• We are currently performing site maintenance, parts of civfanatics are currently offline, but will come back online in the coming days. For more updates please see here.

Altered Maps XVI: Gerardus Mercator Must Die

Status
Not open for further replies.
jgb3lmrukn601.png

Hm, any accompanying map with percentage of Untouchables (caste) in India?

Moreover, in rural areas, many parts have very low access to running water, eg they still rely on wells and rivers and manual carrying of water in rural areas.

Though i suppose that evenso India likely has more toilets than all of the EU ^_^
 
Toilet revolution!

Hopefully they're adopting Japanese toilets instead of Western toilets.

I felt like such a peasant when I returned to Canada from Japan and looked at the sort of toilets we have. Never before have I felt like arriving in the 3rd world when returning from a trip.. It was so depressing
 
I felt like such a peasant when I returned to Canada from Japan and looked at the sort of toilets we have. Never before have I felt like arriving in the 3rd world when returning from a trip.. It was so depressing

Well... Japan (going by Tanizaki, one of their most famous 20th century writers) does have a thing with this too. I wouldn't want to refer to his description of a samurai castle and a tied scene.
Iirc i gave up after that passage. Which is something, considering the book already had been about things like sexual arousal from watching severed heads of fallen samurai.
 
I'm not sure what comfortable pooping has to do with decapitation though?
Uncomfortable pooping leads to spontaneous decapitation and or exploding head syndrome.
 
I wonder why Spanish is so popular in Nepal. When I was there the dominant 2nd/3rd language seemed to be English. I don't think I heard any Spanish at all
Maybe they want to communicate with the dominant language across an ever greater expanse of land in the 'Muricas?
 
Still can't figure out what the Italian and Turkish-learning countries are, but I have a suspicion about the latter.

never heard of them , and the site is tough to grasp . But ı do have an "understanding" of the fear that permeates even a "joke" site . And love that it even predates the failed referendum . Poster long defined as manic depressive at times .
 
Moreover, in rural areas, many parts have very low access to running water, eg they still rely on wells and rivers and manual carrying of water in rural areas.
Those places there will have to settle for outhouses and/or porta-potty's, which are still light years ahead of going in open fields....
 
Toilet revolution!
Though i suppose that evenso India likely has more toilets than all of the EU ^_^
I felt like such a peasant when I returned to Canada from Japan and looked at the sort of toilets we have. Never before have I felt like arriving in the 3rd world when returning from a trip.. It was so depressing

*sigh*
Anybody... everybody... should immediatly get that this is a lie, just by looking at the map.

Let me do a 2-minute McResearch:

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/03/world/asia/india-toilet-movie.html
https://www.washingtonpost.com/worl...ory.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.1908b18ed58b

Quoting from the above articles:
"India’s prime minister, Narendra Modi, troubled by how many Indians still relieve themselves in the open, has vowed to build a staggering 100 million new toilets.
All across the country, new latrines are going up, sometimes so fast they are not connected to anything, creating toilets to nowhere that are so fly-ridden and stinky that almost no one will use them."

"Government officials say they have spent $4 billion to help install 50 million toilets so far, building community latrines and providing subsidies for people to put them in their homes. The Modi government runs a website bestowing on top-performing villages a special “ODF” (Open Defecation Free) status."

"To win favor with the ruling party's top brass, government officials have set to work, trying to outpace one another with toilet-building races and eye-catching information campaigns. Many are resorting to controversial public shaming tactics.
[...]
India is vast and difficult to govern; in outlying regions such as Beed, where central control is weak and corruption levels high,"

"Some argue that Modi is overly optimistic about the pace of change. 'No country anywhere in the world has come anywhere close to eliminating open defecation that fast,' said economist Dean Spears, a sanitation expert, referring to the 2019 target. 'There's no reason to think this is going to be an exception. It's very easy to say that it's a behavioral-change program. But when 500 to 600 million people defecate in the open, you need an awful lot of people on the ground to change that.'"

"Every morning in this district in rural India, teams of government employees and volunteer 'motivators' roam villages to publicly shame those who relieve themselves in the open. The 'good-morning squads' are part of what one official called 'the largest behavioral-change program anywhere in the world.'"

"Rural women sometimes endure taunts and even sexual assault when they relieve themselves outdoors, so they travel in small groups, often before dawn, for protection."

"Not helping matters, hard-liners with the governing Bharatiya Janata Party, or B.J.P., have photographed women who relieve themselves outside in an effort to shame them. Earlier this year, a man who stood up for such women was beaten to death."​

https://news.trust.org/item/20171027134652-neohr

"A flagship government programme to modernise India's sanitation has failed to tackle the practice of low caste women clearing faeces by hand, and has even exacerbated the problem by building toilets not connected to water supplies, campaigners say.
[...]
But Dalit communities, especially women, are still forced to be manual scavengers, a euphemism for clearing faeces from dry toilets and open drains by hand, despite laws to end the practice. The workers have it harder now, activists said."​

https://www.indiatoday.in/india/raj...eward-corruption-rajasthan-1054904-2017-09-29
Headline says it all:
"Money siphoned off under Swachh Bharat Mission Scheme due to possible collusion at ground level"

TL;DR:

1. They claim to be building 100 million "toilets".
2. Of that they claim to have build roughly half (which magically still had allmost the full effect).
3. They actually didn't. -> Potemkin.
4. What they built (probably way less than 52 million) are mostly communal outhouses with no water connection.
5. People mostly don't use them (and then very ugly things happen); but sometimes people do use them (and then very ugly things happen).
6. The whole thing costs about 9 billion dollars. 90$ per "toilet" (real or imagined).
That's 90$ including bureaucracy, massive caroonishly ginormous corruption, public service announcements, lynch mob level paid harrassment campaigns, that whole "rewards" programm etc.
Never mind the actual toilets.
 
