dissolution of the Turkish State is a long running theme of mine , but it happens to be a constant of the world politics and much relevant as of today ; for while it seems so much against the flow of history and what must happen in the the interests of all mankind , yours idiotly has a point . That there will be no 'stan , not simply because there isn't but the Kurdish "Feodalism" and whatnot has no place and no calls of "injustice" on it . No need to accomodate the clan structure as well , now that it's the single constant in the bloody disasters of the last decades of the Republic as well .
disjointed it will seem , but take any single Turkish TV series about the "East" . It will unvariably involve an "Ağa" , some clan leader that owns a mini palace , a few villages to support the kinda opulent life style and some beautiful love interest , a noble daughter or maybe some poor villager detested by her mother-in-law for her lack of ancestry . Or most usually a blonde from the West of the country and they fell in love in university or a similarly modern set-up because the ağa is a most modern guy however trapped he might be in the traditions of yore . Kemal's Republic broke most of the such stuff in the rest of the country ; many would love a return to such but none of the wanna be feodals have the clout of the Kurds . Because , let me see , if they are hurt somehow , they might rebel ... Enter TV series that only aim to popularize them , because their real life counterparts tend to be dudes who like to show off their chest hair as they walk their oxygenized blondes to the jewelry shops . Sunglasses , a pistol at the back of the trousers and huge anger at his blonde and you as she finds you extremely laughable , a freakshow in the streets and this hurts the dude's code of "honour" : A woman that laughs in the streets is a wh_re . Or at least without his permission . Expect a mighty hit by the shoulder as he passes by ; especially in some Grand Bazaar where he is known as the local drug dealer . Of course not every single person born into such a world are criminals or basically bad people and all that . But the New Turkey needs them loved and that results in a string of popular shows . One of the sets , a grand house becomes famous , bus tours begin . And at least one case of people clustering at the bus terminal of the area , liking some "tourist" teenager and offering the current equivalent 70 000 odd US dollars to the family on the spot . They will leave the girl there and will not contact her ever again ... (Now that she would attempt to raise trouble when her "husband" replaced her in 5 years time .)
ı have had almost 10 years here ; ı trust people will not see this as mere propaganda on some stuff . Because it pertains to the general trend of the country where the "Westerners" themselves want to be become feodals -after the total fall of the Republic ; so , it's not entirely the fault of the "Easterners" ... However dysfunctional Turkish Parliaments may be , they never fail to increase the salaries of MPs and there was this proposal to allow weapon permits to the extented families of election winners and naturally diplomatic passports to raise them above the masses ; ı think that took a foreign intervention as it was too "early" . The foreign control is at times spectacular . The Ağa figure is long a staple of Turkish film industry ; back in the days when there was a "chance" that Left could win elections , it was either totally bad or sweetly ridiculed . With all movie people being Leftist and stuff , with the Saudis being still in the Stone Age and preferring their proxies shun the "idolatry" of pictures of all kind . Hence the village owner becomes a proper target . You know , the Right Wing Goverments buying the vote real cheap ; if his authority is weakened the Ağa might vote whatever he want but plurality would go to Left ... Some of the best of such lampooning belongs toŞener Şen who has also played the first "humanization" of such a character in "Züğürt Ağa" - as far as ı know . A tragic figure if you will , born noble despite his father is a senile nymphomaniac , actually tries to care for his villagers and gets robbed by them , tries to work honestly and gets robbed by the Westerners and so on , with a comedy that rarely fails . Filmed in the 80s and ı sincerely doubt it could be done today with a suggestion that a "Sheik" , (the religious opinion leader of the area) could refuse to lead the prayers for rain . Because the money offered by the Ağa was not good enough . But forced by the blackmail of the Ağa that the Sheik and the senile nymphomaniac used to rape village girls together in their youth . This former singer of Kurdish origins has done so indeed , striking against the sheiks recently ; but he is Kurdish in a country that aims to eradicate "Turk" out of anything . Kinda doesn't count when America needs to prove despite all the failings the future belongs to some people , while some other people did not even bother to resist . K is good , T is bad , if too confusing . Still , the singer has been given some hell .
