gawain hopes to embody: frankness, fellowship, purity, courtesy and compassion.

Probably due to misinterpretation of symbols used by ceremonial magicians, it later became associated with Satanism and subsequently rejected by most of Christianity sometime in the twentieth century.[5]

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has traditionally used pentagrams and five-pointed starts in Temple architecture, particularly the Nauvoo Illinois Temple.[1] These symbols derived from traditional morning star pentagrams that are no longer commonly used in mainline Christianity. Because of the more recent obscurity of these symbols, the use of these morning stars has been occasionally criticized as use of "satanic" and "occult" symbols, as they are commonly associated in today's culture.


[edit] Satanism
Satanists use a pentagram with two points up, often inscribed in a double circle, with the head of Baphomet inside the pentagram. They use it much the same way as the Pythagoreans, as Tartaros means Hell in Christian terminology (the word is used as such in the Bible, referring to the place where the fallen angels are fettered). The Pythagorean Greek letters are most often replaced by the Hebrew letters לויתן forming the name Leviathan. Less esoteric LaVeyan Satanists use it as a sign of rebellion or religious identification, the three downward points symbolising rejection of the holy Trinity.


[edit] Neopaganism
Many Neopagans, especially Wiccans, use the pentagram as a symbol of faith similar to the Christian cross or the Jewish Star of David. (It is not, however, a universal symbol for Neopaganism, and is rarely used by Reconstructionists.) Its religious symbolism is commonly explained by reference to the neo-Pythagorean understanding that the five vertices of the pentagram represent the four elements with the addition of Spirit as the uppermost point. As a representation of the elements, the pentagram is involved in the Wiccan practice of summoning the elemental spirits of the four directions at the beginning of a ritual.

The outer circle of the circumscribed pentagram is sometimes interpreted as binding the elements together or bringing them into harmony. The Neopagan pentagram is generally displayed with one point up, partly because of the "inverted" pentagram's association with Satanism, however within traditional forms of Wicca a pentagram with two points up is associated with the Second Degree Initiation and in this context has no relation to Satanism.

Because of a perceived association with Satanism and also because of negative societal attitudes towards Neopagan religions and the "occult", many United States schools have sought to prevent students from displaying the pentagram on clothing or jewelry.[7][8][9] In public schools, such actions by administrators have been determined to be in violation of students' First Amendment right to free exercise of religion.


[edit] Samael Aun Weor
Samael Aun Weor used the Pentagram to represent man's Atman, or Internal Christ. When a man's limbs are outstretched thus that his feet are planted on the ground while his head is situated atop his body it creates the omnipotent symbol of the pentagram. Through the Mantra "Klim, Krishna, Govindaya, Gopijana, Vallebayah, Swahah" one's inner being is said to be awakened and come to the initiate's aid. Aun Weor stated that no demon could resist the power of this mantra, since one's Logos cannot be overcome by a demon of any stature.

In contrast to representing one's Logos, the inverted pentagram represents one's Umbral Guardian, the malignant antithesis of the divine father. When the pentagram's inferior rays point upwards, it represents Satan. This symbol is therefore shown above as the goat of the Witches' Sabbath, which serves as a call to the vast columns of demons.
 
No matter how the symbol is, first thing that comes to mind when they see it, is Nazi. Hell, I still do it.
Thats how I see all swastikas pointing clockwise.

Gilder said:
It isn't a bias. It's the truth.
Calling it a "smear campaing" is biased to my eyes because it's implying that they are doing something negative as well as a jab on my religion. A better non biased approach would be to not attack the church and use neutral terms and words.

A BETTER sentance would be "The pentagram is seen as demonic because Christianity (Mind you Christianity was one religion before 1054) has associated with the symbol with satan worship or gnostic beliefs" Also, it was not just Catholics who did this, remember our good friends the Protestant Puritans in Massachusetts? They wernt innocent eather when it came to persecution of witches.
 
Surely, as soon as Catholicism stops making itself such good bait.
Just remember to not shoot the messenger. I may be a Catholic Christian, but I dont represent all of Catholicism.

Cheeze the Wiz said:
Of course.
Thanks, I have also rummaged around for sources on this thing on Wicca.
 
The Pentagram is a pagan symbol, pal. Your Catholic Chruch demonized it in a smear campaign while expanding into Europe.

Catholics like christianity generally do not make a distinction between pagan gods and demons. consider for example 1 Cor 10:19-20: <<19 What am I saying then? That a thing sacrificed to idols is anything, or that an idol is anything?

20 But I say that the things which the Gentiles sacrifice, they sacrifice to demons, and not to God, and I don't desire that you would have fellowship with demons.>>

And perhaps I was a bit hard on wiccans, most of whom probably are not aware what they are getting themselves into. As one who spends much of his free time counceling mentally troubled people coming out of the occult and paganism and seeing the torment they daily go through, I guess I just don't have a tremendous amount of tolerance for the subject.
 
Calling it a "smear campaing" is biased to my eyes because it's implying that they are doing something negative as well as a jab on my religion. A better non biased approach would be to not attack the church and use neutral terms and words.

A BETTER sentance would be "The pentagram is seen as demonic because Christianity (Mind you Christianity was one religion before 1054) has associated with the symbol with satan worship or gnostic beliefs" Also, it was not just Catholics who did this, remember our good friends the Protestant Puritans in Massachusetts? They wernt innocent eather when it came to persecution of witches.


And the reason the Church came to associate it with Satan is because of a smear campaign. It is hardly a jab at your religion, but it is a phrase that describes what happened.
 
it was not just Catholics who did this, remember our good friends the Protestant Puritans in Massachusetts? They wernt innocent eather when it came to persecution of witches.

i agree except on one point. the part about them being guilty, since Exodus 22:18 says <<Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live.>>
 
Depends on what orientation the Swastika is. If its rotated 45 Degrees with the arms going Clockwise, then it is an association with Nazism. Any other orientation would not make them nazis.

CivGeneral said:
Thats how I see all swastikas pointing clockwise.
Sure. Of course. I think that what you actually do is think "nazi" first, then realise, "oh no it's counter-clockwise"

Then please explain to me why the pentagrams (especialy the upside down ones pointing to the ground) are associated with demonic worship to Christians. (Note, I would appreciate it if the explanation was done in a respectiful and civil maner. Please avoid any attacks on me or my faith.)

But what if I look at a pentagram upside-down from the guy who drew it? Does that make it satanic? Or what if I look at an Indian Swatiska in a mirror? Oh no I think I'm going cross-eyed again.
Anyway Cheezy FTW on his post.

What is annoying is that you assume that Christianity has the sole correct explanation for pentagrams, even when everybody's telling you that pentagrams have been around for longer than Christianism.
 
I don't blame Paul for saying that idols were actually demonic (except for his speech on Mars Hill), but once Christianity had more power it became a political thing.

I also see that it is not only the Christians who complain that their religious beliefs are being attacked while criticizing others.

More importantly, I am of the opinion that many of the basic tenets of neopaganism and Wicca are silly (at least, believing in them because it is the cool thing to do) but whatever, one must believe what they think is correct.
 
Baselss stereotype. Wicca and Neopaganism are an entirely seperate thing from New Age Spirituality. It is true that they both have some roots in Victorian Era mysticism, but they have evolved to a point where they have very few similarities.
What are the differences?
 
More importantly, I am of the opinion that many of the basic tenets of neopaganism and Wicca are silly (at least, believing in them because it is the cool thing to do) but whatever, one must believe what they think is correct.

Oh yeah, let it be said here that I also do not hold Wiccan beliefs to the highest regard.
 
I don't blame Paul for saying that idols were actually demonic (except for his speech on Mars Hill), but once Christianity had more power it became a political thing.

point taken. sometimes i hit that reply button kind of too soon. the various so-called christian churches were indeed guilty of using witchcraft as a pretense for persecuting/martyring the innocent. I say so-called because Christ himself never taught anything like the inquisition or other forced conversion persecutions.
 
But do they believe on the greek/roman gods? That's a honest question. While there are plenty of wiccans around here (or people who call themselves that), I've never met a neopagan.
Some do. Depends on the particular Neopagan. They worship different pantheons, but the most popular seem to be the Celtic pantheon.

I'm not forced to respect all faiths. When I smell BS I name it BS. And this goes for Wiccas as it goes for most christian evangelical movements.
All I'm asking is that before you make any conclusions, you first learn about the religion. From what you said you, like most people, obviously have very limited knowledge of Wicca and Neopaganism. As such, you are in no position to make judgements.

Here's a question: why did people begin to believe in this sort of thing in the 60's, centuries after nobody took it seriously? It makes about as much sense
Here's a question: why did people begin to believe in Christianity in the early 20th century? Seriously though, it is because that the 60's were a period when society began to question its conventions, and this lead to people seeking out a different truth than what they had been raised believing in. Many found Wicca, which had been existence for a long time and is based on millenia old traditions, to hold the kind of truth they were looking for, that it spoke to them in a way Christianity and other religions did not.

