None Shall Pass 3 [Game Thread]

[Snerk]

Well it wasn't like one of our options on D1 was to throw the ring into mt. doom. The ring had to go to someone. Abstain votes are still scummy.

 

[landlubber]

Has Pouter publicly claimed anything at all about his role? Maybe it's had no effect on him because he's SW.

 

[Kennigit]

has he claimed SW?

 

[Arakhor]

Well it wasn't like one of our options on D1 was to throw the ring into mt. doom. The ring had to go to someone. Abstain votes are still scummy.

By that argument, voting for anybody who wasn't one of the three main people in the lead was also scummy. I could have self-voted at that stage and still made no effect on the result, yet that would have been fine?

 

[Pouter Pigeon]

RE: The ring conversation, I am indeed SW, and I still don't know what the ring does at all. My assumption is that it has some sort of passive power that I'm unaware of (bulletproof, maybe? I don't know...) but I suppose it could have no effect on me due to faction...I wish I had something more interesting to say about it. I wasn't told that I could target anybody or activate it, but I haven't tried either...my concern is that if it has a targeted ability, and I try to use it on somebody it will be some kind of attack, which I wouldn't want to do unless I had a lot more info to go on. I also haven't tried giving it away, but I don't see any benefit of doing so.

 

[Snerk]

By that argument, voting for anybody who wasn't one of the three main people in the lead was also scummy. I could have self-voted at that stage and still made no effect on the result, yet that would have been fine?

The more votes the better I say. Abstaining leaves less to analyse.

@PP: keep it secret, keep it safe!

 

[Lohrenswald]

can you elaborate?

This is a good lead for today or tomorrow

Do you think it was the mafia's choice that there was only one kill this night?

 

[spaceman98]

Spaceman thought that it was odd that, way back on Day One, I didn't want anyone to get the Ring. Let's hope that my paranoia was not justified, eh?

Well the thing is, there's basically no way to prevent SOMEONE from getting the ring with the options we are given

Do you think it was the mafia's choice that there was only one kill this night?

Probably not, no.

We have one kill (Cuth), and one failed kill accounted for (Visor)

That still leaves a third kill.

Arakhor was blocked tonight. If Martin was also blocked, that makes both of them strong candidates for the lynch tomorrow, though I will point out that blockers aren't completely reliable (source: Ciertako): Doctors or bulletproof townies can also explain this result.

 

[Arakhor]

Well, if you start lynching people based on the lack of a regular number of kills each night, that's just asking for the mafia to start messing with the town.

 

[Lohrenswald]

Probably not, no.

We have one kill (Cuth), and one failed kill accounted for (Visor)

That still leaves a third kill.

Arakhor was blocked tonight. If Martin was also blocked, that makes both of them strong candidates for the lynch tomorrow, though I will point out that blockers aren't completely reliable (source: Ciertako): Doctors or bulletproof townies can also explain this result.

mhm mhm

 

[spaceman98]

Well, if you start lynching people based on the lack of a regular number of kills each night, that's just asking for the mafia to start messing with the town.

Yes, but that doesn't invalidate tonight's data

 

[spaceman98]

Arakhor or Martin to hang tomorrow.

Martin also didn't reveal his own block, forcing the blocker (or an ally of the blocker) to reveal it in thread, thus exposing them. So right now both Martin and Arakhor are equally scummy in my eyes. Martin possibly moreso

 

[dcmort93]

Arakhor or Martin to hang tomorrow.

Martin also didn't reveal his own block, forcing the blocker (or an ally of the blocker) to reveal it in thread, thus exposing them. So right now both Martin and Arakhor are equally scummy in my eyes. Martin possibly moreso

My money's on ML, but either would make decent vig targets tonight.

Hint hint

 

[Zack]

Tally:

Spoiler :

17 Jarrema (Visorslash, spaceman98, dcmort93, azzaman333, Snerk, Newyn, johnhughthom, Legato Endless, Kennigit, Pouter Pigeon, landlubber, Xym, Al Sipsclar, remake20, MartinLuther, Sprig, KingMorgan)

2 MartinLuther (Lohrenswald, Arakhor)

1 Visorslash (Jarrema)

----

Posting, Invalid Vote: Internet Flea

[TIMER=10/17/2015 11:00 PM CDT; Day Four Over]tunnel snakes rule[/TIMER]

 

[Visorslash]

The potentially hilarious thing about this game, is that last one I said that Han Solo was a good cover role for scum when everyone was calling me scum for being Bail Organa because that was 'obviously' a cover role.

Han Solo ATM currently has a very real chance of being scum this game.

 

[Internet Flea]

I'm hoping it turns out Gandalf the White is a cover role for Gandalf the Grey.

Almost fully caught up now, so I can actually make an informed decision.

*deep breath*

Vote: Newyn. On principle.

 

[Zack]

And Internet Flea's vote turns it into a nail-biting 17-2-1-1.

 

[Zack]

Final Tally:

Spoiler :

17 Jarrema (Visorslash, spaceman98, dcmort93, azzaman333, Snerk, Newyn, johnhughthom, Legato Endless, Kennigit, Pouter Pigeon, landlubber, Xym, Al Sipsclar, remake20, MartinLuther, Sprig, KingMorgan)

2 MartinLuther (Lohrenswald, Arakhor)

1 Newyn (Internet Flea)
1 Visorslash (Jarrema)

 

[Zack]

Day Four

"Jarrema, do you have a defense prepared?"

Jarrema nods his head and clears his throat.

> be me

> excited af about killing enemies

> working for elrond cuz all sw are racists

> will have my revenge

> let's do this elrond me and you

> i was sat at home watching lotr marathon when elrond ring

> 'i am kill'

> 'no'

> i will do it myself buddy elrond

> ur memory lives on glorious leader

> i can do this

> mfw i immediately die

> mfw i have no face

Jarrema ends his speech and accepts death.

Spoiler :

Jarrema was Gandalf!

Spoiler :

Jarrema was actually Lurtz, a member of the Lord of the Rings Mafia!

Spoiler :

The Lord of the Rings Mafia has been eliminated!

It is now Night Four.

[TIMER=10/18/2015 11:00 PM CDT; Night Four Over]tunnel snakes rule[/TIMER]



Alive:

20 / 30

Al Sipsclar
Arakhor
azzaman333
dcmort93
Internet Flea
johnhughthom
Kennigit
KingMorgan
landlubber
Legato Endless
Lohrenswald
MartinLuther
Newyn
Pouter Pigeon
remake20
Snerk
spaceman98
Sprig
Visorslash
Xym


Dead:

10 / 30

classical_hero - Éowyn
JohannaK - Sauron
Takhisis - Boromir
BSmith1068 - Jango Fett
Autolycus - Arwen
choxorn - Palpatine
Riedquat - C-3PO
robbiecon - Elrond
Cuthillius - Saruman
Jarrema - Lurtz​

 

[Visorslash]

You need to update the alive list, AA and VGL are still in there instead of remake and JHT.

Also nice writeup.