‘Alien: Romulus’ Review – Fede Álvarez Reignites the Franchise with Grimy Thrills
The future of the
Alien franchise was clouded in mystery after the 2019
Disney-Fox merger. The House of Mouse would have been foolish to leave the iconic IP untouched, but giving director Ridley Scott a third film to complete his prequel trilogy also seemed very unlikely given the divisive response to both 2012’s
Prometheus and 2017’s
Alien: Covenant. Flash forward 5 years, and we’re now left with
Alien: Romulus, a standalone prequel set between Scott’s original
Alien (1979) and
James Cameron’s Aliens (1986). Helmed by writer-director Fede Álvarez, famous for the 2013
Evil Dead remake and 2016’s
Don’t Breathe,
Alien: Romulus has all the right ingredients to reignite the franchise’s popularity in the zeitgeist. And, to no surprise, it does so in style. By all means, this is the series comeback that Disney and 20th Century Studios were hoping for. However, that studio-driven purpose hinders its own true potential.
Bringing a filmmaker like Fede Álvarez, who’s adored in the horror community, into the
Alien IP is a dream come true for many fans. The director’s taste for bleak themes, off-putting characters, and cruel set pieces is the perfect recipe to tell a new kind of
Alien story. But unlike 2022’s
Prey directed by Dan Trachtenberg, which brought back the
Predator series,
Alien: Romulus is less of a standalone genre exercise and more of a revamp with connective tissue. In this way, it does seem like there was more studio oversight involved, including the guidance of Ridley Scott as a producer, to attract as many newer folks as possible to the franchise. This retroactively hinders
Alien: Romulus as it feels like it’s often more concerned with reminding audiences how spectacular, frightening, and simply awesome an
Alien movie can be by retreading familiar ground rather than being its own thing.
Alien: Romulus centers on the relationship between young space colonist Rain Carradine (Cailee Spaeny) and her synthetic android Andy (David Jonsson). Stuck in a life of servitude to the Weyland-Yutani corporation on a desolate mining planet, Rain dreams of escaping off-world. She longs to set foot on Yvaga III, the supposed peaceful planet where colonists go to retire after completing their work. Moreover, it’s where the sun actually shines. Stuck in this dream, Rain only has Andy to lean on. Rain’s father, before his death, programmed Andy to be her primary caretaker — but in most cases, she has to look after him as he’s got glitches in his system. The two are barely getting by on their own when one of Rain’s old friends, Tyler (Archie Renaux), comes back into the mix with the offer of a lifetime.
Tyler is orchestrating an illegal escape to Yvaga III with his sister Kay (Isabela Merced), his cousin Bjorn (Spike Fearn), and Bjorn’s girlfriend Navarro (Aileen Wu). Rain is invited to join in, though only with the help of her synthetic Andy. Their plan is to sneak aboard a long-abandoned space shuttle orbiting just above their mining planet. Andy, being an android, can grant them access to the ship’s hypersleep chamber and look after their cryo pods while they travel across the galaxy for the whole 9 years it takes to reach their destination. With nowhere else to go, Rain reluctantly agrees. In true
Alien fashion, the group soon discovers that they aren’t infiltrating a forgotten spaceship but the deserted Romulus space station, and it’s filled with secrets. Once they stumble across a room full of facehuggers that were being mysteriously stored by Weyland-Yutani, you know how the rest goes.
The biggest setback of
Alien: Romulus has nothing to do with its relatively straightforward premise. While its “back to basics” horror approach will definitely turn off people who are expecting something as risky as Ridley Scott’s prequels, there are still enough fresh ideas present to enlighten the franchise’s lore and storytelling. This is mainly seen in the brother-sister relationship between Andy and Rain. Their siblinghood introduces a new kind of dynamic to the
Alien universe, one that brings out surprising amounts of emotion within the viewer. This is the most cunning part of Fede Álvarez’s screenplay, which is co-written by longtime collaborator
Rodo Sayagues. Their bond is constantly pushed to the limits, putting Rain in a position where she can turn on Andy for following his programming, especially when under eerie circumstances. Ultimately, Rain’s decision-making in these moments builds a distinct identity that separates her from past
Alien protagonists.