now that we are not to doubt the "Muslimness" of the Kurdish feodals . The historical narrative now says Anatolia became Turkish as a coalition effort of the Selçuks, Arabs and Kurds . The art / science of History requires evidence and all the trappings of Civilization that developed over the last 5000 years . My word against established "facts" ? That r16 said so will be scientific proof of something happening that way ; as soon as the first starship arrives in orbit and starts the orbital bombardment ; but it's entirely BS ... That it wasn't 50 000 Turks but an alliance of 40 000 reinforced by 10 000 Kurds and Arabs . "That Turkified Anatolia" . As per the Roman tradition Byzantium would depend on the wealth of the East to reinforce its West , but Arabs like Halid bin Velid had cut off the best from the rule of Konstantinoplis , for 3 centuries . Through the Christian Middle East opting to side with their ethnic cousins from Mekke . If Arabs and Kurds were that great "Muslims" they would have done it on their own . Not for the lack of trying , too , now that some guy who physically saw the Prophet when young is buried in Istanbul , where he died during some siege in his old age ...
the answer is in that Turks were not that great "Muslims" ... Any Arab historian will give you a long elaborate rant on how how the Arab Greatness ended with the employment of Turkic mercenaries who corrupted the rule ; Qatar's Al Crusading has a 4 hours long documentary on it . With not a single reference to how the entire pre-Islam Arab world as it is now embraced the idea that the Roman rule was a good thing but by now the Romans were simply impostors who had betrayed the Christian ideals and Allah Had Chosen Muhammed to bring back the Truth . And that was why in less than a Century "Islam" had reached to Spain and breached into India and yet got stuck at the fringes of Anatolia and forced back from Poitiers and did not even attempt a rematch with the Chinese . Order of the law in all three cases : Franks claiming to be the heir to the Western Rome , Byzantium being the very Eastern and Chinese would possibly dismiss Rome all together ; in the good old days of CFC this is where there would be the chorus of Zheng He ! Al Crusading also entirely dismisses how the Arab Golden Age's military machine was fueled by plunder , even if this was valid for everybody back then and Arabs like spent a century to pacify pagan Turkic states , with kinda no honour , reducing the peoples to vassals just like many other empires had done to many other peoples for millennia by then . Like denying an Islamic identity to avoid seeing them as equals , but enforcing it all the same . Not even the toppling of the Umeyyads was any help ; utterly sharpening the Arab "intelligentsia" by 1070 , when the Selçuks had "unjustly" had themselves crowned as Sultans for about 15 years and intolerably using Turkish to conduct the affairs of the State . Real history books make a point of Arab conquerors remaining Arabs instead of adapting the local languages and become "locals" just as Mongols were to transform themselves much later .
this is how that Roman Diyojen forced a war on the Alparslan , one the Sultan didn't want , practically begged not to . Byzantium's victory was assured : The hated Turkic rule would crumble , Christian Arabs would certainly meet their Liberators with flowers . While the Arab intelligentsia was expecting a return to glory days , Iranians were already promised independence from Islam and in an era when the amount of foodstuff really determined the power of a country , all the Muslims in Mesopotamia would be given a 1258 . The Greek and Armenian Churches never duke it out in the open , but it was especially tough on the smarter Arabs : That epic fail that has few parallels in human history ... ı doubt they ever teach it to all those thousands of Arab Princes .