Once agan, show me the differance between the pentacle and pentagrams that wiccans use and the pentacle and pentagrams that the Church of Satan uses.
First, let me point out that the Church of Satan is not a real theology, but rather a pseudo-religion that uses Satan as a symbol for defiance of social norms. In reality members of the Church of Satan are atheists who put on themselves no code of morality. If you want a religion that is merely a revolt against social norms, the Church of Satan is it. Secondly, let me point out that leaders in Neopaganism have been even more vocal in their opposition to the Church of Satan than Christian leaders. In particular Isaac Bonewitz, the founder of Ar nDraiocht Fein: A Druid Fellowship is very outspoken against the Church of Satan. Thirdly, let me point out that the Church of Satan only uses the inverted pentacle because the Church artificially turned it into a symbol of evil, it was never so prior to Christianity and it isn't to anyone outside of the Christian social tradition. Fourthly, let me point out that the Church of Satan uses the inverted pentacle, where as Wicca almost entirely uses an upright pentacle or pentagram.

Well I cant blame them, since they do practace unorthodox magic that is alien and santanic to us Christians.
Wiccan magic is no different from Christian and Shinto ritual and prayer. Wiccans believe that through ritual and appeal to the divine, they may be able to effect the future or present shape of things. They do not believe that by waving a wand they can somehow transform a frog into a prince, it is nothign like that. Wiccan magic is the same thing as Christian or Shinto prayer, just more ritualized, with a higher emphasis, and with a more controversal name.

You know screaming does not help anything. I already told you that I am in the middle ground. Dont ever assume that I dont have an open mind :rolleyes:. This is a debate thread, is it not? You cant exclude people who disagree with Wicca out of this thread. Its your job to influence the ignorant, not tell them to shut up :rolleyes:.
Actually, I meant it as a thread to clear up misconceptions, not for people with anti-Wiccan biases to sound off. Secondly, you are hardly in the middle-ground; if you believe that something is devil-worship, that is a pretty strong opinion. Sorry if it came off like I was yelling, I was merely trying to emphasize the necessity of maintaining an open mind when discussing something like this.

Depends on what orientation the Swastika is. If its rotated 45 Degrees with the arms going Clockwise, then it is an association with Nazism. Any other orientation would not make them nazis.
The Nazis used several orientations for different uses, including ones used by Hindus, Buddhist, Falun-Gong, etc.

Christians only see the pentagram if pointing down (also with a demonic face of the devil) as santanic.
Then the Wiccan pentacle is not Satanic, although (one of) the Shinto one(s) would be.

Then please explain to me why the pentagrams (especialy the upside down ones pointing to the ground) are associated with demonic worship to Christians. (Note, I would appreciate it if the explanation was done in a respectiful and civil maner. Please avoid any attacks on me or my faith.)
Because as the Christian Church, and later the Catholic Church, expanded they took note of the resilience of traditional religion among the peoples they sought to convert. As such, they tried to either demonize or Christianize the symbols, holidays, and practices of those peoples. This included, among other things, Samhain (which became Holloween), Noel (which became Christmas), and the pentacle, which became a symbol of Satan as opposed to a symbol of the unity of nature, humanity, and divinity.[/QUOTE]

What are the differences?
New Age Spirituality, while still not exactly what you are thinking of, is still closer to what you are thinking of than Neopaganism and Wicca. Neopaganism is a legitamate religion that attempts to revive pre-Christian religion, with varying levels of syncreticism and reconstructionism. Practitioners are not much different from practitioners of other religions, even if they are on the whole more cynical, scholarly, and nature focused. Wicca is similar, but unlike Neopaganism it is much more of a modern religion with a theology that, while very similar to and based in pre-Christian religions, is not a pure attempt and reconstructionism or even reconstructionist syncreticism.
 
Then please explain to me why the pentagrams (especialy the upside down ones pointing to the ground) are associated with demonic worship to Christians. (Note, I would appreciate it if the explanation was done in a respectiful and civil maner. Please avoid any attacks on me or my faith.)

I would not avoid them, and in this case, it's damn well impossible. Everything you associate with demonic worship is nothing more than symbols of other religions - you even got Lucifer's name from the roman worship system!
 
Fourthly, let me point out that the Church of Satan uses the inverted pentacle, where as Wicca almost entirely uses an upright pentacle or pentagram.
That I am fully aware off.

