Seems like post #715 was ignored, so I should have -2 points and Earthling should have +1; these adjustments have been made (along with my own votes).
Takhisis ~ 13
CivGeneral ~ 19
Duke Blackstone ~ 17
landlubber ~ 6
Joecoolyo ~ 8
Owen Glyndwr ~ 18
civplayah ~ 5 Odd numbers are good, now it takes three hits to kill him
Catharsis ~ 14
Dachs ~ 16 pfft, I missed a couple of days... no coming back from that I fear
ZeletDude ~ 9
Earthling ~ 16
DroopyTofu ~ 13