Challenging the "Five Second Rule"

What do you do?


  • Total voters
    59

Whomp

Keep Calm and Carry On
Retired Moderator
Joined
Dec 17, 2004
Messages
18,200
Location
Chicago
You know you've done it and 70% of women and 65% of men were familiar with the five-second rule, and most utilized the rule in their decisions to eat food that had fallen on the floor.

The conclusion was that in most cases, dry floors would be safe to eat from.
This was confirmed by two students at Conneticut College.
Click the video here
http://abcnews.go.com/gma
They dropped skittles and apple slices on the campus dining room floor.
Skittles were good for at least a minute and the apple slices for thirty seconds.

A study on the five-second rule was also performed by Jillian Clarke, a high school senior, during a seven-week internship at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign in 2003.

Clarke in her tests wanted to test the five-second hypothesis in cases where the floor was known to be contaminated. She therefore spread E. coli on both rough and smooth floor tiles in a laboratory, placed pieces of gummy bears and cookies on the tiles for various amounts of time, and then examined the foods under the microscope. All the foods had a significant amount of bacteria in less than five seconds. She also found that women were more likely than men to use the rule, and that cookies and candy were more likely to be picked up than broccoli or cauliflower.

So how lucky do you feel today?
 
Very Lucky. Also I'm not around to many E coli infested floors. (I hope.)
 
Interesting, but I have to say I am no fan of these studies generally performed by students which conclude nothing of any real use, If i drop something on the floor I won't think "Hmm, I saw this study, and generally on this type of floor surface it would be a bad idea for me to pick up these food and use it". Of course thats partly because while I would be thinking that the dog would have eaten it.
 
Didn't myth busters bust the 5 sec rule?

Are they saying Myth busters were wrong?
 
I have no problem eating from the floor. Everything is on the floor.
 
Didn't myth busters bust the 5 sec rule?

Are they saying Myth busters were wrong?
No mythbusters did it with e coli infested floors and said it would take less than 2 seconds. Time was not a factor when food is exposed to bacteria.
 
I haven't died from food that i've picked up off the floor and ate yet
 
Unless I'm on a sidewalk cafe in the poor section of Calcutta during a New Year's Day soccer riot...

If you can get it within five seconds, it's a five second rule. If it takes you fifteen seconds, use the fifteen second rule. It's all relative. ;)
 
I could see not picking up dropped brocolli myself. It's too squishy. It's not scientific, but I'm more inclined to pick up a hard M&M or cookie than a soft food, like a slice of cheese.

But Mikey always likes what I give him.
 
Of your examples, I'd only eat gummi bears or Skittles on the ground, and only within 5 seconds.
 
Unless I'm on a sidewalk cafe in the poor section of Calcutta during a New Year's Day soccer riot...

And you don't get sick, you don't get infections, and you never get headaches? :)

I never eat anything that has fallen on the floor.
 
At home I can't really eat something off the floor because I live in a house with three fur-bearing animals. If I'm in a clean house, however, I don't mind eating something I've dropped on the floor.
 
At home I can't really eat something off the floor because I live in a house with three fur-bearing animals.
Yourself included?
 
Damn lucky. All the time.

Seriously...humans survived hundreds of thousands of years roughing it. Man up.
 
Back
Top Bottom