Serving in secret: Being transgender in the US military

[Vectors]

U.S. Army Maj. Jamie Henry has served in the military for more than a decade, working as a doctor at the Walter Reed National Military Medical Center in Maryland. But from the moment she joined the Reserve Officers’ Training Corps at 17 years old, she had no choice but to lie about who she really was.

“I’ve been transgender my whole life,” she said.

Henry, 32, was born biologically male and named James but said she has always felt female. She knew revealing this secret to anyone in the military could mean losing the job she loves. “For the longest time, it was very difficult, very painful — much of it inner turmoil that I couldn’t express with my colleagues,” she said.

Although “don’t ask, don’t tell,” which barred openly gay and lesbian people from serving in the military, was repealed in 2010, transgender individuals must still serve in silence. The Department of Defense’s medical guidelines state that anyone with what it terms “psychosexual conditions” such as “transsexualism” and “transvestism” is disqualified from service.

In the past, many transgender troops were discharged after being diagnosed with gender dysphoria, a strong feeling that a person is not his or her physical gender. The military does not keep any records of how many transgender service members have been dismissed. A study by the Williams Institute at UCLA estimated that 15,500 transgender people are serving in active duty or in the National Guard or reserve forces.

Being discharged from the military has been on Henry’s mind after coming out this year. She came out to her commanding officer and then slowly to each of her colleagues. She is the first known active-duty U.S. Army officer to come forward as transgender, but her story is not unique.



Retired U.S. Navy pilot Brynn Tannehill understands the frustration and pain transgender people feel serving in the shadows. She earned her Navy wings in 1999 flying helicopters and maritime patrol aircraft during three deployments. She left the Naval Reserve in 2010 to transition to a woman. She said the hardest decision was choosing between being her “authentic self” and serving her country.

“It was extraordinarily difficult, and it feels unfair,” she said. “It feels as if what I’m capable of is being wasted.”

Tannehill now works with former and active LGBT service members at the nonprofit SPART*A (Service Members, Partners and Allies for Respect and Tolerance for All).

The U.S. military has recently taken some steps to help transgender service members. This year the Air Force, Army, Marine Corps and Navy issued new guidelines that make it harder to discharge transgender service members. And the American Medical Association last month unanimously passed a resolution stating that there is no “medically valid reason to exclude transgender individuals from service in the U.S. military.”

Defense Secretary Ash Carter recently signaled support for transgender military service. In February, during a visit to troops in Kandahar, Afghanistan, he said, “I don’t think anything but their suitability for service should preclude them.”

But as long as the ban on being transgender is officially in place, Tannehill and other advocates say the pressure to hide their gender identity can take a huge emotional toll. In June, for example, the military transgender community lost one of its own. Decorated Air Force Staff Sgt. Jess Shipps, who served for more than a decade and left last year to transition to a woman, took her own life. Henry remembers Shipps as someone “filled with joy” but dealing with “deep dark thoughts.” She met Shipps through advocacy work with SPART*A.

“Even as we’re getting so close, so hopeful, there’s still so much pain for so many servicemen. We have so much at risk to lose,” said Henry.

As the community mourns, Tannehill said Shipps’ death has encouraged her to keep pushing for change. And there is some hope that progress is being made. Last month Tannehill and five other transgender service members were invited to the annual LGBT pride month reception at the White House. The best part for Tannehill: She was authorized to wear the Navy dress whites for women.



“It felt good,” said Tannehill. “It felt very good to actually be myself and be in uniform at the same time, because the rest of my time in uniform, I wasn’t being myself.”

Since coming out, Henry is proving that being transgender in the military is possible. In March she requested that her name and gender be changed in her permanent military and medical records, and to her surprise, the request was granted.

“As I’m coming out, I’m like, oh, my God, they might be accepting transgender service members. I’ll have my career back,” said Henry. “I can just be like any other doctor in the military. That’s incredible to me.”

Al Jazeera America

I just read this article and was wondering what people think about transgender people serving in the military and transgender people in general.

 

[Arwon]

Transgender people are allowed to serve in the Australian military. Colonel (now Group Captain in the RAAF) Cate McGregor was speech writer and advisor to the chief of the army and her resignation was refused after she came out in 2012. She's also friends with the Prime Minister.

This is really a bit of a no-brainer. We've got a long way to go socially and legally on transgender people and this is part of that.

 

[Kozmos]

As long as it doesn't affect what they do or their team. Lives are on the line after all.

That said, my knowledge is murky on the whole gender dysphoria thing. Does it have a basis in some kind of random biological variation that sends mixed signals to the brain/body or is it purely a psychological preference or a mental formation or what?

 

[IglooDame]

I just read this article and was wondering what people think about transgender people serving in the military and transgender people in general.

I think now that the gates are officially open to homosexuals in the military that they will follow suit with transgender folks. What do I think about them? I have a lot of empathy for them and wish them well in their military service.

 

[Formaldehyde]

It is a slippery slope. Before you know it they will be recruiting dogs to fight in combat.

Seriously, this is a heroic gesture on her part to publicly come out. I just hope it doesn't lead to serious difficulties with other service members.

 

[Joecoolyo]

It is a slippery slope. Before you know it they will be recruiting dogs to fight in combat.

 

[Smellincoffee]

I think the amount of people claiming to be transgender exceeds -- greatly -- the number of people who have actual chromosomal issues. It is an issue not worthy of the attention it receives, but that's what you get when people have more time on their hands than they have productive things to do.

 

[Arwon]

Why does transgender people outnumbering intersex people mean anything?

 

[Zkribbler]

Now, I am so confused.
[q]“I’ve been transgender my whole life,” she said.[/q]
I'm under the impression that transgender meant post-op. What she says makes sense only if it includes pre-op.

She was born a male, and if she's still pre-op, then she must be dressing like a male, 'cause if she didn't, then even the army is smart enough to figure things out.

My best friend since high school came out to me, post-op, about a decade ago when I went to his place for Thanksgiving dinner. Within a few moments, it became apparent that the only changes were physicial. He, now she, was the same person. But this explained why I seen him struggle for decades with identity issues. I'd visiting to find him a slender fitness nut, then a fat slob, then a Muslim, then a law student, then an actor with a bicep like a twig bearing the SAS's "Who Dares Wins" tattoo on it. But I'd always just put that down to him being a towering intellect going stir-crazy in a backwater town.

Surprise, his son, now daughter has followed in his footsteps. Maybe the smartest person I ever knew, but crippled with debilitating depression, both pre-and-post op.

My friend was, and his offspring is, the nicest and smartest of people...when not being overwhelmed with psycological issues.

 

[Arwon]

Transgender doesn't just mean post-operative.

 

[cardgame]

The word you're looking for is transsexual (post-SRS), transgender is a broad term.

 

[bhavv]

I have always wished that I had been born a female.

Does that make me transgender?

 

[Arwon]

Nope.

 

[cardgame]

Not necessarily. Being transgender generally means you suffer from body dysphoria - your mental gender and physical gender don't align and cause terrible stress.

 

[bhavv]

It causes me terrible stress that I cannot be a beautiful princess wearing a diamond tiara and a pink tutu

 

[Arwon]

That sort of oh-so clever degradation and mockery isn't funny once you understand things like transgendered person suicide rates.

 

[bhavv]

Oh but I'm serious. I like pink tutus and tiaras.

 

[Berzerker]

thanks for your service

 

[Zkribbler]

Oh but I'm serious. I like pink tutus and tiaras.

Then wear them! It's a free country.

 

[Takhisis]

Isn't the Army supposed to make a man out of you?