NOTW XLIV: The Root of All Evil GAME THREAD

[DaveShack]

I'm finding Bad Player's story a little hard to believe.

 

[choxorn]

Let's also not forget that Bad Player didn't reveal himself -- NinjaCow revealed Bad Player (and if BP turns out to be innocent, rather unwisely).

That actually just raises further questions. So, BP scanned stg mafia on night 1, and didn't vote for him instantly. While strange, it's somewhat understandable- you might want to scan someone else innocent and get them to reveal the mafia scan. Then he scanned Celtic... and told NinjaCow about the scans, for no apparent reason. Yes, he's a Bad Player, but his play has been bad on the level of "insane" if he's innocent.

 

[Zack]

That actually just raises further questions. So, BP scanned stg mafia on night 1, and didn't vote for him instantly. While strange, it's somewhat understandable- you might want to scan someone else innocent and get them to reveal the mafia scan. Then he scanned Celtic... and told NinjaCow about the scans, for no apparent reason. Yes, he's a Bad Player, but his play has been bad on the level of "insane" if he's innocent.

I wasn't offering it up as a defense for him, just pointing it out. I'm as skeptical of Bad Player as the next guy.

 

[Kennigit]

why is that insane?

honestly, why? What if ninja was also a relatively simple scanner and scanned badplayer? They gets to talking, etc. Or masons or whatever. Not saying it's ideal, but these words "ridiculous" and "insane" get thrown around and I really am missing the insanity.

Also verarde you need to do more than pop in and say "eh, seon?" and now just go "choxy boxxy wants bad player dead" (paraphrased). Seon was an innocent lynch, and choxorn is already on fire for being too sheepish. You're lower than a sheep, it's just a lemming at this point.

 

[choxorn]

I suppose that's plausible. So, Bad Player, why exactly did you claim to NinjaCow, anyway?

 

[Takhisis]

I don't see how this is scummy, he's claimed to be a scanner but later backed down from the lynch when confronted about it, he wasn't immediately murdered after revealing that either so that's even more odd. Also, since he is claiming I am mafia when I know I'm not, then I know he is either lying and a mafia or has a useless scanner role, neither of which are really all that bad to lynch.

Also I didn't vote for him yesterday because I know that in all of your eyes OMGUSing a scanner is basically putting a sign above your head saying "MAFIA HERE".

So, you don't do things like voting someones you think is scum because voting scum is scummy?

He claims you're mafia when *you* 'know' you're not.

also since I like posting before I type everything I want to say, here's another double post:

takhisis needs to answer already for his thought process in a non spammy way. He's not answering any PMs--not even with the common courtesy of calling me ridiculous--, he's being incredibly scummy, and he is also acting consistently with other times he has been mafia (read: every game).

Takhisis didn't answer your PMs?

Unvote, Vote: Takhisis

Takhisis never answers inquiring PMs when he's mafia.

Yes, except for the simple problem of me never having got a PM. Kennigit's obvious lie is obvious. To my great regret I must allow LordNwahs6 to escape and tell Kennigit to explain why he lies so obviously.

why is that insane?

honestly, why? What if ninja was also a relatively simple scanner and scanned badplayer? They gets to talking, etc. Or masons or whatever. Not saying it's ideal, but these words "ridiculous" and "insane" get thrown around and I really am missing the insanity.

Also verarde you need to do more than pop in and say "eh, seon?" and now just go "choxy boxxy wants bad player dead" (paraphrased). Seon was an innocent lynch, and choxorn is already on fire for being too sheepish. You're lower than a sheep, it's just a lemming at this point.

I thought I was the one being spammy…

 

[Kennigit]

oh come now, you really think I would lie about something as trivial as sending a PM? cfc has some hiccups sometimes, but it's in my sent folder.

quick edit- it didn't say much more than was already said by me in the thread though.

 

[Takhisis]

Erm, no, just no. I haven't got a PM from you since November.

 

[Bad Player]

Really? So Seon managed to get in contact with another doctor, and told them to protect you despite finding you suspicious?



