Ask a Protestant Christian

Status
Not open for further replies.
If aborted babies go to heaven why are you against it?

Isn't heaven the end-goal of everyone?

First of all, I don't actually know aborted babies go to Heaven. I was speculating. In actuality, I think they'd have to believe, after death (And I think they'd be able to do so if they wished) in order to get into heaven.

Second of all, even if abortion were to give the children a free ticket to heaven, abortion to send the kids into heaven would be violating the system of free will God set up, and this is sinful.
 
Typical Catholic response. While the Bible does condemn gluttony, it does not clearly state exactly what this means. I would ask you don't bring Catholic dogma into "Ask a Protestant" please.

And this kind of post just leaves a way to judge other people. While eating expensive food may not be the best option, it is NOT specifically condemned, and so is between a given person and God.

All of those forms of gluttony are mentioned in the bible.

Laute:
Numbers 11:4 said:
And the mixt multitude that was among them fell a lusting: and the children of Israel also wept again, and said, Who shall give us flesh to eat?

God rained fowls for them to eat, but punished them 500 years later.

Nimis:
Ezekiel 16:49 said:
Behold, this was the iniquity of thy sister Sodom, pride, fulness of bread, and abundance of idleness was in her and in her daughters, neither did she strengthen the hand of the poor and needy.

Studiose: Two sons of Eli the high priest made the sacrificial meat to be cooked in one manner rather than another. They were met with death. (1 Samuel 4:11)

Praepropere:

1 Samuel 14:29 said:
Then Jonathan said, "My father has troubled the land. See how my eyes have become bright because I tasted a little of this honey.

His father Saul commanded no food to be taken before the evening.

Ardenter:

Genesis 25:30 said:
and Esau said to Jacob, "Please let me have a swallow of that red stuff there, for I am famished." Therefore his name was called [a]Edom.

His punishment was that he found no place for repentance.

It's not my fault that capitalist civilization today are bastions of hedonistic sin. Your denial of these sins is just an excuse to keep on sinning, much like the denial of liberals that fornication and homosexuality are sins are excuses to keep on sinning.
 
I would ask you don't bring Catholic dogma into "Ask a Protestant" please.

perhaps Catholics wouldn't "bring catholic dogma" onto this thread if you didn't do the same in regards to whatever variant of protestantism you adhere too on the Ask a Catholic thread.

Perhaps practicising the same as you preach instead of reeking of hypocrisy would prevent such intrusions onto the ask a protestant thread. (It is difficult not to at the best of times).
 
Submission is not barbaric at all. In fact marriages that do follow the biblical pattern of the father as the head of the house are far happier.
Right, yesterday we just celebrated the 50th anniversary of my maternal grandparents and my grandfather makes no major decisions without consulting my grandmother.

Man is the head of the family, woman the neck that turns the head
-Chinese proverb
Is abortion a sin to protestants?

not all Protestants hold the slaughter of the unborn as a sin
 
If people are in power because god wants them to be (as Paul implies), then what do you think of pro-democratic revolutions? Isn't such rebellion un-Biblical?
 
If people are in power because god wants them to be (as Paul implies), then what do you think of pro-democratic revolutions? Isn't such rebellion un-Biblical?
If they succeed, then God wanted them to succeed. If they fail, then God wanted them to fail.
 
This thread still needs a title-change, but "Ask Domination" is verging on being a personal thread.

As you're so fond of quoting, Paul says that ALL scripture is God-breathed. The Qur'an was apparently sent to Earth by Allah (God), so is that not inerrant and unquestionable?

However, questions about Islam aside, if ALL scripture is God-breathed, so is the Apocrypha. It is considered deuterocanonical, but it is most certainly ancient religious literature of the Christian faith and should qualify definitely.
 
So why does god want brutal dictators in power?
Many reasons. For one, brutal persecution of Christians allows them to exercise their virtue (and if a dictator doesn't persecute Christians, then he isn't that brutal in the first place).
 
Submission is not barbaric at all. In fact marriages that do follow the biblical pattern of the father as the head of the house are far happier.

I know such families and, no, no it's really is not the case. No. I mean, it's wrong. Just wrong.
 
Why does God want cuts in tax rates for high income earners and capital gains?

