JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
So much for being the land of freedom.Prisoners per 100,000
Spoiler :![]()
U!S!A! U!S!A!

Spoiler :![]()

So much for being the land of freedom.Prisoners per 100,000
Spoiler :![]()
U!S!A! U!S!A!
Spoiler :![]()
Why does Granada have a mostly Green flag? I doubt there are many muslims there now
I suppose that a number of the 'seperatist' regions are not really active or serious (eg Crete).
He was Italian, wasn't he?![]()
Cortés dealt with the Maya? No, with the Aztecs
Aladdin's weird. The characters are Muslim but the original setting is China at least in the version that was related to Antoine Galland and later added to the One Thousand and One Nights. The train of transmission is this: Galland listened to a Marionite in modern Syria relate Alladin. He then added Alladin which is set in China to the One Thousand and One Nights. Disney's Alladin is rather corrupt. Anyways, to return to Galland because his story and that of the One thousand and One Nights still has a bit of mileage to go. Galland's version of the One Thousand and One Nights is based on an Arabic version. (I believe from Syria but don't quote me on that). But the One Thousand and One Nights proper is actually set in Persia and is based on earlier Persian versions. The Arabs to their credit didn't change much: the storyteller is universally identified as Šahrzâd and the person she is telling the story to is her fickle husband Shahryar both of whom are obviously Persian. (Shahryar literally means Great King in Persian). Lets move on: the origin of the Thousand and One Nights is probably traceable to a book called the Hazār Afsān (Thousand Stories) which is even more Persian because we know it was a favorite of the Sassanids but unfortunately it hasn't survived. So far sas we can tell, the main difference seems to be the incorporation of the framing device, Šahrzâd, to link the stories and the inclusion of a range of non-Persian stories into the collection(s). (There's a few iterations). Anyways, Galland who was French added Aladdin to the collection based on a story told to him by a Marionite in what-is-now modern Syria about events that happen in China. (Interestingly, Sinbad and Ali Baba were also added into the collection by European translators). And that's that. Make of if what you will.cybrxkhan said:For Aladdin artist doesn't bother to distinguish between Arabia and Iran in his/her reasoning (which is a pity as there is nothing much to suggest Iran over the Arab world), but I think the movie makes more sense as somewhere closer to the Levant/Fertile Crescent, the setting is too urban a place to be in the middle of the Arabian desert.