ah yes , it wasn't the Kurds but the Armenians that "Turkified" Anatolia . As Selçuks took advantage of a war they hadn't seeked in the first place by following the advice of the "Iranian" visier to Alparslan . That the Selçuks were bringing back the Roman rule , you know , also adopting the phrase "Rumi" . That there wasn't much of a difference and ı use that as very "lightly" . It can can be gauged by the almost 800 years that didn't see much of an Armenian issue . Those guys had held the East for Byzantium for so long , they could have rebelled against Muslims , let alone not opposing in the first place throughout the 1070s . Did so only at the projected demise of the Turks with the ever imminent fall of the Ottomans at late 19th Century . It was naturally horrifying : The "tsunami" of the 7th Century could be explained by the "racial inferiority" of the subjects of Byzantium in the Middle East . It was now "Whites" surrendering to those horsebandits who were even despised by the Arabs . The first Global response ; naturally ending with the bloodbath of Kudüs 1096ish . Western Europeans killing all sorts of Middle Easterners because the return of Christian control to those lands would naturally benefit Byzantium , while no King in those days could be a real King without declaring himself as the true heir to Rome ... See , in 50 years Turkic pagans newly converted becoming the shield and sword . Article of Faith in Islam that Allah Will Protect His Religion , but no clarification of how , right ? Horsebandits finding a void to put up a state , gaining justication defending an entire region and expanding and expanding on the very same notions . Tell that to the Arab schemer of 1070s that it would take 6 centuries for the godless to be stopped and yet Islam would be a global phenomenon long after that and he would f_rt laughing , let alone wetting himself .
oh yes , Kurds didn't take the Ottomans to Vienna either . Nor did they ensure the victory of Sunni ideals over the Shia . As we have been told since 2011 or so , when the war to South , the Irresuction , looked like the assured destruction of the Syrian State , the liberation of "Kurdish" territories ( yellow in the current fashion of the day ) meaning pipelines to the Mediterrenean to be combined with oilfields to stolen from the Shia Iraq , guaranteed by American directed conspiracies against the now extinct Turkish Armed Forces . Which started , you know , like 4 years before the "unexpected" Arab Spring . And while it looks a sparkling human history , with a "nation" oppressed for thousand of years looking on the verge of freedom , some of the biggest shames of Turkish history invariably involves the very same Kurdish feodals . It's like shocking to discover the Kemalist Turkey was ever ready to talk of percentages : That once we were not entirely of Turkish stock , DNA , RNA and whatever passes "scientifically" . Indeed , with my blue eyes (which are insisted to be green by some) ı would never qualify to be Turkish in 1071 ; but the thing is who were Armenians becoming as they converted ? Or are we to believe the Kurds as staunchest ever defenders of Islam were like totally living in their "ancestral" lands and tolerated by the evilly Christian Byzantians for centuries ? Especially the mountains above the plains of the border areas ? Kurdish "Islamists" never fail to mention the seperatists are all Armenians , especially when Turks are around . Remember 800 years ? The Germans took over the Enverland after the leave of the Allies by November 1914 and could they live 8 months with the Armenians ? Apparently all that the New Turkey can find for the incessant attacks of the tribes in the East on the deported is a band of thieves that robbed the intellectuals arrested in Istanbul in the train station of Eskişehir ; and by the looks of it it was arranged to happen by the nembers of Ittihad - the party in charge at the time . To demoralize the Armenians on their way to exile in Syria as a standart prison brutality thing . ı don't know whether any of the intellectuals were murdered or raped or thrown off a cliff . Indeed , the coming of "real" Democracy to Turkey has been proven by Easterners bragging on TV that the evil Western missionaries taught arts and stuff to Armenians who then forgot their place , spoiled and all that . It was coming to them afterall . There is yet to be a single "brave" Kurdish , or for that matter Turkish historian to declare the single reason the East joined the Turkish War of Liberation was the fear that the "Ingilizler" (namely the victorious British) would investigate the heroic actions of 1915 .
