The 30 year late automobile insult was accidental, but now I almost wish it wasn't.
Nope! It persists today. Are you even bothering to read the topic, watch the videos, and even read a link, to see a persistent depiction from the time of the Yellow Peril as Asians immigrated to America to PRESENT DAY with the bizarre depiction of Asians in America?
Why not actually forget whatever you think is going on and listen to the Asians who have experienced this nonsense? Why not actually read and learn about it?
I know, that would challenge your world-view too much.
It's not a 30 year slight. It's over a fifty year slight that still happens on a weekly basis in America. The whole point is to try to raise some awarenes so that some Asian kid that's ten years old doesn't have the same crap happening.
Well what you describe sounds very similar to many of the stereotypes about Asians... that they are timid, weak, docile, submissive, socially awkward, and also nerdy, obedient, studious, etc. It sounds like what you are saying is that the stereotypes are true, and Asian parents are to blame for teaching their children to live up to these stereotypes. Is that what you are saying? If so then how can you simultaneously bemoan the stereotypes? For example, who told you that you were part of the "model minority?" Did your parents use that term? Or did you come up with that term yourself to describe your perception of what Asians are/should be? I have never heard Asians described as the "model minority" before.Part of being the "model minority" is being told by your parents that you're supposed to stay quiet, work within the system since it's obvious by media images and history that Asians are unwanted in America.
You mean Asian-Americans right? Cause I see a lot of Asians marching, protesting, rioting etc in Mumbai, in China, and other countries all over Asia. If your point is that American Asians don't protest... OK... but why? Why is it that Asians in India, and China and Taiwan, Nepal and Myanmar, etc seem perfectly willing to do all those things that you say Asians don't do? What is different about those Asians? Is it that they are facing some actual hardships in their lives, that actually warrant protests? Or do you feel that they are (and I admit I am extrapolating here) just lazy troublemakers like the people who do that sort of thing in the US?Asians try not to complain ... We don't try to create a political force. We don't riot. We don't march.
Again, what "Asian culture in general"? You've seen the protests and political unrest constantly going on in Asia... BTW, The Middle-East, Pakistan, Iran... those are all in Asia too, just sayin'... It does sound like you are saying that you embrace the stereotypes associated with Asians and as you say "fetishize" them. Is that correct? Do you buy in to the Asian stereotypes I mentioned?Does seem like Asian culture in general doesn't get off on outrage in the same way Americans do. Americans love outrage (left, right, black, white) whereas yeah, Asians seem to tend to shrug off such nonsense & get on with making money/achieving goals... I kind of fetishize these Asain beliefs (and focus/discipline) to be honest.
Docile means - Easily taught or managed. Do you think this word applies to the stereotypical perception of Asians or not?Hmmm, so being peaceful and patriotic and not bucking the system is docile?
What about "studious?" Do you think that the word "studious" applies to what you describe or not?Interesting. So putting the irritation into acquiring an education such as to improve one's income and economic stability is weak?
Well, yes that is exactly what the term "nerdy" implies. When I think of someone nerdy, I think of someone who does not stand up to bullies, ridiculers etc. I think of a person who gives up on having a vibrant "social life" and instead just focuses on schoolwork so that they can be financially successful later. So yes "educated" and "nerdy" often do go hand in hand in-terms of stereotypes. So are you saying that you don't think that educated people are stereotyped as being nerdy?So ignoring the words of bigots and working diligently to get the next generation to study and succeed is being nerdy? Interesting.
Anyone can be a spin-doctor and turn "educated" into "nerdy".
Note that these statistics all deal with perception rather than reality... "X% of people think such-and-such to be so" or "X% of people say that such-and-such will happen"Asian Americans have a pervasive belief in the rewards of hard work. Nearly seven-in-ten (69%) say people can get ahead if they are willing to work hard, a view shared by a somewhat smaller share of the American public as a whole (58%). And fully 93% of Asian Americans describe members of their country of origin group as “very hardworking”; just 57% say the same about Americans as a whole.
Actually, now I'm kinda curious, are there any other Asian-Americans here (or Asian-Canadians, Asian-Australns, Asian Brits, what have you)? Other than me, TK, Leonel (if I recall correctly), bhavv (I think) and jacketgull?
What does control the world mean? And what's proportional?
Money = influence. If you have a few billion dollars for instance & control a major news media outlet you're going to "control the world" more that Joe Schmo the media-consumer.Dude, Jews definitely do not control the world. It is a lot more.. complicated than that.
Why I think 'Asian' I think of Chinese/Japanese/Korean people. Not geographically totally correct but just the way I think of them. I consider India separately as well as Russia & former soviet nations & don't think of Middle Easterns as 'Asian" (even though they are of course).Again, what "Asian culture in general"? You've seen the protests and political unrest constantly going on in Asia... BTW, The Middle-East, Pakistan, Iran... those are all in Asia too, just sayin'... It does sound like you are saying that you embrace the stereotypes associated with Asians and as you say "fetishize" them. Is that correct? Do you buy in to the Asian stereotypes I mentioned?
Also more intelligent, more virtuous and, naturally, more modest.Buddy, I'm braver than you could possibly imagine.
I would say it's a convention that most people ascribe to, perhaps subconsciously. "Asian" usually means someone of Japanese, Korean, or Chinese descent. I think it's pretty stupid too, but it seems to have stuck.
In the UK "Asian" generally refers to south asians only, for example.
I get that it's not everyone who does this, but when you walk up to a random person on the street and show them a picture of an Israeli man, a Kazakhstani man, and a Japanese guy, all labelled, and ask "Which one of these is Asian?", most people won't say ".. All of them are".
I'm just trying to say that these stereotypes that are being discussed as "asian" for teh most part only apply to east Asians (and in some ways to south asians too).
You know what, there is no natural boundary between Europe and Asia, so it's hard to determine where one ends and the other begins. As Konrad Adenauer used to say "Asia begins east of the Elbe River". So you and me would be Asians as well by such definition. "Eurasian" is a compromise, I guess.
Narz said:Why I think 'Asian' I think of Chinese/Japanese/Korean people. Not geographically totally correct but just the way I think of them. I consider India separately as well as Russia & former soviet nations & don't think of Middle Easterns as 'Asian" (even though they are of course).
In the post Matzke emphasized the idea of clines, roughly a continuous gradient of genetic change over space. Fair enough. But in the map above I traced two linear transects. I would suggest that anyone who has a general understanding of the demographics of South-Central Eurasia would immediately anticipate that these transects would reveal a relatively sharp break in allele frequencies. True, there are intermediate populations between the two end points, in Nepal, and on the fringes of India’s northeastern states. But clearly about halfway through the southwest-northeast transect you’ll see a rapid shift in allele frequencies. The blue transect is different, insofar as the change occurs very near its eastern pole. In Bengal, 85% of the length of the transect from its western terminus, the populations will still be far closer genetically to those on the western pole than those just to the east!