NOTW XLIV: The Root of All Evil GAME THREAD

[Autolycus]

Bad Player, why did you not investigate Pizza last night? You should know by now your accuracy.

 

[Bad Player]

I did but he died and not because of me. ATPG believed sirtommygun is innocent and didn't want to lynch him without confirmation. ATPG wrote all this in the threa for you!

 

[sirtommygunn]

Bad Player at worst you're a false scanner and at best you're a fairly obvious mafia.

 

[Bad Player]

I'm telling you s t g is mafia I'm sure of it.

And you're 3rd on the bandwagon.

 

[classical_hero]

vote:sirtommygun If this is wrong, then we know whom to go after.

 

[Takhisis]

Bad Player, your claims of scannicity are ridiculous but sirtommygun voting you just like that with a mere 'yeah, the others are right' is scummy too.

LordNwahs6, my vote stays on you. You lurk, hang a lampshade on your lurking and then go lurkerifficaly back to the grave after posting a vote.

 

[Kennigit]

Bad Player, your claims of scannicity are ridiculous

you keep using that word. why is it so ridiculous?

anyways, vote: sirtommygun

 

[Takhisis]

Hey, the word scannicity isn't ridiculous!

 

[Mergle]

sirtommygun for all the reasons given yesterday. If he's mafia, choxorn looks suspcious for spurious reasoning on atpg killing (everyone heard that conversation!), otherwise, badplayer is the villain.

 

[sirtommygunn]

Bad Player, your claims of scannicity are ridiculous but sirtommygun voting you just like that with a mere 'yeah, the others are right' is scummy too.

I don't see how this is scummy, he's claimed to be a scanner but later backed down from the lynch when confronted about it, he wasn't immediately murdered after revealing that either so that's even more odd. Also, since he is claiming I am mafia when I know I'm not, then I know he is either lying and a mafia or has a useless scanner role, neither of which are really all that bad to lynch.

 

[sirtommygunn]

Also I didn't vote for him yesterday because I know that in all of your eyes OMGUSing a scanner is basically putting a sign above your head saying "MAFIA HERE".

 

[Zack]

And why would you kill me if you were mafia? Nobody believes any of my random rambling rants/accusations, killing me would only give me credibility and make you look suspicious.

"This is why I haven't been dying tonight! Not because I'm mafia!"

 

[Kennigit]

I don't see how this is scummy, he's claimed to be a scanner but later backed down from the lynch when confronted about it, he wasn't immediately murdered after revealing that either so that's even more odd.

a supposed 3-time scanner wouldn't be worth a fifth of his weight in dragon gold if he isn't doing anything against archy. The mafia would have no need to fear him.

as opposed to something like seon, a claimed doctor. Mafia would love to lynch him.

 

[Kennigit]

also since I like posting before I type everything I want to say, here's another double post:

takhisis needs to answer already for his thought process in a non spammy way. He's not answering any PMs--not even with the common courtesy of calling me ridiculous--, he's being incredibly scummy, and he is also acting consistently with other times he has been mafia (read: every game).

 

[choxorn]

I did but he died and not because of me. ATPG believed sirtommygun is innocent and didn't want to lynch him without confirmation. ATPG wrote all this in the threa for you!

You did scan him? Then what was the result?

You're speaking in circles, Bad Player, and the explanations are getting increasingly ridiculous.

 

[Verarde]

For the reason that chox just pointed out, Bad Player.

 

[Bad Player]

I told you I scanned ATPG and Seon spoke to someone to have me protected last night (I spoke to Seon and ATPG privately after Seon did a role claim and I followed ATPG's advice). Because ATPG died I got told no result (but even if I was mafia I could simply lie regardless).

The only point of scanning ATPG (since I presumed him innocent based on some things he told me) was to determine if I'm a true scanner (I figured this is most likely) or a false (reverse) scanner.

 

[Zack]

also since I like posting before I type everything I want to say, here's another double post:

takhisis needs to answer already for his thought process in a non spammy way. He's not answering any PMs--not even with the common courtesy of calling me ridiculous--, he's being incredibly scummy, and he is also acting consistently with other times he has been mafia (read: every game).

Takhisis didn't answer your PMs?

Unvote, Vote: Takhisis

Takhisis never answers inquiring PMs when he's mafia.

You did scan him? Then what was the result?

You're speaking in circles, Bad Player, and the explanations are getting increasingly ridiculous.

Let's all keep in mind that this is the same guy who demanded payment from his fellow known innocents for protection, and chose to protect Jabba the Hutt instead of Jedi.

 

[choxorn]

I told you I scanned ATPG and Seon spoke to someone to have me protected last night (I spoke to Seon and ATPG privately after Seon did a role claim and I followed ATPG's advice).

Really? So Seon managed to get in contact with another doctor, and told them to protect you despite finding you suspicious?

Because ATPG died I got told no result (but even if I was mafia I could simply lie regardless).

True, you could lie and just say you scanned him innocent, or pretend to be a false scanner and say you scanned him mafia.

But you could also lie, say you got nothing and as such, don't know whether you're a true scanner or not, and can thus convince us to waste today lynching sirtommygunn, claim to be a false scanner when he comes up innocent, and then waste tomorrow lynching CELTICEMPIRE.

 

[Zack]

Let's also not forget that Bad Player didn't reveal himself -- NinjaCow revealed Bad Player (and if BP turns out to be innocent, rather unwisely).