Cailee Spaeny, who is impressively coming off both Alex Garland’s
Civil War and Sofia Coppola’s
Priscilla, leads
Alien: Romulus with great vigor while still giving Rain a raw vulnerability. Likewise, David Jonsson (
Industry,
Rye Lane) injects Andy with the kind of pathos that can’t be easily replicated. Johnsson steals the show when Andy is unsuspectingly given a new directive relating to the Xenomorph, completely switching gears and seeming like a completely different character with his android etiquette. Rain and Andy’s sibling dynamic makes up for the thin supporting cast, which is mainly here to get their own fudged up, yet highly memorable death scene. Given the classic horror structure of the script, this isn’t that big of a deal. Fede Álvarez made it work in the
Evil Dead remake, and he mostly pulls it off here as well. However, there is one huge element working against
Alien: Romulus… nostalgia.
For some incomprehensible reason,
Alien: Romulus pulls off a nostalgic callback to Ridley Scott’s
Alien that is brought to life with uncanny CGI. Also, it’s not just one scene or reference — the movie keeps cutting back to this creative choice from the second act all the way to the end. Easter eggs are one thing, but to constantly keep going back to a nostalgia-fueled decision like this, to the point where it cannot be ignored or is no longer easy to swallow, just takes you out of the film each time. Not since
Lucasfilm decided to open
Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny with a 25-minute (!) action set piece with a freakishly de-aged Harrison Ford has there been a creative decision relating to VFX that is this outright perplexing. It’s upsettingly uncanny and, frankly, unnecessary. A real shame because the rest of
Alien: Romulus is utterly breathtaking.
At least in the visual department, it’s evident that Disney is willing to shell out the proper resources to create an
Alien film that surpasses modern blockbuster expectations. With the help of Mexican cinematographer
Galo Olivares (
Gretel & Hansel), Fede Álvarez has crafted the most visually stunning movie of his career. From the busy streets of the dreadful mining planet to the cold interiors of the Romulus space station,
Alien: Romulus boasts an immersive tactility and griminess in its vast sets. Of course, the practical facehuggers and animatronic Xenomorphs are welcomed back with open arms too, and they look better than ever. Aside from the sleek visuals, though, huge credit has to be given to Álvarez’s staging and blocking.
Alien: Romulus ups the ante with one extremely tense set piece after the other, all of which introduce never-before-seen, imaginative scenarios that build up to a truly bathorsehocky insane third act.
At the bare basics of its plot,
Alien: Romulus isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel. But, thematically, it presents enough exciting ideas to prove that filmmaker Fede Álvarez could continue to push the series into uncharted territory with a sequel. If only the movie didn’t make that one
damning nostalgic choice. It’s hard to know who to blame for this outcome — was Álvarez in over his head or was there pressure from Disney/20th Century Studios to overstate
Romulus‘ ties to the original film? In trying to appeal to older fans and affirm its place in the franchise,
Alien: Romulus ends up doing one of the few things that would turn dedicated fans away. It’s quite ironic, repeating certain plot points of the original movie is nothing new for
legacy sequels. Yet, Álvarez would have done a better job at letting his unique ideas breathe if not for this nostalgic inclusion.
Still, despite its one glaring flaw that works overtime to bring the rest of the film down, it’s hard not to be enamored with the sheer imagination behind
Alien: Romulus. When director Fede Álvarez frames entire action set pieces filled with Xenomorphs with clear inspiration from the
Alien: Isolation video game, and even some in zero gravity that bring to mind the beloved
Dead Space series, you would be hard-pressed
not to be over the roof of what this filmmaker can do in the franchise next.