oh yeah , there is the former ideologue of the almost racists who last week had a documentary and he did stress the war started as a defence against the Armenians but he is a fan of Kazım Karabekir . Do not expect to hear , at least any time soon , that Kemal obliged but drove a "hard" bargain . Multi-party , multi-ethnic democracy and 100% at that . With no allowance for Ağas to rape village girls , though logic dictated their wealth would give them an headstart in the Capitalism that would guide the country , with some serious tariffs and stuff to avoid the mistakes of Ottomans . And some assurances that the sons and daughters of the feodals given the best education possible to keep them "up and front" . It became multi-party , multi-ethnic Republic when the Circassians attempted to steal the Rebellion . Well , not exactly a fault of Kurdish Feodals but it kinda harks back to times past with this Circassion hero , second only to Kemal in the narrative of the day , refuses to join the Regular Army , because he was but a non-com in the Ottoman Army and even if if the Parliament could have made him a Colonel he would still be one of the bunch , while the Sultan could always "forgive" and make him a Pasha . The rank of Marshall to follow if he supressed the entire War of Liberation . The New Turkey strives hard to make him a hero of 1919-22 , despite the fact that he ended up wearing Greek Army uniforms . Thus Sultanate being planned to be abolished , disregarding whatever Kemal might have been thinking . He saw himself only as the commander of the Army and he had already a tough task ahead . Especially after accepting feodal demands that their kinsmen also covered for . Might have added a year to the struggle . Nobody actually cared for the Armenians (especially the civilized Christian countries) but the upheaval of the Great War was yet to settle and Kurdish chieftains feared "Peace" . Thus the stated aims of the War of Liberation included Musul . Despite the feeling that the British would have made love to each and every oil well if it wouldn't look so out of place . If it hadn't been so declared , the British might have been as willing to negotiate and enforce a Peace to Venizelos as the French were after the Arab Rebellions of 1920 . In 1922 Kemal was still not expecting the enlightened despot role when they abolished the Sultanate and kept the Caliphate ; Musul was still out of the borders and believe me , nobody had ever expected Kemal pull it out or coming this far ... It was reasonably the best to expect a negotiated peace , perhaps the Sevres allowances doubled and some presence in Istanbul . That's when the stuff began , practically everybody coveting a signal from the "Caliph" to get rid of Kemal or siding with Kemal if the signal looked unlikely to come . Despite the assurances and extensive explanations that he could be a great historic person in consideration of the possibility of checks and balances , the guy preferred to be a "Sultan" . Disregarding the resulting crisis might have reduced Turkey to the size of Byzantium of 1450 within a couple of years . Led Kemal to the Presidency and you are free not to believe what ı have told you just now . Musul was still there and right on time , those very people who were afraid of British rebelled in the name of Islam and weakened the legal case by 1926 . Could have taken some 5 years to hang every single feodal above the age of 15 , a decade or two to convince the villagers it was for the better . Kemal chose not to . 1923 like happens to be the 240th anniversary of Vienna and those years were practically never good , nor Kemal was an adrenaline freak or fighter for the sake of war . The 250th year was of course a little pompous here in Turkey only because it was the 10th Anniversary of the Republic . And it was one of hope . And not a single reference to 1683 , because the Nazis were starting to evict people and some of those professors who were convinced to come here were really good ...
oh , just hear the Kurds on how they were betrayed by the Kemalist stuff . They were not questioned on how many scalps they took from the deported , they were not asked to return the lands they took , only supposed to give up the captives if alive and let them go anywhere they wished . You know , because without Armenians there would be no Turkey to fight over . Promised citizenship and stuff , equality , whatever "Science" offered . Trains to schools to Medicine . Raping village girls was a "bonus" , a privilidge Man had abandoned long ago anyhow . Ankara could have taken Musul , by bayonet if necessary , because the fear of the Commies paralysed the Colonialist West , let alone a crisis of any sorts making way for a resurgent Germany and all those Kurds who rant every night on TV on how they were let down by Ankara over the years could each be some oil tycoon right now , if the grandfathers of their grandfathers had not preferred a tiny pouch of British gold back in the day . You can ever hear them on how they are superior to anyone because they heroically saved a couple of Armenians as the Ottomans were evilly genociding a whole race . They will not remember it at all , that they were pushing just 2 or 3 years ago . How the Arabs were worthless and pushovers and all the oilwells of Middle East awaited as the now extinct Turkish Army asked for permission to enter towns feverishly being fortified in 2014 or so . Ah , ı was so surprised at the time , ı was thinking Arabs were our brothers ? Casualties might have been 10 fold , but who cares ?
