Call me mercenary if you like, but if everyone agreed to split it evenly (either three ways or five ways), then that's what you should do. If your sister is actually hinting that she wants you to pay 40% or so and they pay the other 60% between the four of them, then perhaps she should say that directly.
That's the thing about indirect human discourse, I am often slow at picking it up and/or even detecting it. In this case I am going to follow your advice and go with what was agreed on, but also try to go a bit out of my way to help out more than I was going to (with the celebrations, anything related, etc.). That way if one of my sisters is upset at me, at least they won't see me slacking and will see the opposite, which would help. And if they're not upset then ah well, I'll just look like a boss to everyone there.
I don't think I ever said you should pay more than your fair share (1/5 if splitting it 5 ways, or 1/3 if splitting it 3 ways). I explained what was customary, but also mentioned that it's often done as a way of avoiding arguments or just including the "other" person for appearances' sake.
See, that I would completely understand! If my brothers in law were not really going in on the gift and it was just for show, so that their names could be in the card we give my dad, then I would be perfectly happy to split everything 3 ways. But that's just not what's happening, both my brothers in law are going to be at this party, and the gift to my dad is going to be presented as a gitt from all 5 of us. We are all probably going to give my dad equal hugs and so on.
I can see the situation playing out a bit differently if this was some co-worker and the husband was just written in as a "well he's my husband so of course the gift is from both of us even though he doesn't really know you" kind of way. That would make sense to me as an easy to determine 3 way split.
Valka D'Ur said:
I don't think you're cheap, and never said so (sorry if that wasn't clear in my earlier posts)
Sorry no, I didn't mean you. I didn't want to name any names but I that's just the "gist" I seemed to be getting at the time in terms of the general response.
Valka D'Ur said:
it sounds like your family is really close, and that's nice to hear.
I guess we went through a lot together and there is just a lot of respect for our parents from the 3 of us. They did a lot for us, and my parents are in turn proud of us and glad we're doing well. They sacrificed their lives for this very reason so they're happy everything worked out for everyone. We started at the bottom and now we're here, and we didn't do that by not being close, so being close just makes sense to us. Plus we're European and still think like that, and family is just important and that's that.
Takhisis said:
Oh, come on… you aren't familiar with the meme about women being the root of all evil because they cost work and money, etc. etc.?
I guess I'm sensitive about being seen as "cheap", TIL
Women can be expensive, but so can men. And all the other genders. And probably dogs and other pets.