Wiccan magic is no different from Christian and Shinto ritual and prayer. Wiccans believe that through ritual and appeal to the divine, they may be able to effect the future or present shape of things. They do not believe that by waving a wand they can somehow transform a frog into a prince, it is nothign like that. Wiccan magic is the same thing as Christian or Shinto prayer, just more ritualized, with a higher emphasis, and with a more controversal name.
Well, I dont see Wiccan Magic as the same thing as Christian and Shinto ritual and prayers.

Actually, I meant it as a thread to clear up misconceptions, not for people with anti-Wiccan biases to sound off.
Well youre bound to get stuff like this.

Secondly, you are hardly in the middle-ground; if you believe that something is devil-worship, that is a pretty strong opinion.
I am sorry to say, but I am off course on the middle-ground. Let me explain it to you further. I do believe that Wicca is a form of devil-worship HOWEVER, I feel that the statement is weak in itself and I desire proof that they eather "devil worshipers" or not. Hense when I am stating I am in the middle ground, I am refering myself as the needle on a dial that is on the middle area. Right now I am in the middle region because:
1. I believe that Wiccans are devil worshipers. However I also feel that the argument does not hold weight so...
2. I am looking for any such proofs that they are not "devil worshipers" and debunk any such myths.
3. I have not fully solidified my opinions on this.
4. I am skeptical to what Protestant Christianity has said about Wiccans.

I came looking for any such evidences and proofs that would reasure my skepticism that Wiccans are not devil worshipers as well as solidify my beliefs. However some people dont see that with me :rolleyes:.

Then the Wiccan pentacle is not Satanic, although (one of) the Shinto one(s) would be.
The Pentacles that I would consider satanic would be this one:
Pentagram_with_one_point_down_%28de_Guaita%29.jpg


As for Shinto ones, I dont see them as santanic.
 
Not everything has been debunked however. Perhaps some more research should be done by you. Can you tell me how John Edward channels the dead like he does so convincingly to so many people for instance? I doubt you have an answer to that.

Jesus may or may not be; but, John Edward's is a tool preying upon vulnerable people. His technique is referred to as cold reading: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_reading .
 
Wrong. It is very much shaped by Christianity, in a million subtle ways. The entire way of looking at the religion comes from Christianity. Unless, of course, you have been raised in a non Judaeo-Christian civilisation.

If that's your view on things perhaps you should keep that in mind next time you go on your usual rants about practically all other religions than hinduism, viz your previous post in this thread.


Your arrogance - in assuming that you know a culture and religion better from the outside than I do from the inside - is astounding. As said earlier, I don't do ad-homimens. Nor do I do strawmen. Nor a number of other logical fallacies. That is left to my opponents.

I see, so you're free to criticize everyone else, but no one is allowed to criticize your culture or religion without being called arrogant by you?

I rest my case.
 
I came looking for any such evidences and proofs that would reasure my skepticism that Wiccans are not devil worshipers as well as solidify my beliefs. However some people dont see that with me :rolleyes:.
From COG, a website representing various Wiccan congregations:
Q. Do Witches worship the Devil?
No. The concept of "the devil", a personification of a supreme spirit of evil and unrighteousness, is a creation of Middle Eastern thought which is fundamental to some religions of that region, including Zoroastrianism, Christianity and Islam. Worship of this being as "Satan" is a practice of profaning Christian symbolism and is thus a Christian heresy rather than a Pagan religion. The gods of Wicca are in no way connected with Satanic practice. Most Witches do not even believe Satan exists, and certainly do not worship him. Historically, the gods of an older religion are often branded as the devils of a newer one in order to promote conversion.
Rest of FAQ.
 
If that's your view on things perhaps you should keep that in mind next time you go on your usual rants about practically all other religions than hinduism, viz your previous post in this thread.

What does what you posted have to do with what I posted which you were quoting and (presumably) replying to?

I see, so you're free to criticize everyone else, but no one is allowed to criticize your culture or religion without being called arrogant by you?

I rest my case.

:lol:

Thank you for validating my point for me. I have never said or even implied that no one may criticise me or my beliefs. I have just said that I will do whatever I feel is necessary to refute such criticism if it is unfounded. Your implying that I have said that anyone who criticises me is arrogant is the classical fallacy which I mentioned in the post which you quoted - the strawman :lol:.

And being English educated and having come from an essentially Western system, I know both the Hindu as well as the Judaeo-Christian civilisation from the inside. I know how both work, and what are the flaws of both - something most people cannot see, because they know only one intimately.

Anyone is free to criticise my beliefs - but I have the right to call them out on their ignorance;) (if they are ignorant, that is - well-founded criticism will be accepted). Arrogance comes in when you refuse to acknowledge your ignorance when it has been pointed out to you.
 
Back
Top Bottom