now that the seperatist fight has long benefitted the feodals anyhow . It can be exasperating at times to see the seperatist claims that Turkish schools failed to assimilate them . Right , because their grandfathers did every possible thing to avoid the existance of those schools and made it imperative that no justification could ever be given to "Centrifugal" stuff they brag they defeated evil Turkish schemes to make forget their culture and whatnot . You know instead of letting them to rot in the mountains with no nothing and their feodals would have actually preferred that to happen . No , they heroically discovered themselves , even if it was the idiotic Turkish Left that insisted they were really a 'ing seperate race , oppressed by the 'ing Turkish State so they should all go and vote Communist so that the otherwise utterly voteless Radical Left could establish a Workers' Paradise in the country . Nor one should ever forget the ever glorious the so called national intelligence service which went and established an armed seperatist organization under American supervision so that bloodshd would unite the majority of the country to never vote Communist so that the "Profits" would never be at risk . And never forget now extinct Turkish Armed Forces that in its last years of life supported an anti-war epic . Where the sexually impotent loudmouthed coward ethnically Turkish officer justifies all with racist theories between torturing the wounded Kurdish girl (the freedom fighter that could be captured only because the coward sniped at her) and trading curses on the wireless with her lover (the Doctor who heroically left university to join the righteous fight against Oppression) . In case you wonder , the cowardly Turkish officer gets it right at the end , the Kurdish hero is then shot in the back by the treacherous Turkish soldier hiding in the dark , we have some great shots about the idolatry of Atatürk and how the peoples of Anatolia are all brothers with their brown eyes , while the impotent coward naturally has an European complexion . And the pro-Turkish feelings of the audience are like covered by the shadow of the gun of the Kurdish hero , which is an M16 ... This proves it's all fault of America ... With like millions watching and proud of the country and Army and stuff ! Am pretty sure it would have blown George Orwell off his seat in the movie theater .
ah , the curse of us ; that there has never been a cap on the number of smarties . The Kurdish commoner of 1960s had no particular thing against the State . Despite the 101% readiness to be American puppets the Democrat Party years of 1950s were mostly a success story , especially in economy . While the commoner's father would be a conscript in the Army of 1940s where "writers" , those who could keep up with documentation the Military (inevitably produced mountains of) were comparatively rare and hence "valued" . The father would do anything necessary for the son to read and "save" at least himself . What happened ? The Left insisted the son was a "Kurd" while he was quite ready to accept "Turk" as an upper identity , becoming part of the larger society , perhaps becoming a State Official , perhaps a little store in the nearest town back at home : He knew he was a Kurd , you know , through being a Kurd . Why ? Because the Soviet Union was respecting the Minorities to build the Soviet Man ; insulting people as cavemen had not helped people to become good Communists afterall ! Living in ivory towers of their own , this of course didn't appear obvious to the Turkish Leftists . That the Kurdish commoner was more than willing to be part of society and the "introduction" could be skipped entirely . The son didn't need to hear that he lived in the dirt , he knew that already but there would be no let up in the "Enlightment" . In the heated and divided 60s this left the commoner at odds . Big cities have the schools the commoner needs to attend to save himself and they are lonely places . With Right with its barely disguised racists and the early versions of "Muslims" as the only alternative . As the Left gained power in accordance with the global trends , some brilliant too well read theoricians finally decided they had to have a guerilla war , you know , only because it was a fashionable thing to do and descended on the East . Che was still alive , ı think ... The fathers took one glance at the city boys and took their sons aside and asked what was going on . Then tried to reason with the city boys that they wanted no quarrel with the State , which was finally giving a chance for the commoners to save themselves . The city boys discovered the mountains were full of reactionaries .