dragonprobably
The Poster Formerly Known as MartinLuther
Sorry I'm late. I had stuff to do.
If the watcher could see the killer, why couldn't he see the guy protecting you? How were you certain, of all the people the watcher said targeted you, Jarrema was the killer?
Why would you be suspicious of me even though we agree?
You expect us to believe that. choxorn wasn't even acting scummy, why would you have killed him?
Vote: Jarrema
Perphaps he is like Diamondeye's role from Those Darn States. In which case, Jarrema could be a sort of serial killer if he's that overpowered.
Jarrema attacked me - somebody protected me. Time to lynch Jarrema.
If the watcher could see the killer, why couldn't he see the guy protecting you? How were you certain, of all the people the watcher said targeted you, Jarrema was the killer?

For most of the game I haven't had much real ground for suspicion. I'm not terribly great at reading people, and this is the first proper mafia game I've been in.
While answering for myself is something I can do, so I have done that.
So I am suspicious of Visorslash. He acts sort of weird and go a bit all over the place, but I don't know if that's just how he acts while being part of the town.
Also if I recall correctly, he's sort of been "jumping on the bandwagon" both times mafia got lynched, and I wonder if that's to avoid suspicion. Likewise he's the only one that's said like "town's great" for lynching mafia, again, maybe to avoid suspicion.
However, now, unlike before, I am pretty much convinced that I have found a mafia:
Vote: MartinLuther
Why would you be suspicious of me even though we agree?
ok. I confess. I attacked Visorslash tonight. I want him dead, based on his behavior I am almost sure he is scum (I described my thoughts earlier). Vote: Visorslash.
And no, I dont agree with you, dcmort. It is not exactly how he always is. In previous games, when he was thinking I belong to town, he cooperated with me, and revealed to me. In this game, he explicitly stated that he thinks I am town, and at the same time he refused to cooperate in any way.
I will also reveal. I am Gandalf, and I have bunch of abilities. In more details, I can attack someone, block someone, or protect someone. I killed Choxorn already, and protected chosen target at night 1.

Vote: Jarrema
I hate to say it, but that sounds really scummy. A jack-of-all-trades I could buy, but one with reusable abilities, especially one that can kill as well?
Perphaps he is like Diamondeye's role from Those Darn States. In which case, Jarrema could be a sort of serial killer if he's that overpowered.