*sigh*
Anybody... everybody... should immediatly get that this is a lie, just by looking at the map.

Let me do a 2-minute McResearch:

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/03/world/asia/india-toilet-movie.html
https://www.washingtonpost.com/worl...ory.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.1908b18ed58b

Quoting from the above articles:
"India’s prime minister, Narendra Modi, troubled by how many Indians still relieve themselves in the open, has vowed to build a staggering 100 million new toilets.
All across the country, new latrines are going up, sometimes so fast they are not connected to anything, creating toilets to nowhere that are so fly-ridden and stinky that almost no one will use them."

"Government officials say they have spent $4 billion to help install 50 million toilets so far, building community latrines and providing subsidies for people to put them in their homes. The Modi government runs a website bestowing on top-performing villages a special “ODF” (Open Defecation Free) status."

"To win favor with the ruling party's top brass, government officials have set to work, trying to outpace one another with toilet-building races and eye-catching information campaigns. Many are resorting to controversial public shaming tactics.
[...]
India is vast and difficult to govern; in outlying regions such as Beed, where central control is weak and corruption levels high,"

"Some argue that Modi is overly optimistic about the pace of change. 'No country anywhere in the world has come anywhere close to eliminating open defecation that fast,' said economist Dean Spears, a sanitation expert, referring to the 2019 target. 'There's no reason to think this is going to be an exception. It's very easy to say that it's a behavioral-change program. But when 500 to 600 million people defecate in the open, you need an awful lot of people on the ground to change that.'"

"Every morning in this district in rural India, teams of government employees and volunteer 'motivators' roam villages to publicly shame those who relieve themselves in the open. The 'good-morning squads' are part of what one official called 'the largest behavioral-change program anywhere in the world.'"

"Rural women sometimes endure taunts and even sexual assault when they relieve themselves outdoors, so they travel in small groups, often before dawn, for protection."

"Not helping matters, hard-liners with the governing Bharatiya Janata Party, or B.J.P., have photographed women who relieve themselves outside in an effort to shame them. Earlier this year, a man who stood up for such women was beaten to death."​

https://news.trust.org/item/20171027134652-neohr

"A flagship government programme to modernise India's sanitation has failed to tackle the practice of low caste women clearing faeces by hand, and has even exacerbated the problem by building toilets not connected to water supplies, campaigners say.
[...]
But Dalit communities, especially women, are still forced to be manual scavengers, a euphemism for clearing faeces from dry toilets and open drains by hand, despite laws to end the practice. The workers have it harder now, activists said."​

https://www.indiatoday.in/india/raj...eward-corruption-rajasthan-1054904-2017-09-29
Headline says it all:
"Money siphoned off under Swachh Bharat Mission Scheme due to possible collusion at ground level"

TL;DR:

1. They claim to be building 100 million "toilets".
2. Of that they claim to have build roughly half (which magically still had allmost the full effect).
3. They actually didn't. -> Potemkin.
4. What they built (probably way less than 52 million) are mostly communal outhouses with no water connection.
5. People mostly don't use them (and then very ugly things happen); but sometimes people do use them (and then very ugly things happen).
6. The whole thing costs about 9 billion dollars. 90$ per "toilet" (real or imagined).
That's 90$ including bureaucracy, massive caroonishly ginormous corruption, public service announcements, lynch mob level paid harrassment campaigns, that whole "rewards" programm etc.
Never mind the actual toilets.

So you are saying that their plan is crap and the money was thrown down the drain. Smells bad, though i suppose politicians are POS everywhere.
 
He wasn't talking to those people. :dunno: He just felt the need to "gotcha" people who off-handedly mused or joked about a drive-by map in a serial thread.
Maybe i disagree with you on the drive-by-ish nature and purpose of the thread.
Certainly arguments can be made either which way.

It is telling however, that you are making, yet again, rather grandious assessments of my character and my psyche...
...on a flimsy basis such as me having prefaced the meat of my post with "*sigh*".
 
Maybe i disagree with you on the drive-by-ish nature and purpose of the thread.
Certainly arguments can be made either which way.

It is telling however, that you are making, yet again, rather grandious assessments of my character and my psyche...
...on a flimsy basis such as me having prefaced the meat of my post with "*sigh*".

It's not a grandiose assessment to say that you felt the need to "gotcha" people who weren't looking for a fight. You say that the flimsy basis used is that you prefaced your post with a sigh but neglect to include the following sentence where you finger-wag at us for believing a lie and then jump right into a "two minute McResearch". Educational is not the intended result when you belittle your audience.
 
It's not a grandiose assessment to say that you felt the need to "gotcha" people who weren't looking for a fight. You say that the flimsy basis used is that you prefaced your post with a sigh but neglect to include the following sentence where you finger-wag at us for believing a lie and then jump right into a "two minute McResearch". Educational is not the intended result when you belittle your audience.
Fight?

I don't know whether you knew all or most of what i referred to.
Maybe your comment ("Toilet revolution!") was ironic. I don't know that either.
I never claimed to possess any of the above knowledge.
:dunno:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom