Would you consider Italy to be in Western Europe?

Is Italy in Western Europe?

  • Yay

    Votes: 54 80.6%
  • Nay

    Votes: 13 19.4%

  • Total voters
    67

Rossiya

Fridge Magnet Porn
Joined
Mar 10, 2006
Messages
6,981
Yes, it's that time of year to apply for college and sixth form in England, and so the conundrum of that "Ethnic background" section ensues...

However, the section of my school's admission forms is weird- as you may know, my father is Italian, making me half Italian. Therefore, this would be a good option to tick if it was on the sheet- but it is not. :scan: This is one of the bad things of these sorts of questions in British application forms, the only recognised white ethnicities are British and Irish.

My school, however, has provided a little more choice, still no Italian. English (yes, I am, but the whole point of this section is to display your ethnic background, which I consider to be a mix of Italian and English, only one box can be ticked), Scottish (nay), Welsh (nay), "Other White British" (not really sure what this means), Irish (nay), "Traveller of Irish Heritage" (gippo, most certainly not), "White Eastern European" (Polish, Kosovans, I suppose; do I include Italy in this?), "White Western European" (Is Italy in Western Europe?), Gypsy/Roma (no) and "Any other White Background" (if Italy is not in Western Europe, I suppose I would put this).

So this brings me to my question. I have asked this question to people, and their answers have ranged from, "Shut up, you're English", to "Italy is in Southern Europe" (not an option :mad:). Neither helps me.

So, the question is: "Would you consider Italy to be in Western Europe?"

If the majority says "yes", I shall put myself as a "White Western European", if the majority of the poll is "no", I shall be a person of "Any other White background".

The obvious answer to the question would be that Italy is in Southern Europe, and Central Europe, but neither is applicable...

"Western Europe":

Western_Europe_map.png


Note the interesting inclusion of Greece. Of course, does "Western Europe" refer to cultural Western Europe, or geographical Western Europe?

Answer!
 
I would definately say Italy is in Western Europe. It is in the south of Western Europe, but still in Western Europe.
 
Being a dual citizien, I always tick "white other", since I don't feel "white British" accurately conveys my ethnicity.
 
Italy is southern Europe.

See the following map.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...ons_of_Europe.PNG/800px-Regions_of_Europe.PNG

Yellow is western Europe.
Green is southern Europe.
Cyan is central Europe.
so on...

Wiki shows the same thing...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Location-Europe-UNsubregions.png

Here is the whole wiki article.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Europe

Yes, I know Italy is in Southern Europe! :crazyeye: It's not an option in the section though (stupidly).

Being a dual citizien, I always tick "white other", since I don't feel "white British" accurately conveys my ethnicity.

You are French, no? Would you, perhaps, in this case, put "White Western European" then?
 
I'd put it in Southern Europe. In your case, I don't know what I'd do.

I often have this problem myself.

What do I choose between:

- White central European
- Slav (white eastern European)
- Latin
 
Yes. "Western Europe" is only a useful concept, IMO, if it includes Germany, Austria, Italy, Greece, etc., which are more historically, culturally, and ethnically (I think) linked to France and Britain than to Russia, the Ukraine, etc., which are, of course, "Eastern Europe."

It's funny that if we go by that map, then the answer to "Is Portugal in Western Europe?" is apparently "no," even though it's the westernmost country!
 
gee, here in america we have just white.

is there really enough distinction between the whites in europe?
 
Shut up, you're English :D
 
Yes, Italy is part of Western Europe.
 
Italy is aligned with Western Europe.

Why is that ethnicity question so complicated? Do they quota everything or is it just used for other purposes, sinister or not?
 
Italy is aligned with Western Europe.

Why is that ethnicity question so complicated? Do they quota everything or is it just used for other purposes, sinister or not?

No idea. Does it really matter what ethnicity I am? Perhaps, it is used to shut the PC people up, saying that yes, we do have Asian, African, whatever students.
 
Italy is culturally Western Europe. Finland shouldn't be Western Europe culturally or geographically, I wonder why it is included.
 
Yet another reason why categorizing people on race is stupid.


I would consider northern Italy(by the Alps) to be Western European and I would consider the boot and the various islands Mediterranean. Of course this division probably isn't very useful in modern times.
 
Back
Top Bottom