Deport bombers of families?

[Hitro]

So I would be interested to hear who proposed that after all.

 

[Hamlet]

Originally posted by Hitro
So I would be interested to hear who proposed that after all.

Benjamin Netenyahu is my guess.

 

[Graeme the mad]

I believe against it for both reasons expressed in your poll.
Im glad to see some Israelis against it - would you punish everyone who commits a crime's family - if your son/father/mother etc commited a crime would you think its fair to be sent to prison for it and would you not feel you wanted revenge against the people who sent you to jail for what I beliee you will see as an injustice

Simon you strike me as an intelligent person - do you really believe this is a good policy or are you 'in charachter'

 

[Simon Darkshade]

Certainly I believe that this is good policy.
No, this is not part of any character. I honestly believe in what I say, not just in this thread, but in many, many others.

You must defeat the enemy.
In doing so, you can't be nice, and humane, and coddling. You must exercise force, and harshness.

One agrees with quite a lot of what Benjamin Netanyahu writes and says; he is an astute, experienced commentator with the right ideas and the will to do them. The time has come for drastic solutions to drastic problems...

 

[philippe]

simon let say you are a palestine man that is 20 years old.your spycho brother does a suicide attack.you are now suddenly deported.
And then you will say to your friends about the cruel deeds the israeli has done.its a chain and with your really (sorry to say this) UNREALISTIc, UNDEMOCRATIC and BULLSH!t argument you will only spread more hate.
I think you would just prefer to nuke them all....

 

[Graeme the mad]

I agree completley with phillipe (though not his grammar or spelling)

It perpetuates hate as has been demonstrated time and time again throughout history.

 

[Sh3kel]

I believe against it for both reasons expressed in your poll.
Im glad to see some Israelis against it but Sh3Kel is really beginning to worry me - would you punish everyone who commits a crime's family - if your son/father/mother etc commited a crime would you think its fair to be sent to prison for it and would you not feel you wanted revenge against the people who sent you to jail for what I beliee you will see as an injustice

Simon you strike me as an intelligent person - do you really believe this is a good policy or are you 'in charachter'

I didn't even vote and already you're making me look like a facist warpig. Thanks.

 

[G-Man]

Originally posted by IceBlaZe
The British forces managed to keep their triggers down most of the time in N.I., how come our army is so fast on the trigger?

I'm just guessing but maybe it's because in N.I. there aren't thousands of people with machine guns and RPGs and the British don't have to get out of there to allow militants a chance to rearm each time.
Just to remind you - the last time the british dealt with the Palestinians they sent spitfires to shoot Palestinians who got out of their cities, fearing these Palestinians might go and blast one of their police stations or set fire to a jewish town.



"You do not punish the innocent party, who have no link to the crime"

They got money from the crime, therefore they're related and if they accepted the money (and I don't think any of these families didn't) they're no longer innocent. Also, most of these families called other Palestinians to do the same. Incitment (spelling) to murder is a crime.

 

[Graeme the mad]

OMG - SORRY SORRY SORRY

I apologise to Sh3kel and can only say that my own biased attitude caused me to say that - I thought he posted something for it - ermm that was really stupid of me and I apologsie to you unreservadely Sh3Kel

I realsie this dont make up for it

 

[Adebisi]

edited (...)

 

[IceBlaZe]

So anyone who won't deport the suicide bombers families is also against the American A-Bomb or the Bombing of Drezden?

 

[Hitro]

I am at least. Fighting an enemy shouldn't include becoming like that enemy.

 

[IceBlaZe]

Good old Hitro

 

[Hitro]

Originally posted by IceBlaZe
Good old Hitro

Spammer!

So what exactly do you want to say? What do you support now?

 

[IceBlaZe]

I support me, moi and myself.

Truly, I don't think there is justification to deport families of suicide bombers. It's unhumane.
Same reason I won't vote for the FZP.

 

[Greadius]

Minor curiosity here... is Israel deporting them from uncontested (well, as uncontested as it can be) Israeli territory or from the West Bank or Gaza. If they are in Israel proper and not Israeli citizens, Israel has the soverign right to deport them for any reason they see fit, or no reason at all.

 

[RedWolf]

Originally posted by IceBlaZe


There have been many other cases of IDF soldiers blatantly shooting civilians, when no militant is around.
IDF Soldiers easy on the trigger, is no rare.
Should we now deport the families of those soldiers?
Not only that, the IDF rarely does anything about soldiers blatantly killing palestinian civilians.

The British forces managed to keep their triggers down most of the time in N.I., how come our army is so fast on the trigger?

IceBlaze,

I can never quite figure you out - some days you seem like such a hard liner - other days you hold opinions close to my own (that article you posted hits the nail on the head so well).

I hope this isn't taken as derogatory - I actually have a great deal of respect for your ability to see both sides of the issue.

 

[amadeus]

Anyone that pledges allegiance to the Palestinian Authority, Hamas, etc, should be immediately forced to leave the country. No matter how you try and slice it, free speech isn't worth being blown up for.

 

[FearlessLeader2]

I am of the opinion that anyone who knowingly profits from a criminal act is a criminal, and should be treated as such. If the family of a homicide bomber receives money, and accepts it, it is an accesory to every murder the homicide bomber committed, and thereby liable for prosecution.

Given the above, I say, don't deport the families, arrest, try, and imprison them instead.

 

[Zarn]

You should not deport the families of the criminals. It is just plain wrong. Thank God, most of you agree. There has to be a way to discourage suicide bombings. I'm sure the Isreali government is really thinking about it though.