nerdfighter13
Prince of the Universe
Where is Poland? Poland is in Civ 5.
Actually, far from anachronism, I'm using an even more modern conception of Europe than the dated, 1990s version you're using. People who still think that Europe extends to the Urals, or that Russia is a part of Europe in any meaningful way, are indeed living in the distant past. Europe extends at best to Romania, Moldova, Latvia & Estonia. Even Ukraine and Belarus are only barely part of Europe in the 21st century -- I would personally exclude them from any meaningful understanding of Europe in this day and age. Looking at the modern conception of Europe, it's clear that Poland and Czech Rep are in the Eastern half, while Germany and France are in the West. Scandinavia is obviously Northern Europe while Italy, Spain, Portugal and Greece are clearly Southern Europe.
Yes, if you want to continue using an ancient definition of Europe that extends to the Urals, and merely update this raw geography with 1990s borders, then fine, go ahead. But I'm personally going for a more relevant, 21st century approach, which takes Europe to be a meaningful group of like-minded countries, quite aside from the corruption and authoritarianism of Modern Russia. This Europe indeed has PL and CZ in its East, but it's in the East of something meaningful and forward thinking, not backward and fearful like the old 1990s Europe.
If you want to talk about geography, look at Russia and look at Asia and tell me they aren't the same thing...
Funny thing is, last time this thread came up, everyone in PL and CZ was at pains to say that Russia was nothing like Poland or Czech Rep, that it was a historically and culturally distinct entity that had nothing to do with the rest of Europe. Now everyone's bleating about how European Russian culture is and how it so obviously belongs with Poland and Czech Republic! Hilarious.
It's a term invented after the Cold War for Eastern European countries to distinguish themselves from Eastern Europe, the former Soviet Union, and communism.
I've been skimming through this thread's many pages for a bit now and I can accept your definition. If the European Union(/or better, EU+Schengen Europe) is the definition of Europe we are going with, then Poland is indeed in the eastern half of it.
That however, does not take away the fact that Poland is culturally Central European. Your updated definition doesn't change what culture group Poland is in, and neither does your exclusion of Russia from the European sphere suggest that Russia is no longer in the Eastern European cultural group.
There is so much wrongness here, I don't even know where to begin
But it's easter, so happiness and vodka for all!
I was drinking Martini yesterday on Easter, not Vodka...![]()
![]()
There is so much wrongness here, I don't even know where to begin
But it's easter, so happiness and vodka for all!
Are You sure You are Polish ?All true Polish drink Voka hahhaha
![]()
I'm Silesian, so i'll be happy with just a beer.![]()