True, you could lie and just say you scanned him innocent, or pretend to be a false scanner and say you scanned him mafia.

But you could also lie, say you got nothing and as such, don't know whether you're a true scanner or not, and can thus convince us to waste today lynching sirtommygunn, claim to be a false scanner when he comes up innocent, and then waste tomorrow lynching CELTICEMPIRE.

Seon said that doctors know that there is a group of doctors and that a doctor contacted him. Seon thought he might still die (I asked ATPG who said I should let Seon live in case he was genuinely a doctor) so he asked this doctor to protect me last night.

I think CELTICEMPIRE is innocent because he has been inactive so he couldn't have killed anyone so if I was mafia then claiming false scanner if sirtommygun flips innocent would not work. As I said, lynch me if sirtommygun is innocent!!!


I roleclaimed to NinjaCow because he was accusing CELTICEMPIRE and I didn't want a bandwagon to start on him.

 

[sirtommygunn]

So, you don't do things like voting someones you think is scum because voting scum is scummy?

Well that's certainly changing the context of what I did, but yes voting for someone who claims they are a scanner just seems to make everyone around here convinced the scanner is real. I simply don't have the charisma to convince everyone here that he's lying, so it was better to just vote strategically to avoid the lynch.

 

[Takhisis]

Ah, so you 'don't have the charisma' (as if it were a stat, really) so let's just not vote for the scum, eh?

 

[sirtommygunn]

I'm voting for him now, aren't I? I'm a bit confused you see, because what you said implies I'm not voting for him, so I would like you to clear the air on that issue for me.

 

[choxorn]

My Detect Scum ability is being overloaded by the insane amounts of scumminess on this page.

 

[Verarde]

SO ISSSSSSSS MINE OH WAIT WRONG GAME

Hi.

 

[Bad Player]

If I'm wrong about sirtommygun lynch me I'm that confident!

 

[Takhisis]

I don't like it when people dare the town to lynch them.

 

[landlubber]

Day over. I apologize for the lateness, and I won't be able to update until about an hour from now. If someone could quickly get a tally together, that would be great.

 

[landlubber]

End of Day Four​

The Champion's Guild had another productive day of marching. By the end of the next day, they will be outside Kaluge for sure. Wanting to ensure a successful mission against the Red Dragon, the Champions were very aggressive. The main candidates for the lynch were Bad Player and sirtommygunn.
After hours of fierce debate, it was decided that Bad Player must be a foreigner, and a threat to the mission to capture the Hoard. As several Champions approached Bad Player with swords drawn, he stood tall and proud, not at all fearful of his fate, but he appeared remorseful. As the first sword struck him, he closed his eyes, expecting to die. Instead, the sword could not penetrate his skin. Strike after strike was made, but no wounds appeared. Bad Player had a look of confusion on his face, seemingly unaware of why he could not be killed.

Spoiler :

Bad Player survived the lynch through unknown means!

Bad Player: 5
sirtommygun.: 4
Kennigit: 1
Takhisis: 1

Night ends in 24 hours!
Send actions to me!

Living Players (16/24)
choxorn
DaveShack
Bad Player
bonefang
Autolycus
Verarde
Mergle
Red_Spy
classical_hero
BigTin
CELTICEMPIRE
Kennigit
sirtommygun
Zack
LordNwahs6
Takhisis

Deceased Players (8/24)
BSmith1068, a loyal Champion murdered Night One.
Gone 3 the Celt, a loyal Champion lynched Day Two.
Jarrema, a loyal Champion murdered Night Two.
J65536d, a loyal Champion torn to pieces Night Two.
Seon, a loyal Champion lynched Day Three.
NinjaCow64, a loyal Champion murdered Night Three.
Askthepizzaguy, a loyal Champion torn to pieces Night Three.
SouthernKing, a loyal Champion who faced the wrath of the Gods Night Three.

 

[choxorn]

Bad Player survived the lynch through unknown means!

Seems perfectly legit, bro.

 

[landlubber]

I only received two orders. I'd really like more, for the sake of balance, so I'm extending night by 24 hours.