This is verging on political discussion, but lets just say, I don't claim to speak for God. IMO the Bible clearly bans abortion and it at least theoretically supports Capital Punishment, but other than that, Christians can take any position and be valid, and even on Capital Punishment I know many Christians who totally reject it.



God rained fowls for them to eat, but punished them 500 years later.

This was not an issue of eating fowl being a sin (It wasn't) but greed and unwillingness to be satisfied with what God provided for him.




Studiose: Two sons of Eli the high priest made the sacrificial meat to be cooked in one manner rather than another. They were met with death. (1 Samuel 4:11)

Because there were specific laws on how to cook the meat.





His father Saul commanded no food to be taken before the evening.

And, as the Bible is clear on, Saul's command in this instance was wicked.
Ardenter:



His punishment was that he found no place for repentance.

First of all, I don't agree with that. Esau's punishment was loss of his birthright, NOT his "Place in Repentance." Esau was unsaved because he did not REPENT of his sin, not because he sold his birthright....

perhaps Catholics wouldn't "bring catholic dogma" onto this thread if you didn't do the same in regards to whatever variant of protestantism you adhere too on the Ask a Catholic thread.

Perhaps practicising the same as you preach instead of reeking of hypocrisy would prevent such intrusions onto the ask a protestant thread. (It is difficult not to at the best of times).

If I have done this, I apologize, though I do not recall to doing so.

Right, yesterday we just celebrated the 50th anniversary of my maternal grandparents and my grandfather makes no major decisions without consulting my grandmother.

Man is the head of the family, woman the neck that turns the head
-Chinese proverb

Interesting and I agree.


not all Protestants hold the slaughter of the unborn as a sin

Sadly this is true.

If people are in power because god wants them to be (as Paul implies), then what do you think of pro-democratic revolutions? Isn't such rebellion un-Biblical?

I don't think so necessarily, though some Christians disagree with me. While I agree that in general we should obey our government, I also think "For everything there is a season" applies to fighting and revolution as well. Every Christian must consult their own conscience and the Lord God and make up their own mind.

This thread still needs a title-change, but "Ask Domination" is verging on being a personal thread.

Not really.

As you're so fond of quoting, Paul says that ALL scripture is God-breathed. The Qur'an was apparently sent to Earth by Allah (God), so is that not inerrant and unquestionable?

APPARENTLY is the key word. It was not valid Scripture.

However, questions about Islam aside, if ALL scripture is God-breathed, so is the Apocrypha. It is considered deuterocanonical, but it is most certainly ancient religious literature of the Christian faith and should qualify definitely.

The fact that it is deuterocanon is considered by most Protestants as evidence that it isn't Scripture.

That said, these questions are better suited for Plotinus. I don't know everything about the history of my faith. In Ask a Theologian I'm sure you'd get a better response.
 
Do you find yourself retaining disturbing amounts of VeggieTales knowledge from your childhood?

It would be Patch the Pirate for me. I was an adult when the Veggies appeared.

Was that seriously from a VeggieTales thing? That disturbs me, if so. Firstly, it sounds like a horrible way to describe proper relationships between men and women. Secondly, it is only adding to the epidemic of run-on sentences in grade schools.

That is the closest I can do "as" a lawer.:mischief:
 
I'm not disagreeing with your interpretation, Domination, but we have precisely as much proof that the Bible is God-breathed as we do that the Qur'an was given to Muhammed* by the Archangel Gabriel, i.e. they tell us so within their own pages.
 
I'm not disagreeing with your interpretation, Domination, but we have precisely as much proof that the Bible is God-breathed as we do that the Qur'an was given to Muhammed* by the Archangel Gabriel, i.e. they tell us so within their own pages.

Well, the thing is, as a Christian I accept the Bible. I'm not a Muslim so I don't accept the Qur'an.

The Apocrypha point was valid, but I don't believe it was ever intended as Scripture. That doesn't mean there aren't truths you can take out of them, they just aren't inspired Scripture.
 
Reassure a Protestant Christian (after having read his sig): My aim never is to convince anyone their religion is falsch.
 
OT believers as opposed to the NT believers.
 
Is the musical "Jesus Christ Superstar" sacrilege?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom